Skip to Main Content

2020 Safest School Districts in Suffolk CountyAbout this List

Explore the safest school districts serving your area. Ranking based on student and parent ratings of health and safety, area crime rates, and rates for expulsion, suspension, and school related arrests. Read more on how this ranking was calculated.

1 – 25 of 55
Safest Districts
55 results

  1. Port Jefferson Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Port Jefferson, NY
    • 7 reviews
    #1 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Port Jeff School district has been a blessing for me. All of the teachers are so supportive and very approachable if you have any questions. The classes are structured very well and you find yourself really well prepared academically. Since it is a small school, everyone knows everyone and its very easy to create long lasting relationships that will go well past high school.
    Read 7 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      Health & Safety
    • 3 Total Schools
    • 1,122 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  2. Cold Spring Harbor Central School District

    • School District
    • Cold Spring Harbor, NY
    • 12 reviews
    #2 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Sophomore: Cold Spring Harbor is a very good school district. The staff is excellent. The majority of the teachers at all levels of education are informative and empathetic. The variety of clubs and activities is decent for a fairly small district. The atmosphere is welcoming and most students are quite courteous. Even though there is a lack of diversity, relatively little prejudice and bigotry exists. The district prepares students well for college and further education, although students' workloads often become overwhelming and stressful. The emphasis on athletics sometimes overshadows other, much smaller programs, such as art and music. Overall, my experience in the district has been enjoyable.
    Read 12 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      Health & Safety
    • 4 Total Schools
    • 1,752 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  3. Southampton Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Southampton, NY
    • 12 reviews
    #3 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: Southampton was a perfect school for me growing up! The teachers put so much effort in building strong and close relationships with their students. They were always willing to work with students who were struggling if they asked for it. There were many classes offered between electives and AP classes. The sports were given many resources despite not being that great and the overall facilities are nice. The diverse student body led to a great experience. The only downsides were the clique nature of a small school which often caused drama because everyone knew everything about each other. Some areas of administration may also need help.
    Read 12 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      Health & Safety
    • 3 Total Schools
    • 1,650 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  4. Mount Sinai School District

    • School District
    • Mount Sinai, NY
    • 28 reviews
    #4 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: I had a decent experience at Mount Sinai. The district lacks diversity, and pours a lot of regard into sports. Only recently has there been attention on the Theatre and Arts programs. Not a huge variety of classes to take in terms of anything separate of gen eds. Lots of AP courses, though. But I will say in terms of education, we have some of the greatest educators in the state. They do a great job of preparing students for standardized tests and college!
    Read 28 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 3 Total Schools
    • 2,301 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  5. Westhampton Beach Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Westhampton Beach, NY
    • 15 reviews
    #5 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Westhampton Beach is a very safe and friendly children/ family environment/ school and town in general. The sports teams are very good and competitive, but also it gets the entire community to be involved to come out and support the teams. There are a lot of general community activities and involvement within the school community, the teachers are great and very helpful with almost anything you might need guidance with. The school is not very diverse, mainly Caucasian with other exceptional races. Westhampton is technologically advanced with tools, and resources students have available to them, including laptops. The theater and music programs are also amazing with great teachers to help future careers in music/ theater. Overall, it is a great school.
    Read 15 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 3 Total Schools
    • 1,807 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  6. Babylon Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Babylon, NY
    • 9 reviews
    #6 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: For being such a small school, Babylon offers many activities. Our community is supportive and the students are active!
    Read 9 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 3 Total Schools
    • 1,618 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  9. Bridgehampton Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Bridgehampton, NY
    • 1 review
    #7 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: It is a very small but very diverse school. I have been going here since kindergarten. The teachers really take an interest in you and care about you. They will help you in any way possible.
    Read 1 Review

    • B
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 1 Total Schools
    • 204 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  10. Harborfields Central School District

