Compare College Prep at Wisconsin Private High Schools

College Prep

96 results

University School of Milwaukee
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.21 out of 5 97 reviews
#1 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: My son recently finished prekindergarten at USM, and I cannot speak highly enough about the education he received. The growth and maturity he experienced over that first year was remarkable and was a joy for me and my husband to witness. Not only did he learn the fundamentals in letters and numbers, he learned how to be kind, patient, to try new things, to work through challenges, and to be confident.

His teachers happily fostered his interests and applied their years of experience and knowledge of best-practices to his education. Not only are USM's teachers exceptional, the school's campus and facilities are unmatched, as well as its commitment to safety.

I love how the school encourages meaningful collaborations between students of all ages, how it teaches and upholds the standards of its Common Trust, and how it supports and engages with parents. We were thrilled with the education our son received and look forward to continuing our USM journey!
Read 97 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1360 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
The Prairie School
Private School
Wind Point, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.61 out of 5 69 reviews
#2 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: The teachers are awesome and so approachable! You can reach out to them with questions about almost anything ranging from academics to outside resources. The facilities are also very nice; the students are basically welcome to use anything and all the projects are supported, as long as a loose set of rules are followed. The social aspect of the student body at the school, however, can be a little iffy because everyone has known each other for a really long time -- sometimes it can be difficult on new kids to join the community.
Read 69 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1340 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Madison Country Day School
Private School
Waunakee, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.08 out of 5 26 reviews
#3 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I have attended Madison Country Day School from kindergarten through senior year. Because of the size and environment of the school, I feel very close to my classmates and community; they're like my second family! The small size has also allowed me a lot of flexibility regarding enrichment, course/subject advancement, and specialized learning tracks. However, while the school does provide limited support services, the student body sometimes acts as a resonating chamber for negativity, stress, and poor mental health, especially in the upper grades.
Read 26 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1390 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Wayland Academy
Private School
Beaver Dam, WI
9-12
Rating 3.77 out of 5 56 reviews
#4 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Niche User: Wayland Academy truly seemed like a great place from when I visited! I got to shadow a student during a Spring Open House. The boy's dorm "Wayland Hall" was very very nice. The admissions counselors and teachers seemed very helpful and the students all had strong connections and friendships with each other. The campus itself is really nice. Safety was really great with a gated campus along with card access to dorms and students have to sign in and out of the dorms if they want to leave. I have heard of their mentor program but I can't say much about it, as I never attended.
Read 56 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1260 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart
Private School
Madison, WI
9-12
Rating 4.24 out of 5 74 reviews
#5 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Going to Edgewood has been a memorable experience for me. It has been a mixed bag as to the specifics, but overall I would recommend at least shadowing the school if you think that you or your child will be a good fit there. A good fit for Edgewood is someone who is open to learning about faith, believes in the value of community service, kind but with thick skin. There are a lot of stereotypes about Edgewood, some true and some false. It's just something you have to learn to deal with as a student. YES NEW STADIUM!
Read 74 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1330 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
North Cedar Academy
Private School
Ladysmith, WI
9-12
Rating 3.73 out of 5 11 reviews
#6 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: My step-son is in his second year at NCA and we are so pleased with his maturity and the academic and social gains he has made since attending NCA. He is a part of the NCA - University of Wisconsin Eau Claire "Early Pathway" program and in his first semester alone this year he has completed 5 university classes at UW-Eau Claire at no cost to us! The school seems well managed and well run. It is always spotlessly clean we notice, the teachers are professional, kind and experienced (ours son's favorite is the GREAT music teacher he has at NCA), and the dormitory staff and coaching staff has been great to him. We could not be more pleased with the school, and the bonus is that our son (like all US students) attends tuition free!
Read 11 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1300 Average SAT
32 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Marquette University High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
Rating 4.37 out of 5 186 reviews
#7 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
University Lake School
Private School
Hartland, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.54 out of 5 50 reviews
#8 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Junior: University Lake School is a small school, and to me, this enhances the experience. Everybody knows everybody, and this creates an incredible family atmosphere. Students can receive help from teachers almost whenever, and teachers can provide catered help to each student. ULS is also academically demanding, and this sets ULS apart from many other schools. I believe that without the academic rigor and expectations set by University Lake School, I would not have been able to learn quickly and progress into higher learning. ULS brings out student's strengths and allows them to achieve their dreams, no matter what those may be.
Read 50 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1280 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Divine Savior Holy Angels High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
Rating 4.24 out of 5 246 reviews
#9 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I am so glad I went to Divine Savior Holy Angels for high school. I have met some of my closest and lifelong friends here! I would recommend DSHA to anyone who asked since it has truly made me a more rounded person. Through sports, extracurriculars, and academics, I will be sad to leave next year. I love the teachers as well. It is so easy to develop close relationships with the teachers and they are so helpful anytime you make need it! If you are struggling in a class, they will not let you fail or your grade worsen. Instead, they will contact you directly and figure out how they can help and address the problem. DSHA tries to make everyone comfortable and it is so easy making friends when you are a freshman since there are so many programs in place e to get you used to and comfortable with high school. Everyone is friends with everyone and there really is not that much division. The academics are incredible at DS. It really is a college prep school! Overall, I highly recommend DS!
Read 246 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A+
College Prep
1220 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Dominican High School
Private School
Whitefish Bay, WI
9-12
Rating 4.17 out of 5 82 reviews
#10 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: For those parents and families that value an education that, in addition to very high academic expectations, places a premium on character development within a loving family atmosphere, look no further than Dominican High School. What makes this school more unique is that this private school fosters high, individually driven, academic achievements within a non-stressful atmosphere. No matter the student's background, academic gifts or challenges the atmoshpere is welcoming for the full student body. The supportive faculty and staff will not overlook those students that need extra academic support! My students are transfer students and within one week they felt not only acclimated, they felt a part of a large caring family.
Read 82 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1390 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Catholic Memorial High School
Private School
Waukesha, WI
9-12
Rating 4.02 out of 5 127 reviews
#11 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: CMH has gone above and beyond during this pandemic by providing an excellent college prep experience while strictly following all COVID-19 safety parameters. I am very happy with the level of responsiveness by teachers and administrators at this school.

