Skip to Main Content

2019 Best College Prep Private High Schools in WisconsinAbout this List

Explore the private high schools that best prepare their students for college success. Ranking based on SAT/ACT scores, 4-year matriculation rate, the quality of colleges that students consider, and student and parent ratings of college readiness. Read more on how this ranking was calculated.

1 – 25 of 86
College Prep
86 results

  1. The Prairie School

    • Private School
    • Wind Point, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 46
    #1 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Parent: People think they can't afford it, but Prairie gives financial aid based on your income. My kids couldn't go there without it! We're just average income people so we had to make changes to get the best education for them. We were totally surprised, and I still find it hard to believe, that parents, teachers, and everyone there helps raise money for financial aid for the families who need it! We've had teachers who cared about our kids like family. Like every school, Prairie has issues and improvements can be made. But, I liked it right away because it teaches what we teach our kids at home…respect others and be a problem solver. THANK YOU to those who suggested we just visit and apply! PLEASE don't assume you can't afford it. That's what we thought, too and we are definitely not the only people of average income there. I hope more families in the area just go see Prairie and apply!
    Read 46 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1330 Average SAT
    • 30 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  2. Madison Country Day School

    • Private School
    • Waunakee, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 17
    #2 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Parent: Our child, now in high school, has been at MCDS since Lower School and our overall experience has been strongly positive. The school has grown steadily over the past decade and yet no child falls between the cracks. The low faculty-to-student ratio is key to student success. Faculty are very dedicated to the students and communicate well with parents. The curriculum is challenging, but not excessively so. The range of students' abilities across subjects is broad, yet the common denominator is that all are aiming to do the best they can and succeed in college, be that at a large university or a small liberal arts college. The school also values character education, and the arts are not considered peripheral, but an essential part of the curriculum. The relative lack of racial diversity is offset by social and ethnic diversity, including an international outlook among many families.
    Read 17 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1400 Average SAT
    • 30 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  3. University School of Milwaukee

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 68
    #3 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Junior: the campus is absolutely gorgeous. additionally, all the classrooms are up to date as the school has no shortage of funding.
    classes are all pretty engaging and challenging. teachers are amazing and will make sure to help you if you are ever struggling.
    the culture of the school is very intense; everyone is very driven. If you thrive in this type of environment, you'll like USM. however, if you're a bit more passive this may be a bit of a challenge for you. for the most part, students are polite and accepting and no one is really ever outwardly mean. obviously, there's still some high school drama, but that's expected everywhere you go. if you're coming in as a new student, expect it to be difficult to break into new friend groups as many of the kids here have been going to school with each other since they were 5.

    overall, USM is a good school and will help you in the future.
    Read 68 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1340 Average SAT
    • 30 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes
  4. Sponsored

    The Prairie School

    • Private School
    • Wind Point, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 46

    Parent: People think they can't afford it, but Prairie gives financial aid based on your income. My kids couldn't go there without it! We're just average income people so we had to make changes to get the best education for them. We were totally surprised, and I still find it hard to believe, that parents, teachers, and everyone there helps raise money for financial aid for the families who need it! We've had teachers who cared about our kids like family. Like every school, Prairie has issues and improvements can be made. But, I liked it right away because it teaches what we teach our kids at home…respect others and be a problem solver. THANK YOU to those who suggested we just visit and apply! PLEASE don't assume you can't afford it. That's what we thought, too and we are definitely not the only people of average income there. I hope more families in the area just go see Prairie and apply!
    Read 46 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 634 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  5. Marquette University High School

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • 9-12
    • 162
    #4 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: Marquette University High School (MUHS) has fulfilled my life academically, socially and spiritually. The overall atmosphere to which all students are exposed to is spectacular to the effect that we are pushed to become stewards of positive change, whether it be in school or out in the community. MUHS encourages all their students to become life-long learners, never putting to waste the chance to learn or step out our shell of conformity and regularity. But, most importantly, MUHS encourages all its students, from the freshman to seniors, to become individuals who go out and serve, rather than be served. In essence, the well rounded education, coupled with the enhanced focus on the individual, creates a perfect atmosphere for any young man to discover his true passions and vocation in life.
    Read 162 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1310 Average SAT
    • 28 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  6. Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart

    • Private School
    • Madison, WI
    • 9-12
    • 59
    #5 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Junior: Edgewood high school is an amazing school if one wants to receive an amazing education. I’m an atheist and was dreading the required religion classes, but I now rather find them interesting as the religion classes offered focus on multiple religions and viewpoints of the world. I felt like I have close relationships with my teachers and could go to them for anything, academic or not. The kids, despite being a little preppy, are all very friendly and due to the medium size of the class you truly know everyone at Edgewood. Overall, the tight-knit community at Edgewood makes any student feel like they belong at Edgewood.
    Read 59 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1330 Average SAT
    • 29 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  7. Divine Savior Holy Angels High School

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • 9-12
    • 204
    #6 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: DSHA has given me countless opportunities and connected me with wonderful teachers, students, and other faculty members. The school feels connect through our shared faith, yet welcoming to others of different faiths and backgrounds. Retreats bond classes together and the vigorous courses allow students to reach their fullest academic potential. I truly have found the the DSHA community is accepting and supportive, with my only criticism being on its diversity. I feel there are defiantly minority groups who may struggle feeling the same connectedness and support I have felt in the DSHA community. I do believe that DSHA is trying to give these voices a platform through dasher dialogues and culture assemblies. The teachers are caring and hardworking with the students best interests at heart always. Overall DSHA has allowed me to develop leadership skills in my faith, sports and student council, and challenged me academically pushing me to my fullest potential as a student
    Read 204 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1190 Average SAT
    • 28 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  10. University Lake School

    • Private School
    • Hartland, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 45
    #7 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Parent: My 7th grade son was in a public school where it became uncool to be smart. His grades were dropping, he missed assignments, and had some experiences with bullying. At ULS he is in a small class where he gets more attention from teachers to help him with organization and staying on task. The other students are kind and care about their grades, so it is a good environment for him to excel. The school has a welcoming community and strong, hands-on approach to learning. It's been great for our son!
    Read 45 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1290 Average SAT
    • 27 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  11. Wayland Academy

    • Private School
    • Beaver Dam, WI
    • 9-12
    • 47
    #8 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Niche User: Wayland Academy truly seemed like a great place from when I visited! I got to shadow a student during a Spring Open House. The boy's dorm "Wayland Hall" was very very nice. The admissions counselors and teachers seemed very helpful and the students all had strong connections and friendships with each other. The campus itself is really nice. Safety was really great with a gated campus along with card access to dorms and students have to sign in and out of the dorms if they want to leave. I have heard of their mentor program but I can't say much about it, as I never attended.
    Read 47 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A+
      College Prep
    • 1240 Average SAT
    • 27 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  12. Catholic Memorial High School

    • Private School
    • Waukesha, WI
    • 9-12
    • 105
    #9 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: The first three years here have been the most amazing experience. I love coming here every day and how good the teachers are at preparing us for college. There are always lots of people here to put a smile on your face every day. The caring nature here as well as the faith connection is so amazing and I am very proud to be a Crusader! Also, the strong emphasis on the fact that this school is a living memorial to the members of the Waukesha community who serve and have served for our country. I am always very proud of what we stand for as a school.
    Read 105 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1350 Average SAT
    • 28 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  14. Notre Dame de la Baie Academy