    • School District
    • Greenlawn, NY
    • 29 reviews
    #8 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: I enjoyed the overall atmosphere the school has created where the faculty encourages students to follow their dreams. Harborfields offers many programs and clubs for all students to be involved in something. For example, I had a great experience over my four years being on the Robotics team. In my Junior year we went all the way to the nationals and it was an awesome experience. I also feel the classes are challenging and the school curriculum truly prepares you for college.
    Read 29 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 4 Total Schools
    • 3,133 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  11. Smithtown Central School District

    • School District
    • Smithtown, NY
    • 45 reviews
    #9 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Over my past four years in the Smithtown Central School District I have experienced many things that have made it a wonderful experience. Throughout the past couple years I have made life-long friends and relationships through school and other school-related activities. Smithtown really provides one with a range of different activities for one to be involved in. Everyone will be able to find at least one thing that they will enjoy doing and make their experience memorable. Another fact about the school district is that it really prepares one for the real world and challenges one may face. The teachers are always there to help you by offering extra help and advice. Now, nothing is perfect so that is why this school district gets a four star rating, but the greatness of this school district definitely outweighs the minor setbacks of it.
    Read 45 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 12 Total Schools
    • 9,026 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  12. Southold Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Southold, NY
    • 6 reviews
    #10 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: Great place to go to school for the independent-minded. If you're a self-starter this place will be great. All of the kids get along and every one means the best!
    Read 6 Reviews

    • B
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 2 Total Schools
    • 767 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  13. Northport-East Northport Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Northport, NY
    • 24 reviews
    #11 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: I have had a very good experience at Northport High School. They are very arts oriented which played to my strengths. I was lucky enough to be able to take fashion design classes which helped me be prepared for getting into the college I have dreamed about, FIT. They also have other rigorous academic classes. There really seems to be something for everyone there!
    Read 24 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 9 Total Schools
    • 5,395 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  14. Islip Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Islip, NY
    • 4 reviews
    #12 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: Islip Union Free School District is truly an amazing place to learn! I was a student at Islip schools for my entire K-12 career and loved every minute of it. Not only are the teachers and the education fantastic, but the students and the Islip community are truly connected. I don't think i would be the confident, smart, and enduring young woman i am today without the help and support of this fantastic school district. They truly molded me and taught me to be the best that I could be!
    Read 4 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 5 Total Schools
    • 2,859 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  15. Commack Union Free School District

    • School District
    • East Northport, NY
    • 42 reviews
    #13 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Commack School District is a great place to learn. As a senior myself, I have traveled all throughout the district during my education journey. Our primary schools helped students learn the above and beyond subject basics. This continued into the intermediate schools where respect and responsibility became paramount. As we entered the middle school, our grade doubled in size meaning we had to learn how to cooperate with new people. Finally, high school has prepared me for college education and life in general. The teachers are also great in offering help and assistance. They will try their best to help you succeed in the best possible way.
    Read 42 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 8 Total Schools
    • 6,193 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  16. Three Village Central School District