While many students in our state have literally missed a year of school, CMH students have been able to study in person, meet with friends, and participate in athletics, arts, and worship. When I decided to send my daughter to CMH, I was a little hesitant because of the money, but I now can confirm that this is money well spent!

Many public school parents who have had to watch their children rot at home with no athletic opportunities and canned online lessons, will most likely be paying money down the line to alleviate the inevitable psychological problems this pandemic will cause our state's children.
Read 127 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1300 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Xavier High School
Private School
Appleton, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.19 out of 5 135 reviews
#12 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: I had a pretty good time at Xavier! My teachers were well educated and I knew they cared deeply for me. The community is very welcoming and parents of students there often knew what was going on in the school. The athletics department was amazing, and students were taught constantly how to take care of their bodies, minds, and spirits. My only complaint is that some students there can be spoiled, but that comes with every private school. Xavier is amazing in educational and athletic terms, so I would definitely recommend to a friend.
Read 135 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1300 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Lawrence Seminary High School
Private School
Mount Calvary, WI
9-12
Rating 4.36 out of 5 47 reviews
#13 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: St. Lawrence is providing a top notch education to our two very different sons. One likes academics and forensics, the other spends all of his free time on the basketball court. We are pleased with the faithful, independent, courteous and well educated young men they are becoming who desire to make the world a better place. Teachers are challenging yet compassionate. They have promptly replied to my questions and concerns. I can't say enough about how pleased we are with this school.
Read 47 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1330 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Northeastern Wisconsin Lutheran High School
Private School
Green Bay, WI
9-12
Rating 4 out of 5 21 reviews
#14 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: One of the best aspects of N.E.W. Lutheran is its quality of education. The school's teachers have an exceptional knowledge of their field, whether it be English, mathematics, or science. Secondly the school has developed a strong international student program, and I personally enjoyed the diversity that came with it. Sports make up at least half of the school's extracurricular activities, and just as much of the school's overall culture. Don't worry, non-athletes. Math Team, robotics, drama, and student-led music bands have you covered.
To be frank, many of the students that attend N.E.W. came from Lutheran middle schools, but there is plenty of room for kids like me who originated from a public school. The school's dress code is a degree stricter than that of typical schools, but it is fairly straightforward -- you don't have to dress up too fancy, and on Wednesdays, you can pay a buck or two to wear sweatpants.
Read 21 Reviews
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1400 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. John's Northwestern Academies
Private School
Delafield, WI
7-12
Rating 4.52 out of 5 21 reviews
#15 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: We were concerned our bright but underachieving son would get lost in the shuffle at a big high school. He was hesitant to leave home but quickly made friends and got used to the routine. In a few short months, we started to see dramatic changes in his attitude and academic performance. He also started trying new sports and extracurricular activities and his confidence soared. Now in his second year, he has a leadership position which is like a part-time job that teaches practical skills and time-management. St. John's gives students the arena to develop into the total person they are capable of becoming - a successful student and young person of character, personal responsibility and integrity. I also like the easy access to faculty and staff who really know my child. The investment to send our son here was a big decision but the school worked with us to make it possible. The results are worth it!
Read 21 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1220 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Catholic Central High School
Private School
Burlington, WI
9-12
Rating 4.35 out of 5 34 reviews
#16 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: All four of our children attended Catholic Central. Two went on to graduate from Marquette, one is currently at Edgewood College, and our youngest is wrapping up his senior year and plans to attend Edgewood as well. Catholic Central provides a diverse curriculum complimented by passionate teachers and small class sizes. This combination allows for plenty of attention for each student and engaging classes all year long. In addition to the academics, Catholic Central’s athletic programs are rich in tradition and focus on developing the entire individual, not just the athlete. If you are looking for a holistic education where your child can continuously explore their interests, Catholic Central is the place to be!
Read 34 Reviews
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1330 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Notre Dame de la Baie Academy
Private School
Green Bay, WI
9-12
Rating 4.09 out of 5 190 reviews
#17 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I enjoyed attending Notre Dame Academy because I liked being in a Catholic school environment. I liked learning about my faith on a daily basis and being able to participate in all of the opportunities made available to me to allow me to grow in my faith, such as attending mass regularly with my classmates, participating in reconciliation, and going to Adoration.