    • Private School
    • Green Bay, WI
    • 9-12
    • 174
    #10 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: Notre Dame Academy strives to build the student on an educational basis but also focuses on as the whole person. Notre Dame students exceed expectations in school and off campus as well. Participating in various service projects and donating to organizations in need of assistance are just two small things the students of Notre Dame Academy take on as a responsibility throughout their time in high school. The ACT and overall GPA are a great representation of how a supportive school helps students excel in the classroom. The opportunities that are provided are endless. Students can express themselves and their faith by joining the multiple clubs and having ample opportunities to participate in mass and other faith related activities. The comforting atmosphere of Notre Dame can be seen in the smiling faces of teachers, counselors and administration. Overall, my high school education could not have taught me how to be a better person or student than it has at Notre Dame.
    Read 174 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1360 Average SAT
    • 27 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  15. Dominican High School

    • Private School
    • Whitefish Bay, WI
    • 9-12
    • 51
    #11 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: Dominican has provided me with endless opportunities throughout my four years of high school. I was able to try out many things I never would have considered if not for constant encouragement from students and faculty. I eventually found my place on the KnightLife team, which gave me the chance to be a leader at a school that treated me so well. The people at this school are the kindest and most welcoming people, no matter where you come from. I feel confident that I will excel in college thanks to the academics and amount of preparation I have been offered here. I was the first of my family to attend, but my younger siblings all plan to attend Dominican for high school. The Dominican spirit will truly stay with me for the rest of my life.
    Read 51 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1460 Average SAT
    • 25 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  16. Catholic Central High School

    • Private School
    • Burlington, WI
    • 9-12
    • 29
    #12 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Parent: All four of our children attended Catholic Central. Two went on to graduate from Marquette, one is currently at Edgewood College, and our youngest is wrapping up his senior year and plans to attend Edgewood as well. Catholic Central provides a diverse curriculum complimented by passionate teachers and small class sizes. This combination allows for plenty of attention for each student and engaging classes all year long. In addition to the academics, Catholic Central’s athletic programs are rich in tradition and focus on developing the entire individual, not just the athlete. If you are looking for a holistic education where your child can continuously explore their interests, Catholic Central is the place to be!
    Read 29 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1430 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  19. Xavier High School

    • Private School
    • Appleton, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 122
    #13 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: Xavier High School is a prestigious place, which offers their students the best facilities in the city. This school has numerous resources that can help a student reach his full potential. The community is generally accepting, however, there are cliques. The teachers are the most honest, heartfelt people in the city. Although this school is amazing, the college guidance department leaves you unprepared for the college process. If you value respect and family, Xavier High School delivers.
    Read 122 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1310 Average SAT
    • 28 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  20. Martin Luther High School

    • Private School
    • Greendale, WI
    • 9-12
    • 83
    #14 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: After attending Martin Luther High School for almost four years, I have seen a dramatic impact the school's faculty and curriculum has left on me. The teachers in this school continuously reached out to me, making sure I was doing okay. I was convinced by many of my peers to join the wrestling team, and three years later I am the captain of other people I now call brothers and sisters. Leadership was not the only thing that Martin Luther taught me. I learned the true meaning of commitment, hard work, and the importance of academics. The courses provided in the school curriculum are challenging ones that prepare students for college as well as the common hardships of life. Had I not attended this assiduous school, many opportunities that I have now, would not be available to me. In conclusion, Martin Luther High School is one of the greatest educational institutions to ever be established.
    Read 83 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1480 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  21. St. Lawrence Seminary High School

    • Private School
    • Mount Calvary, WI
    • 9-12
    • 39
    #15 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Alum: My experience at St. lawrence Seminary was one of overwhelming change. I came in as a timid and rather strange freshman. That changed when I surrounded myself with the community and took active participation in classes. The catholic aspect of the school is incredibly satisfactory and the adademic aspect is of equal reagrd. The facilities are all clean and are routinely taken care of by not only the janitorical staff, but also by students. We were encouraged to take part in school clean-ups and ministry, exposing us to the world and the greater community. If there was one thing I would have to change about St. Lawrence Seminary, it would be the inclusion of college credits. The AP program is nearly nonexistant, and entering college I was slightly dissapointed to see none of my college level work pay off. Regardless, the school is fantastic, life-changing, and ultimately excellent in all fields related to academics and community.
    Read 39 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A
      College Prep
    • 1340 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  22. Wisconsin Lutheran High School