    • School District
    • Stony Brook, NY
    • 19 reviews
    #14 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Three Village Central School District is a very solid, spirited school district that incorporates a strong yet equal balance between elevated academics and accelerated sports and clubs. Infused with great teachers, resources, and extracurriculars, this school district procures a wholesome package of what is desired in an ideal learning environment. Though diversity cannot necessarily be improved, I believe the food quality there can be improved upon and be more appetizing and appealing to students for consumption. Despite this, I believe Three Village is a great district to be in and also a great experience overall for any student who attends.
    Read 19 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 8 Total Schools
    • 6,171 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  17. South Huntington Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Huntington Station, NY
    • 18 reviews
    #15 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: Teachers, faculty and staff throughout the entirety of the school district devise their actions to creating a comfortable, natural, accepting environment with a primary focus on academic excellence. Going through this district is a unique experience that constantly promotes the appearance of a nostalgic state of mind when recanting upon unfathomable experiences. This community is based on unity to achieve instilled common distinction in a wide array of facets.
    Read 18 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 7 Total Schools
    • 6,011 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  18. Mattituck-Cutchogue Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Cutchogue, NY
    • 5 reviews
    #16 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: I grew up on the North Fork until I moved to Huntington going into sixth grade. There, I was just a number, engulfed by the thousands of other kids with needs just like mine. Moving back to Mattituck High School senior year, I recognized the effort and time they put into your individual education. It is more of a family than a school district.
    Read 5 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 2 Total Schools
    • 1,168 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  19. Elwood Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Greenlawn, NY
    • 10 reviews
    #17 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: All the teachers I've had were incredible. We're a very diversified school in Suffolk County, and we're also what's known as a Blue Ribbon School -- one of the best in the country! There's a good reason for that. The academics are amazing, I've never had a bad teacher in my entire 12 years of school. Our high school teams truly excel, and there is a lot of school spirit. Drugs and alcohol are not a huge problem as they are with many other schools in the country. Even the counselors and administration are very caring and concerned about the students. All in all, I've been very lucky to be in this school district!
    Read 10 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 4 Total Schools
    • 2,212 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  22. East Moriches Union Free School District

    • School District
    • East Moriches, NY
    • 1 review
    #18 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: From kindergarten to 8th grade, East Moriches School has prepared me for the rigors and difficulty that is high-school. And the choice of high school, though difficult during the end of 8th grade, ultimately prepares you for college decisions and everyday decisions as you age.
    Read 1 Review

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 2 Total Schools
    • 732 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  23. Sag Harbor Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Sag Harbor, NY
    • 2 reviews
    #19 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Parent: I have three children who have gone through the Sag Harbor school district. Each is very different, and they all had an excellent experience. A challenging academic environment, including the IB Diploma Program, prepared them well to get into top universities. The faculty truly cares about each student, and there is a wealth of clubs, art options and sports. It is like a private school with its small class sizes and attention to every student.
    Read 2 Reviews

    • B+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 2 Total Schools
    • 995 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  24. Bay Shore Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Bay Shore, NY
    • 28 reviews
    #20 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: I have enjoyed my time in Bay Shore, the community is warm and welcoming, and teachers do there best to help guide students on a path to success. Although, one thing I would like to see change is to have more diversity in higher level classes.Overall the district has a very diverse student body, which is wonderful for connecting with others and learning new points of view. However, what the school district can improve on is help students of color reach there full potential.
    Read 28 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 7 Total Schools
    • 6,067 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  25. East Hampton Union Free School District

    • School District
    • East Hampton, NY
    • 13 reviews
    #21 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Alum: Academics are very good and the environment was very safe. Greatest 4 years of my life! School has top of the line security including an on site police officer. The sports teams are also well supported by the school. The Arts department does well in incorporating different medians of art such as photography and sculpture.
    Read 13 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      Health & Safety
    • 3 Total Schools
    • 1,845 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  26. Sayville Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Sayville, NY
    • 14 reviews
    #22 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Throughout my experience as Sayville High School, I have made ever lasting friendships and memories. As my time at this school comes to a close, I find myself really appreciating everything it has to offer. From clubs to electives, Sayville High School has made me grow and mature into the young woman I am today. The football games bring together not just the whole school but the entire town! Sports, clubs, and academics are all mutually respected and everybody seems to get along. Teachers have left an eternal foot print on my heart. The support and motivation provided is incredible, and nobody ever feels alone here. At Sayville High School, there is no "popular" crowd and there is no "jocks", everybody's equal. Walking past people I rarely talk to and sharing a friendly smile with them is something that means the most to me. My school is one of the kindest and most safe schools anybody could attend. I could not ask for a better place to have had my education for these past few years!
    Read 14 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      Health & Safety
    • 5 Total Schools
    • 2,975 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  27. Kings Park Central School District

    • School District
    • Kings Park, NY
    • 26 reviews
    #23 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Kings Park is a close knit community that operates like an extended family. Small enough to know your neighbors well but big enough to fulfill all your needs. It's a very special high school. The students are great, the teachers care for each of their students and the administration is wonderful. I'm not just a student, but a student with a supportive extended family. When I stumbled, the teachers did all they could to get me back on track. When I needed extra help, every one of my teachers was available. As I began my college search, the Guidance Office gave me the education to pick wisely. I couldn't have done this without my KP High School family. If I was able to change anything it would be some type of requirement for students like myself considering an alternative high school be questioned by the Administration to challenge or explore why a particular student wants to go elsewhere. I will be forever thankful for my time at KP High School.
    Read 26 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      Health & Safety
    • 5 Total Schools
    • 3,209 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  28. Eastport-South Manor Central School District

    • School District
    • Manorville, NY
    • 25 reviews
    #24 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: Every social studies teacher is fun and interesting in their own way making for an exciting new approach to everyday class . The science teachers were all incredibly knowledgeable in there specific regent of science and very open to questions and assistance if you were falling behind.Math would be the only subject to complain about in our school some teachers rush through the curriculum to assure your ready for the regents in June and have ampule time to review but in doing so gloss over key aspects upon your first leaning that can make the rest of the course difficult. while some math teachers go very slow in going thru the massive course loads of some math in high school but in doing so don't leave proper time to review leading into either rushing the end of the course or cramming in last second. Our school has a very devout and courageous theater and arts programs they are always going on trips with the marching band or putting on plays in our schools wonderful theater.
    Read 25 Reviews

    • B
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      Health & Safety
    • 5 Total Schools
    • 3,384 Students
    View Nearby Homes

  29. Shelter Island Union Free School District

    • School District
    • Shelter Island, NY
    • 1 review
    #25 Safest School Districts in Suffolk County

    Senior: The teachers are very accessible and offer an excellent regimen for learning the coursework. Due to the district's smaller size, the teachers are prone to connect to the students and guide them if there were to be any obstacles to their educational success.
    Read 1 Review

    • B-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      Health & Safety
    • 1 Total Schools
    • 216 Students
    View Nearby Homes
  30. Sponsored

    Millbrook School

    • Private School
    • Millbrook, NY
    • 9-12
    • 42 reviews

    Parent: I'm the parent of two Millbrook students, and we are strongly considering the school for our third child. Why? Because each child is "known and needed" at Millbrook. They work enormously hard to understand who your child is, what makes them tick and what will help them become the best version of themselves. I have two very different kids who both found success at this school. While there are many areas of excellence at the school (gorgeous campus, thoughtful curriculum, wide variety of sports and arts options, terrific attention to college prep, warm community), I have to cite the superb faculty and school leadership. I can honestly say that they are inspiring, nurturing, responsive and determined to help my sons succeed. Simply put, my sons became better people by being around the world class human beings at Millbrook. My husband and I are so grateful!
    Read 42 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 317 Students
    • 4:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  34. Review Your School 
  35. Sponsored

    Diocese of Brooklyn

    • Catholic Diocese
    View Profile
  36. Sponsored

    Washington Episcopal School

    • Private School
    • Bethesda, MD
    • PK, K-8
    • 9 reviews

    Parent: We have 2 boys currently attending WES. One is in his 3rd year there and a 2nd grader and the younger is 2 months into his first year (kindergarten). Both love their school and the teachers; they can't wait to go to school every single day.

    I'm always surprised at how fast they learned to read and they're now writing stories at home...for fun! The school's focus on being kind, confident, and prepared is definitely the right direction and this mentality shows in each of their students. The parents with whom we interact are also very nice and some have become good friends. The administration staff is exceptional. It shows every day in every teacher and staff member. The head of school is out there every morning welcoming kids to school, helping with drop off, and greeting everyone by name.
    Read 9 Reviews

    • 290 Students
    • 4:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  • 1 of 3