Compare College Prep at Wisconsin Private High Schools

College Prep

94 results

University School of Milwaukee
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
PK, K-12
90 reviews
#1 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: My son recently finished prekindergarten at USM, and I cannot speak highly enough about the education he received. The growth and maturity he experienced over that first year was remarkable and was a joy for me and my husband to witness. Not only did he learn the fundamentals in letters and numbers, he learned how to be kind, patient, to try new things, to work through challenges, and to be confident.

His teachers happily fostered his interests and applied their years of experience and knowledge of best-practices to his education. Not only are USM's teachers exceptional, the school's campus and facilities are unmatched, as well as its commitment to safety.

I love how the school encourages meaningful collaborations between students of all ages, how it teaches and upholds the standards of its Common Trust, and how it supports and engages with parents. We were thrilled with the education our son received and look forward to continuing our USM journey!
Read 90 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1350 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
The Prairie School
Private School
Wind Point, WI
PK, K-12
65 reviews
#2 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: People think they can't afford it, but Prairie gives financial aid based on your income. My kids couldn't go there without it! We're just average income people so we had to make changes to get the best education for them. We were totally surprised, and I still find it hard to believe, that parents, teachers, and everyone there helps raise money for financial aid for the families who need it! We've had teachers who cared about our kids like family. Like every school, Prairie has issues and improvements can be made. But, I liked it right away because it teaches what we teach our kids at home…respect others and be a problem solver. THANK YOU to those who suggested we just visit and apply! PLEASE don't assume you can't afford it. That's what we thought, too and we are definitely not the only people of average income there. I hope more families in the area just go see Prairie and apply!
Read 65 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1330 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Madison Country Day School
Private School
Waunakee, WI
PK, K-12
20 reviews
#3 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: Our child, now in high school, has been at MCDS since Lower School and our overall experience has been strongly positive. The school has grown steadily over the past decade and yet no child falls between the cracks. The low faculty-to-student ratio is key to student success. Faculty are very dedicated to the students and communicate well with parents. The curriculum is challenging, but not excessively so. The range of students' abilities across subjects is broad, yet the common denominator is that all are aiming to do the best they can and succeed in college, be that at a large university or a small liberal arts college. The school also values character education, and the arts are not considered peripheral, but an essential part of the curriculum. The relative lack of racial diversity is offset by social and ethnic diversity, including an international outlook among many families.
Read 20 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1410 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart
Private School
Madison, WI
9-12
63 reviews
#4 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Going to Edgewood has been a memorable experience for me. It has been a mixed bag as to the specifics, but overall I would recommend at least shadowing the school if you think that you or your child will be a good fit there. A good fit for Edgewood is someone who is open to learning about faith, believes in the value of community service, kind but with thick skin. There are a lot of stereotypes about Edgewood, some true and some false. It's just something you have to learn to deal with as a student. YES NEW STADIUM!
Read 63 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1340 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Marquette University High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
174 reviews
#5 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Marquette University High School is an incredible place. As a Jesuit institution, they focus on the whole person: academic and faith life. This is the most important thing at Marquette. The academics are very challenging but they give you so much help and opportunities to help you get better grades. They have advising for you and I personal thought that helps a lot. They also have a center and after school program for those who are struggling with grades, assignments, and projects. All the staff at this school are always there for you and want to help you anyway that they can so that means you have someone on your side at all time.
Read 174 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Wayland Academy
Private School
Beaver Dam, WI
9-12
52 reviews
#6 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Niche User: Wayland Academy truly seemed like a great place from when I visited! I got to shadow a student during a Spring Open House. The boy's dorm "Wayland Hall" was very very nice. The admissions counselors and teachers seemed very helpful and the students all had strong connections and friendships with each other. The campus itself is really nice. Safety was really great with a gated campus along with card access to dorms and students have to sign in and out of the dorms if they want to leave. I have heard of their mentor program but I can't say much about it, as I never attended.
Read 52 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1240 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Divine Savior Holy Angels High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
216 reviews
#7 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I love the all-girls environment of the school. I feel comfortable sharing my ideas and growing intellectually without the stress of finding a boyfriend or dressing up. All girls are encouraged to explore their education and participate in leadership growth. All students, even shy and reserved girls, have a voice and actively participate in class. The school is also making a push to increase diversity by adding student-led discussions about social issues faced in their communities. I would highly recommend any female in Wisconsin who wants to further her academic persute to apply. I drive almost an hour to get to school and return home, but I believe is worth it for my education at Divine Savior Holy Angels High School.
Read 216 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1220 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
University Lake School
Private School
Hartland, WI
PK, K-12
48 reviews
#8 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: My 7th grade son was in a public school where it became uncool to be smart. His grades were dropping, he missed assignments, and had some experiences with bullying. At ULS he is in a small class where he gets more attention from teachers to help him with organization and staying on task. The other students are kind and care about their grades, so it is a good environment for him to excel. The school has a welcoming community and strong, hands-on approach to learning. It's been great for our son!
Read 48 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1290 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
North Cedar Academy
Private School
Ladysmith, WI
9-12
5 reviews