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • 9-12
    • 249
    #16 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: Wisconsin Lutheran High School is an exceptional school for any student looking to challenge themselves academically, get involved in extra curricular activities, and be constantly enveloped in a Christian environment. Due to the versatility of the school and the willingness of the teacher and administration, I've been able to experience choir, basketball, STEM curriculum, student council, A/V club, book club, steel band, mission trips to Arizona and Zambia, the Civil Rights Tour, AP classes, and so much more! This school provides amazing opportunities for all of its students in academics, athletics, and fine arts. I'm glad to be able to call Wisco my home.
    Read 249 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1290 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  23. Northeastern Wisconsin Lutheran High School

    • Private School
    • Green Bay, WI
    • 9-12
    • 17
    #17 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: I have had a great experience at NEW Lutheran. I love the Christian atmosphere, and the closeness you gain with other students and teachers. NEW is very good at teaching their classes and I have learned a lot here in both my education and religion. The only thing I would change would be the negative attitudes that follow some of the students around. I would love to see everyone get along, though I doubt that would happen anywhere you go.
    Read 17 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1430 Average SAT
    • 28 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  26. Christian Life School

    • Private School
    • Kenosha, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 102
    #18 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Parent: I have had seven children go through Christian Life for their entire pre-collegiate careers; the oldest began there in kindergarten in 1991 and the youngest will graduate next year. The experience has been uniformly wonderful. Each has been excellently prepared for the demands of college life, but--of far more long-term importance--each has been nurtured as an individual and encouraged to develop into a balanced, creative, thoughtful, spiritual, compassionate person. Thank you, Christian Life School!
    Read 102 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1290 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  27. Pius XI Catholic High School

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • 9-12
    • 176
    #19 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Junior: Pius is a great school. Coming in as a freshman was extremely difficult and I had a hard time adjusting through my sophomore year. However now as a junior I truly feel I have found my place. I have not always had the best teachers and experiences, but they are the things that have probably prepared me from real life the most. I would rate the school a 3.75 if that was an option. I cannot overlook the hardships I faced while here, and the difficulties I had to overcome, but this past year has been by far incredible, the new administration and policies have made my many hours spent here far more enjoyable.
    Read 176 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1240 Average SAT
    • 24 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  28. Eastbrook Academy

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 32
    #20 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: I have been attending Eastbrook Academy for 7 years and this is a truly remarkable school! The academics are challenging and above average. The teachers also challenge each student to become their best self academically and professionally. Although there are not many clubs or sports, the many aspects such as the family oriented atmostsphere is hard to find anywhere else. During my last year it was remarkable to see the changes the Eastbrook made, especially those that students requested. Overall, Eastbrook Academy a unique school full of diversity, family, leaders, and hard working faculty and students.
    Read 32 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1310 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  29. Heritage Christian Schools, Inc.

    • Private School
    • New Berlin, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 48
    #21 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: I have loved my time at Heritage! I have been attending since I was in elementary school and have enjoyed growing up in this environment. There may not be as many classes or opportunities as a public school, but Heritage has strengthened me in better ways. My relationship with my teachers and my chapel experience have strengthen my faith and allowed me to come closer to Christ. That is the best thing anyone can do for you!
    Read 48 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1330 Average SAT
    • 27 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  30. St. Thomas More High School

    • Private School
    • Milwaukee, WI
    • 9-12
    • 137
    #22 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: If you look at St. Thomas More you would think that this seems like a school I want my child to attend and going here for 4 years I would say yes you are correct. This school has everything! We have a variety of sports and clubs that we as the students can get involved in. The culture here is lovely we have a mix of Spanish, African American, Native American, and American culture. This school is very diverse and open to everyone which is a great thing. Another good thing about St. Thomas More is the education we are able to get. The courses are challenging, but they prepare you for college. A few things that I wish they could change is getting better teachers that know what they are doing not some random teacher you find in a public high school. Another thing I wish they would have helped us practice and be ready for the ACT. Even though there might be a few things that should be changed this school is still great! It has made me the person I am today.
    Read 137 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1250 Average SAT
    • 24 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes
  31. Review Your School 

  32. Lourdes Academy Catholic Schools

    • Private School
    • Oshkosh, WI
    • PK, K-12
    • 18
    #23 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Alum: My experience was a bit different in the Lourdes Academy HighSchool. The diversity was very small and I personally didn’t get involved in any clubs because there was very few of them. However, you could make your own club up with a teacher permission which i believe is really cool. Lourdes Academy is best for helping you do good in the community and to help those in need. Along with good class that will help you in the future. One thing I would change is dresscode because I am a strong believer that how one dresses is how they express themselves to one another. I also believe that dresscode is valued more important than academics and I don’t think that’s right. This is my personal review on Lourdes Academy, but if you love the small community environment then this school is the place!!
    Read 18 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1230 Average SAT
    • 26 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  33. St. Joseph Catholic Academy

    • Private School
    • Kenosha, WI
    • K-12
    • 92
    #24 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: Being at St. Joseph Catholic Academy has been a great high school experience for me. For my parents, St. Joseph offered Catholic education which they considered to be very important for me. although I was skeptical at first, I gradually learn to appreciate St. Joseph for its AP and Honors classes, more individual attention, helpful faulty, and a close knitted student and teacher community. However, school clubs are still experiencing some difficulties since they are relatively new. St. Joseph is a bit lacking when it comes toward diversity, but it has been improving throughout the year. Overall, St. Joseph is a high school that values its students in order to prepare them for college and beyond that.
    Read 92 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1220 Average SAT
    • 25 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes

  34. Lake Country Lutheran High School

    • Private School
    • Hartland, WI
    • 9-12
    • 91
    #25 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin

    Senior: At Lake Country Lutheran, the high school experience is embodied by the teachers and students alike. The teachers involve every student and get to know each student on a personal level by skipping free periods or lunch to sit down and chat about life. The student body is unique and encouraging and does not miss a beat to lift s fellow student up. The academics are challenging but always grant the opportunity of success if you work hard to achieve it. Athletically, it is extremely competitive as almost every year, an extracurricular activity is competing at the state level. One thing I would change is the variety of classes Lake Country Lutheran offers as it is a smaller school, only about 300 students, and offers all core classes but not a wide variety of others. Overall, my experience has been positive and encourage anyone wanting a education based on faith to pursue this school.
    Read 91 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • A-
      College Prep
    • 1250 Average SAT
    • 27 Average ACT
    View Nearby Homes
  35. Sponsored

    Flint Hill School

    • Private School
    • Oakton, VA
    • PK, K-12
    • 55

    Parent: Flint Hill is a lovely school, and I have been surprised by how down-to-earth the culture is, despite the price tag and rigorous college prep environment. Kids really get what they need in an individualized way, we have been thrilled with the school, having had 2 kids attend for almost a decade now!
    Read 55 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,097 Students
    • 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  36. Sponsored

    Roanoke Catholic School

    • Private School
    • Roanoke, VA
    • PK, K-12
    • 58

    Alum: I attended RCS since 5th grade, and absolutely loved it. This school provides an excellent college prep education while being centered on Catholic teaching. The teachers deeply care for their students, and definitely push them to be better students, but also better people. Theology classes certainly teach the beliefs of the Church but also allow for questions and discussion about the Catholic faith, which gives students the opportunity to own their faith rather than know about their faith. I would highly recommend this school to any family interested in a high quality, holistically minded, education.
    Read 58 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 501 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  • 1 of 4