Skip to Main Content

Shelter Island Real Estate Market

Housing
C-
Based on home values, property taxes, housing costs, local schools, and more.
Area Feel
Rural
Rent vs. Own
  • Rent
    14%
  • Own
    86%
Sponsored Mortgage Options for Shelter Island
Get Rates
  • $0 Lender Fee on Home Loans Limited Time Only
  • Biggest Home Loan Sale Ever. Low interest rates. Get a quote today!
Niche may be compensated by the third party lenders and others who place ads on the website. Niche is not a lender and does not endorse the products of these advertisers. Fees that Niche receives for ads do not affect the terms you may be offered by the lender you choose. There are many additional borrowing options available.

Real Estate Costs

Median Home Value
$844,200
National
$184,700
Home Values
  • <$50k
    0%
  • $50-$99k
    0%
  • $100-$199k
    0%
  • $200-$399k
    6%
  • $400-$749k
    29%
  • $750k+
    65%
Median Rent
$2,022
National
$949
Monthly Rent
  • <$500
    0%
  • $500-$999
    0%
  • $1,000-$1,499
    36%
  • $1,500-$1,999
    11%
  • $2,000+
    52%

More opinions are needed to display this poll.  Take our survey

Explore Real Estate in Similar Places
More
Homes in Shelter Island have a median value of $844,200. The median rent price in Shelter Island is $2,022 and most residents own their homes. Shelter Island is walkable.
Back to Full Profile