#9 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: My step-son is in his second year at NCA and we are so pleased with his maturity and the academic and social gains he has made since attending NCA. He is a part of the NCA - University of Wisconsin Eau Claire "Early Pathway" program and in his first semester alone this year he has completed 5 university classes at UW-Eau Claire at no cost to us! The school seems well managed and well run. It is always spotlessly clean we notice, the teachers are professional, kind and experienced (ours son's favorite is the GREAT music teacher he has at NCA), and the dormitory staff and coaching staff has been great to him. We could not be more pleased with the school, and the bonus is that our son (like all US students) attends tuition free!
Read 5 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
32 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Catholic Memorial High School
Private School
Waukesha, WI
9-12
116 reviews
#10 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: The first three years here have been the most amazing experience. I love coming here every day and how good the teachers are at preparing us for college. There are always lots of people here to put a smile on your face every day. The caring nature here as well as the faith connection is so amazing and I am very proud to be a Crusader! Also, the strong emphasis on the fact that this school is a living memorial to the members of the Waukesha community who serve and have served for our country. I am always very proud of what we stand for as a school.
Read 116 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1350 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Lawrence Seminary High School
Private School
Mount Calvary, WI
9-12
41 reviews
#11 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: My experience at St. lawrence Seminary was one of overwhelming change. I came in as a timid and rather strange freshman. That changed when I surrounded myself with the community and took active participation in classes. The catholic aspect of the school is incredibly satisfactory and the adademic aspect is of equal reagrd. The facilities are all clean and are routinely taken care of by not only the janitorical staff, but also by students. We were encouraged to take part in school clean-ups and ministry, exposing us to the world and the greater community. If there was one thing I would have to change about St. Lawrence Seminary, it would be the inclusion of college credits. The AP program is nearly nonexistant, and entering college I was slightly dissapointed to see none of my college level work pay off. Regardless, the school is fantastic, life-changing, and ultimately excellent in all fields related to academics and community.
Read 41 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1330 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Dominican High School
Private School
Whitefish Bay, WI
9-12
72 reviews
#12 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: For those parents and families that value an education that, in addition to very high academic expectations, places a premium on character development within a loving family atmosphere, look no further than Dominican High School. What makes this school more unique is that this private school fosters high, individually driven, academic achievements within a non-stressful atmosphere. No matter the student's background, academic gifts or challenges the atmoshpere is welcoming for the full student body. The supportive faculty and staff will not overlook those students that need extra academic support! My students are transfer students and within one week they felt not only acclimated, they felt a part of a large caring family.
Read 72 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1460 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Catholic Central High School
Private School
Burlington, WI
9-12
30 reviews
#13 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: All four of our children attended Catholic Central. Two went on to graduate from Marquette, one is currently at Edgewood College, and our youngest is wrapping up his senior year and plans to attend Edgewood as well. Catholic Central provides a diverse curriculum complimented by passionate teachers and small class sizes. This combination allows for plenty of attention for each student and engaging classes all year long. In addition to the academics, Catholic Central’s athletic programs are rich in tradition and focus on developing the entire individual, not just the athlete. If you are looking for a holistic education where your child can continuously explore their interests, Catholic Central is the place to be!
Read 30 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1430 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Notre Dame de la Baie Academy
Private School
Green Bay, WI
9-12
183 reviews
#14 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Notre Dame Academy is a great school with many people who truly strive to help the students achieve. The IB curriculum is excellent and encouraged. That being said, the school is very much catered to the "top" students rather than the bottom. This can be seen as a good thing for those top students, but anyone who truly struggles or has learning disabilities is in for a ride. Student services has amazing staff who are great with helping these students academically and personally, but there is a clear disconnect between their help and the teacher cooperation. Also, the college counselor is little to no help in the college admissions process, and it's an uphill climb to even get in a meeting (my class had almost no junior conferences due to her absences). However, the school did just get an additional person to help with this process, so hopefully that will be permanent. NDA has it's flaws, but what school doesn't? I have enjoyed my time and don't regret attending high school here.
Read 183 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Pius XI Catholic High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
196 reviews
#15 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: The caring atmosphere is quite pervasive. When you walk in the door you feel that sense of caring. The TAC Program is very important with today's issues. Each student is assigned to a teacher who helps them navigate the high school world. Those teachers are the student's counselor, advisor, advocate, and friend. The academic offerings are amazing. The broad areas of course selection is second to none. The students who graduate are able to get into many different schools. My daughter graduated from Pius and has become very successful!
Read 196 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1250 Average SAT
24 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Northeastern Wisconsin Lutheran High School
Private School
Green Bay, WI
9-12
19 reviews
#16 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: It’s a great environment to learn, grow in your faith, and create relationships with people. One thing I really enjoy is the teacher to student relationship. There are few students that go to the school, so the teachers get one on one time with the students and they really care about whether you succeed. Another thing I enjoyed was that everyone at the school is christian, which eliminates a lot of bullying and drama with the students. The school does a good job of stressing that every single person there is important and loved by God.
Read 19 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1430 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Xavier High School
Private School
Appleton, WI
PK, K-12
125 reviews
#17 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Freshman: I loved how nice everyone was toward me at Xavier High School. Previously coming from a public school, I had very little friends and was often bullied and shamed for my interests in science and the arts. At Xavier High School, I was instead praised for my interests and fond many pupils that share the same common goals. In fact, for the first time in my life, I had an abundant amount of friends to hang out with before, during, and after school. However, I am not enamored with all the Catholic views this school has to offer such as believing that women are inferior to their male counterparts as well as their belief that a woman does not have the right to terminate her own pregnancy.
Read 125 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1300 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Wisconsin Lutheran High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
259 reviews
#18 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Wisconsin Lutheran High School is an exceptional school for any student looking to challenge themselves academically, get involved in extra curricular activities, and be constantly enveloped in a Christian environment. Due to the versatility of the school and the willingness of the teacher and administration, I've been able to experience choir, basketball, STEM curriculum, student council, A/V club, book club, steel band, mission trips to Arizona and Zambia, the Civil Rights Tour, AP classes, and so much more! This school provides amazing opportunities for all of its students in academics, athletics, and fine arts. I'm glad to be able to call Wisco my home.
Read 259 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Eastbrook Academy
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
PK, K-12
38 reviews
#19 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I have been attending Eastbrook Academy for 7 years and this is a truly remarkable school! The academics are challenging and above average. The teachers also challenge each student to become their best self academically and professionally. Although there are not many clubs or sports, the many aspects such as the family oriented atmostsphere is hard to find anywhere else. During my last year it was remarkable to see the changes the Eastbrook made, especially those that students requested. Overall, Eastbrook Academy a unique school full of diversity, family, leaders, and hard working faculty and students.
Read 38 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1340 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Martin Luther High School
Private School
Greendale, WI
9-12
89 reviews
#20 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: The past four years at Martin Luther High School have been some of the best years of my life. I have had the opportunity to learn about many different subjects from well-educated teachers who are determined to help you succeed in reaching your goals. There is a wide variety of classes to choose from at the beginning of each year, depending on your skill level and interest in the subject.
Read 89 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1410 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Christian Life School
Private School
Kenosha, WI
PK, K-12
107 reviews
#21 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: CLS is very focused highly on academics, as well as extra-curricular activities, such as: fine arts, athletics, and clubs. During my time at CLS, I have seen some of our athletic teams attend state competitions, and have seen many victories for our teams. We have missions trips to multiple countries, and have trips in our own country for those who do not feel comfortable leaving the country. Our fine arts have trips every other year, where we generally compete against other schools in choral and orchestral competitions. The school has very high security measures including security officers watching before and after school, and we also have a security guard on deck at all times inside the school. We also have a foreign exchange program, where students from many different countries come to our school and live with host families that are a part of our school. Our class sizes generally range about 22 students to 1 teacher, giving the students much more one on one with the teacher.
Read 107 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1250 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. John's Northwestern Military Academy
Private School
WI
7-12
20 reviews
#22 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: We were concerned our bright but underachieving son would get lost in the shuffle at a big high school. He was hesitant to leave home but quickly made friends and got used to the routine. In a few short months, we started to see dramatic changes in his attitude and academic performance. He also started trying new sports and extracurricular activities and his confidence soared. Now in his second year, he has a leadership position which is like a part-time job that teaches practical skills and time-management. St. John's gives students the arena to develop into the total person they are capable of becoming - a successful student and young person of character, personal responsibility and integrity. I also like the easy access to faculty and staff who really know my child. The investment to send our son here was a big decision but the school worked with us to make it possible. The results are worth it!
Read 20 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1220 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Thomas More High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
143 reviews
#23 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: If you look at St. Thomas More you would think that this seems like a school I want my child to attend and going here for 4 years I would say yes you are correct. This school has everything! We have a variety of sports and clubs that we as the students can get involved in. The culture here is lovely we have a mix of Spanish, African American, Native American, and American culture. This school is very diverse and open to everyone which is a great thing. Another good thing about St. Thomas More is the education we are able to get. The courses are challenging, but they prepare you for college. A few things that I wish they could change is getting better teachers that know what they are doing not some random teacher you find in a public high school. Another thing I wish they would have helped us practice and be ready for the ACT. Even though there might be a few things that should be changed this school is still great! It has made me the person I am today.
Read 143 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1240 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Luther Preparatory School
Private School
Watertown, WI
9-12
122 reviews
#24 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Luther Prep has been such a good experience for me. I have loved every minute of going to school here. When I can in as a freshman I didn't know anyone in my class. It was so crazy how fast I made friends and how quickly we became our own little family. For those of you who don't know much about Prep it's a ministry minded school. The students live on campus in dorms with tutors as their on campus "parents". I think living in the dorms has really helped me learn how to be independent and prepared me for college. Another cool thing about Prep is the diversity. I have people in my class from China, Korea, Canada, St. Lucia, Ukraine, and one of my best friends is from Antigua. Iv'e learned so much about different countries cultures and it's been so awesome to hear how different they're lives are from mine.
Read 122 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1290 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Lakeside Lutheran High School
Private School
Lake Mills, WI
9-12
116 reviews
#25 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Lakeside is a great school with many great opportunities. Our athletics are extremely competitive and blessed with numerous wins. For example, our volleyball team has blessed with going to state back to back and actually winning last year. Not only are sports great, but we also have strong math teams and often win meets. Lakeside also offers a large variety of classes ranging from foods to AP Psychology, there are many classes to fit one's need. Most importantly, however, Lakeside offers God's Word which is why Lakeside is the best fit. Religion classes are taught daily and are an awesome experience to know that your friends believe the same thing that you do.
Read 116 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1270 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Phillips Academy
Private School
Andover, MA
9-12
116 reviews
Alum: My daughter graduated in 2011, and I am a member of the Alumni Council for Phillips Academy (full disclosure).

Even though I knew how special Andover was, I experienced an even better Andover through my daughter. She was a smart girl before, but she developed such confidence, particularly in math and science. I watched the self-doubt become controlled and I saw a true leader develop. Even when there was a disappointment, she knew that she could power through it with the skills she possessed.

And the friendships! She has life-long friends, both boarders and day students, boys and girls, athletes and non-athletes. All are smart, confident, and succeeding in their fields, now that Andover is behind them. But, you never lose Andover; it is always with you, allowing you to strive and succeed in every way.
Read 116 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,146 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
- 2020 Most Diverse Public Middle Schools
- 2020 Best Private School Teachers
- 2020 Best Public High Schools for STEM
Review Your School
Sponsored
The Meadowbrook School of Weston
Private School
Weston, MA
PK, K-8
4 reviews
Works Here: I've worked at Meadowbrook for four years, and was a student there as a child. Meadowbrook has the magical ability to maintain a loving, challenging culture over many years. It was a great place to go to school, and it's a great place to work! It is such a joy to see children grow and learn in such an incredible environment every day.
Read 4 Reviews
318 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Derby Academy
Private School
Hingham, MA
PK, K-8
3 reviews
Parent: I was blown away by how well my children’s teachers got to know them and understand their learning styles in such a short period of time. I expected that at my first parent teacher conference I would have to fill in the teachers about my kids but I didn’t have to as they completely told me all the things I was going to tell them about my kids!
Read 3 Reviews
299 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes

1 of 4

University School of Milwaukee

The Prairie School

Madison Country Day School

Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart

Marquette University High School

Wayland Academy

Divine Savior Holy Angels High School

University Lake School

North Cedar Academy

Catholic Memorial High School

St. Lawrence Seminary High School

Dominican High School

Catholic Central High School

Notre Dame de la Baie Academy

Pius XI Catholic High School

Northeastern Wisconsin Lutheran High School

Xavier High School

Wisconsin Lutheran High School

Eastbrook Academy

Martin Luther High School

Christian Life School

St. John's Northwestern Military Academy

St. Thomas More High School

Luther Preparatory School

Lakeside Lutheran High School

Phillips Academy

The Meadowbrook School of Weston

Derby Academy