My biggest complaint was many of the students did not feel like their voices were heard when going to faculty or staff with complaints regarding situations at school or problems with teachers.
Read 190 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
grade A
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Wisconsin Lutheran High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
Rating 4.21 out of 5 282 reviews
#18 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: Wonderful Christian-based school with teachers that care about their students! Always felt that I had a full support system surrounding me with my faith in God as their highest priority. I Would pay any amount of money to help keep my children as close to God as possible for as long as possible! Daily chapel services are a huge part of this, as well! I am an alum, and my closest friends come from Wisconsin Lutheran HS. The fact that we all have the same faith keeps us close. I strongly recommend sending your children to Wisco...you will not regret this important decision!
Read 282 Reviews
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1330 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Pius XI Catholic High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
Rating 3.93 out of 5 204 reviews
#19 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: The caring atmosphere is quite pervasive. When you walk in the door you feel that sense of caring. The TAC Program is very important with today's issues. Each student is assigned to a teacher who helps them navigate the high school world. Those teachers are the student's counselor, advisor, advocate, and friend. The academic offerings are amazing. The broad areas of course selection is second to none. The students who graduate are able to get into many different schools. My daughter graduated from Pius and has become very successful!
Read 204 Reviews
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1270 Average SAT
24 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Heritage Christian Schools, Inc.
Private School
New Berlin, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 3.53 out of 5 58 reviews
#20 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: My experience attending Heritage was fun! The teachers at the school not only are there to help you academically but truly care about you as a student and your wellbeing. Spirit week was always one of my favorite times of the year, being able to have themed dressed down days and activities for your classes to build a strong relationship with one another. This school is constantly serving others and the community and teaching your kids how to be a leader even in their own neighborhood. Heritage has taught me how to be an example for others and how to put my special gifts into practice. The school not only provides an excellent education but also provides life time friends that will be with you as you grow to the person that God has created you to be. I highly recommend coming to this school to further your education and grow closer with your walk with the Lord as well. Heritage has taught me to constantly push myself to the challenges presented in my life but to push others as well.
Read 58 Reviews
grade B+
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1190 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Eastbrook Academy
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.1 out of 5 48 reviews
#21 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I have been attending Eastbrook Academy for 7 years and this is a truly remarkable school! The academics are challenging and above average. The teachers also challenge each student to become their best self academically and professionally. Although there are not many clubs or sports, the many aspects such as the family oriented atmostsphere is hard to find anywhere else. During my last year it was remarkable to see the changes the Eastbrook made, especially those that students requested. Overall, Eastbrook Academy a unique school full of diversity, family, leaders, and hard working faculty and students.
Read 48 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1300 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
St. Ambrose Academy
Private School
Madison, WI
6-12
Rating 4.73 out of 5 11 reviews
#22 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: I was a 2017 graduate of St. Ambrose Academy. To this day, I look back fondly at the human and educational development I received at this school. Here, I received the critical thinking skills to excel at the University level. I have since noticed that I had an advantage when compared to my peers especially in the liberal arts. St. Ambrose forms and develops the Catholic men and women who will lead the next generation. I am proud to support this school!
Read 11 Reviews
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1380 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Lake Country Lutheran High School
Private School
Hartland, WI
9-12
Rating 4.06 out of 5 104 reviews
#23 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: Lake Country Lutheran is a high school I would recommend to anyone. The education you get is good, but the accessibility of teachers makes it above exceptional. Students do a good job leading and role modeling, and grades easily mingle. It wasn't shocking to have freshman friends with seniors through the program of LIFT, which is a small group bible study led by upper class men. The school is very connected, from faculty to coaches to students to alum. While in attendance you create a life long family, and relationships continue to prosper after graduation. While diversity lacks, as well as the variation a of clubs and opportunities; the staff is open to anything to establish the best experience possible for the students.
Read 104 Reviews
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1280 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Christian Life School
Private School
Kenosha, WI
PK, K-12
Rating 4.01 out of 5 114 reviews
#24 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
grade A minus
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1320 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Martin Luther High School
Private School
Greendale, WI
9-12
Rating 3.57 out of 5 96 reviews
#25 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: As a senior at Martin Luther High School, I have had a great experience these past four years and I would recommend Martin Luther High School for your children. They are very good at having different level classes to challenge students and help them when help is needed. At Martin Luther High School they value your children, they help the students expand in their religion, and have chapel three times a week. They also have built-in a study hall/resource, where students who are struggling can get help from the teachers and students have extra time to work on homework. Martin Luther values their students and makes sure they are ready for college. I feel like I am ready for college, I have learned a lot by taking AP courses they offer and I have learned a lot from the teachers I have had. Martin Luther is a great choice for your child to pursue their dream and prepare them for college.
Read 96 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
grade A minus
College Prep
1360 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Sponsored
BASIS Independent McLean
Private School
McLean, VA
PK, K-12
Rating 3.35 out of 5 37 reviews
Parent: We are are new family to Basis McLean but so far loving it!
I know there has been administrative instability in the past but the quality of the teaching and small class size is outstandingly fabulous. My daughter is so motivated, it is wonderful to see.

If your focus is sports, this is not the school for you. But if your focus is academics and a love a learning, I believe this school is working very well.

We are happy we switched from FCPS, despite the cost esp. as the school offers in-person teaching during this pandemic which has been essential for my child's growth and wellbeing.
Read 37 Reviews
grade A+
Overall Niche Grade
453 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
- 2021 Most Diverse Public Middle Schools
- 2021 Best Private School Teachers
- 2021 Best Public High Schools for STEM
Review Your School
Sponsored
Washington Episcopal School
Private School
Bethesda, MD
PK, K-8
Rating 4.33 out of 5 12 reviews
Parent: We have 2 boys currently attending WES. One is in his 3rd year there and a 2nd grader and the younger is 2 months into his first year (kindergarten). Both love their school and the teachers; they can't wait to go to school every single day.

I'm always surprised at how fast they learned to read and they're now writing stories at home...for fun! The school's focus on being kind, confident, and prepared is definitely the right direction and this mentality shows in each of their students. The parents with whom we interact are also very nice and some have become good friends. The administration staff is exceptional. It shows every day in every teacher and staff member. The head of school is out there every morning welcoming kids to school, helping with drop off, and greeting everyone by name.
Read 12 Reviews
grade A
Overall Niche Grade
290 Students
4:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Virtual Tour
Sponsored
KIPP DC Spring Academy Public Charter School
1-4
grade B+
Overall Niche Grade
411 Students
14:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes