Compare College Prep at Wisconsin Private High Schools

College Prep

79 results

University School of Milwaukee
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
PK, K-12
62
1 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: I only spent one year at USM, but it was the best year of my high school career. I took amazing classes, with mostly amazing teachers. We won the state championship for girls hockey. Fabulous school!
Read 62 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1390 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
The Prairie School
Private School
Wind Point, WI
PK, K-12
37
2 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: We transferred my son to The Prairie School in Elementary School after he experienced some challenges at another school in the area. After extensive research, we enrolled him at Prairie mid year. The teacher, staff, and students embraced him with open arms. He quickly began to shift his opinion of school. He received individual attention to overcome his reading challenges and now excels throughout all subjects. He has become a well rounded child that loves school and participates in many diverse activities including sports and the arts. We have had nothing but excellent experiences throughout the school. The environment is one of developing all aspects of the child. The curriculum is challenging and keeps him engaged while peaking his interests and curiosity. For our family, The Prairie School has been an answered prayer and is the only choice for education in our family.
Read 37 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Marquette University High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
154
3 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Marquette University High School (MUHS) has fulfilled my life academically, socially and spiritually. The overall atmosphere to which all students are exposed to is spectacular to the effect that we are pushed to become stewards of positive change, whether it be in school or out in the community. MUHS encourages all their students to become life-long learners, never putting to waste the chance to learn or step out our shell of conformity and regularity. But, most importantly, MUHS encourages all its students, from the freshman to seniors, to become individuals who go out and serve, rather than be served. In essence, the well rounded education, coupled with the enhanced focus on the individual, creates a perfect atmosphere for any young man to discover his true passions and vocation in life.
Read 154 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1320 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
- 2018 Best Private High Schools
- 2018 Best Private Schools for Athletes
- 2018 Niche Standout High Schools
Divine Savior Holy Angels High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
194
4 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: I love the all girls atmosphere and the manner in which the entire faculty and staff empowered each student to reach for their goals. I felt like I could accomplish anything and that I had an amazing support system surrounding me, motivating me to continue pushing forward.

DSHA is a community that focuses on love, hard work, education, leadership, and faith. Every aspect of it is something that has contributed to the person that I am today!
Read 194 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A+
College Prep
1190 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart
Private School
Madison, WI
9-12
59
5 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Junior: Edgewood high school is an amazing school if one wants to receive an amazing education. I’m an atheist and was dreading the required religion classes, but I now rather find them interesting as the religion classes offered focus on multiple religions and viewpoints of the world. I felt like I have close relationships with my teachers and could go to them for anything, academic or not. The kids, despite being a little preppy, are all very friendly and due to the medium size of the class you truly know everyone at Edgewood. Overall, the tight-knit community at Edgewood makes any student feel like they belong at Edgewood.
Read 59 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1290 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Dominican High School
Private School
Whitefish Bay, WI
9-12
47
6 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: Dominican provided our daughter with the most incredible high school experience we could have ever wished for. She was highly prepared for college because of an exceptional faculty and curriculum, endless leadership opportunities and a solid foundation of her faith. We are grateful for Dominican High School.
Read 47 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1460 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Bishop Ireton High School
Private School
Alexandria, VA
9-12
140
Senior: Bishop Ireton High School is a small Catholic high school in Alexandria, Virginia. The high school has great academics and many different types of extra curricular activities. The school greatly prepares students for college starting from freshman year all the way to senior year. Bishop Ireton is improving every year and plans to make some big renovations soon!
Read 140 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
813 Students
12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Madison Country Day School
Private School
Waunakee, WI
PK, K-12
13
7 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: MCDS is the best school in Madison, with the top ACT and SAT scores, and the highest percentage of National Merit Scholars. The facilities are top-notch and the faculty care about the students.
The one problem with MCDS is their indiscriminate granting of financial aid. They ought to be more selective rather than just handing aid out like its candy. The extremely high number of students receiving aid (over 50%) causes an imbalance where full-tuition paying families are CONSTANTLY being asked to donate money. This causes frustration for families when they see massive amounts of aid being given to academically inferior students or to students with families who simply don’t want to pay the tuition (as in, “we make 250k a year but we’re too cheap to pay the tuition”). People need to understand that MCDS tuition is half of what it is at any other country day school. And the school needs to understand that it can’t possibly survive by giving away so much free tuition.
Read 13 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1400 Average SAT
30 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Xavier High School
Private School
Appleton, WI
PK, K-12
116
8 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Xavier High School is a prestigious place, which offers their students the best facilities in the city. This school has numerous resources that can help a student reach his full potential. The community is generally accepting, however, there are cliques. The teachers are the most honest, heartfelt people in the city. Although this school is amazing, the college guidance department leaves you unprepared for the college process. If you value respect and family, Xavier High School delivers.
Read 116 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1340 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Wayland Academy
Private School
Beaver Dam, WI
9-12
42
9 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Wayland is a great experience for all students! The student body is less than 200 students and about half of the students are international. Overall, there are students from 32 different countries, which makes this school very diverse compared to all the public schools and many other boarding schools in the nation.
The Academy becomes strict when it comes to academics; They treat the school as if it were a college. The average class size is 14 students per class. With the class size being very small, there is more 1 on 1 times with the teacher during or outside of class.
Although athletics might not be the best, it is good for students to be able to get lots of playing time on the field or court, even though they are not a star player. There are also many clubs and other activities outside of athletics.
Overall, I think Wayland is a great school and I definitely recommend it!
Read 42 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1250 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
- 2018 Most Diverse Public Middle Schools
- 2018 Best Private School Teachers
- 2018 Best Public High Schools for STEM
University Lake School
Private School
Hartland, WI
PK, K-12
34
10 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Junior: Academics are incredibly strong. Most students are motivated and excited to attend college. School spirit is electric on Field Days and other events, such as homecoming. Most of the teachers are wonderful and go the extra mile for students. Small school allows for more teacher attention and extra help, but students tend to struggle socially as they grow older. Save for heaps of exchange students who stick to themselves, the student body is not racially diverse. It is certainly not economically diverse, either, and students are not often exposed to differing world views. Technology is an obvious weakness; the “Bring Your Own Device” program is a gross demonstration of socioeconomic discrimination, and the technology person is a grumpy old man who offers no help to students.
Read 34 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
28 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Lawrence Seminary High School
Private School
Mount Calvary, WI
9-12
34
11 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: My experience at St. lawrence Seminary was one of overwhelming change. I came in as a timid and rather strange freshman. That changed when I surrounded myself with the community and took active participation in classes. The catholic aspect of the school is incredibly satisfactory and the adademic aspect is of equal reagrd. The facilities are all clean and are routinely taken care of by not only the janitorical staff, but also by students. We were encouraged to take part in school clean-ups and ministry, exposing us to the world and the greater community. If there was one thing I would have to change about St. Lawrence Seminary, it would be the inclusion of college credits. The AP program is nearly nonexistant, and entering college I was slightly dissapointed to see none of my college level work pay off. Regardless, the school is fantastic, life-changing, and ultimately excellent in all fields related to academics and community.
Read 34 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1340 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Catholic Memorial High School
Private School
Waukesha, WI
9-12
101
12 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: The first three years here have been the most amazing experience. I love coming here every day and how good the teachers are at preparing us for college. There are always lots of people here to put a smile on your face every day. The caring nature here as well as the faith connection is so amazing and I am very proud to be a Crusader! Also, the strong emphasis on the fact that this school is a living memorial to the members of the Waukesha community who serve and have served for our country. I am always very proud of what we stand for as a school.
Read 101 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A
College Prep
1380 Average SAT
29 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
The Madeira School
Private School
McLean, VA
9-12
59
Alum: When I picture my "happy place," Madeira is it! I credit the school with shaping me into the woman I am today. I was able to be the truest version of myself while I attended Madeira. I was challenged academically, but in an environment where I felt comfortable to excel. The friends I made at Madeira have been lifelong friends--some were even bridesmaids in my wedding. The co-curriculum experience is also monumental. The internships I had as a junior and senior in high school shaped my college studies and eventual career path. If I had a daughter, without a shadow of a doubt, she would be a Madeira girl.
Read 59 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
319 Students
10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Eastbrook Academy
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
PK, K-12
26
13 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Freshman: I love the family like atmosphere coming from homeschooling I feel like it was easier to get accustomed to. Small class sizes make learning and asking questions easier. I feel accepted by my classmates and my teachers are great. It is very diverse, which was perfect for my diverse upbringing. One thing that I did notice, however is that students who have been going to Eastbrook, since a young age, have lost some of their...school spirit? But that is understandable if you have been going to school with the same people for 8+ years. Overall Eastbrook is a wonderful school. The learning is definitely rigorous, but if you apply yourself you can succeed. In each class there are things that can be improved, but the good heavily outweighs the bad. The staff and authority are calm and rational. Behavioral standard of honor and respect are high, but achievable. God is emphasized in everything we do and we are encouraged daily to grow closer and become more like him.
Read 26 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1250 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Notre Dame de la Baie Academy
Private School
Green Bay, WI
9-12
165
14 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Notre Dame has a great sense of community that I thoroughly enjoyed throughout my four years. It is easy to find a place to fit in with the large sports teams and many extracurriculars. Overall, I will never forget all the memories I made at NDA!
Read 165 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1370 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Christian Life School
Private School
Kenosha, WI
PK, K-12
100
15 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: I have had seven children go through Christian Life for their entire pre-collegiate careers; the oldest began there in kindergarten in 1991 and the youngest will graduate next year. The experience has been uniformly wonderful. Each has been excellently prepared for the demands of college life, but--of far more long-term importance--each has been nurtured as an individual and encouraged to develop into a balanced, creative, thoughtful, spiritual, compassionate person. Thank you, Christian Life School!
Read 100 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1350 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Thomas More High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
129
16 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: If you look at St. Thomas More you would think that this seems like a school I want my child to attend and going here for 4 years I would say yes you are correct. This school has everything! We have a variety of sports and clubs that we as the students can get involved in. The culture here is lovely we have a mix of Spanish, African American, Native American, and American culture. This school is very diverse and open to everyone which is a great thing. Another good thing about St. Thomas More is the education we are able to get. The courses are challenging, but they prepare you for college. A few things that I wish they could change is getting better teachers that know what they are doing not some random teacher you find in a public high school. Another thing I wish they would have helped us practice and be ready for the ACT. Even though there might be a few things that should be changed this school is still great! It has made me the person I am today.
Read 129 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1160 Average SAT
24 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Pius XI High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
170
17 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Pius XI Catholic High School gave me the best possible high school experience for me personally. The staff is incredible, and the students are extremely welcoming. At Pius XI, teachers and faculty engage with their students to form a wonderful relationship. Faith and Catholic values are encouraged and well-shown at this great institution. Pius XI has been a great experience for me. I have learned so much from their strong academics, compassionate teaching and values, and will carry out what I learned into my future. I am very proud to say that I go to Pius XI Catholic High School. It is very different from most, being known nationally for their fine arts department, being one of the most diverse high schools in Wisconsin, and being a place that I can call home.
Read 170 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1250 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Lourdes High School
Private School
Oshkosh, WI
9-12
15
18 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Alum: My experience was a bit different in the Lourdes Academy HighSchool. The diversity was very small and I personally didn’t get involved in any clubs because there was very few of them. However, you could make your own club up with a teacher permission which i believe is really cool. Lourdes Academy is best for helping you do good in the community and to help those in need. Along with good class that will help you in the future. One thing I would change is dresscode because I am a strong believer that how one dresses is how they express themselves to one another. I also believe that dresscode is valued more important than academics and I don’t think that’s right. This is my personal review on Lourdes Academy, but if you love the small community environment then this school is the place!!
Read 15 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1300 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Newman Catholic High School
Private School
Wausau, WI
PK, 6-12
39
19 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Parent: As a parent, I loved that my student was able to get to know the teachers on a one on one basis! They really care about the students education!
Read 39 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1210 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Martin Luther High School
Private School
Greendale, WI
9-12
79
20 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: After attending Martin Luther High School for almost four years, I have seen a dramatic impact the school's faculty and curriculum has left on me. The teachers in this school continuously reached out to me, making sure I was doing okay. I was convinced by many of my peers to join the wrestling team, and three years later I am the captain of other people I now call brothers and sisters. Leadership was not the only thing that Martin Luther taught me. I learned the true meaning of commitment, hard work, and the importance of academics. The courses provided in the school curriculum are challenging ones that prepare students for college as well as the common hardships of life. Had I not attended this assiduous school, many opportunities that I have now, would not be available to me. In conclusion, Martin Luther High School is one of the greatest educational institutions to ever be established.
Read 79 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
A-
College Prep
1480 Average SAT
26 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Joseph Catholic Academy
Private School
Kenosha, WI
K-12
86
21 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I have been attending St. Joseph Catholic Academy since the 5th grade and I feel very prepared to take on college, socially and academically. This school has so many options of different things to do whether it comes to sports, clubs, theater, J-term options, they have everything! Academically as well, a wide range of classes are offered from regular, to honors, to rigorous AP classes.
Read 86 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
B+
College Prep
1310 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
St. Catherine's High School
Private School
Racine, WI
6-12
40
22 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: I love attending St. Catherine's because of its traditions and diverse student population. There are so many activities to get involved in including sports, clubs, and service projects; you just have to take the initiative! The academics are challenging and the teachers are dedicated and really care about the students and prepare us for college. At 150 years old, the school is old but has character and many stairs. Because so many alumni visit and attend sporting events, I wish the school could build an elevator so everyone can keep coming back to support their alma mater.
Read 40 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
B+
College Prep
1240 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Review Your School
Aquinas High School
Private School
La Crosse, WI
9-12
78
23 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Aquinas High School has been a positive part of my life. I have enjoyed my high school experience at Aquinas. The school truly prepares you for college with the work load and responsibility you have to learn. There are many classes to take that challenge you including AP and Honors classes. The athletics and extracurricular activities at Aquinas make the experience of attending this school a fun one. There are so many opportunities to be involved and make a difference. The environment of Aquinas makes it a one of a kind place to be. The Catholic community makes all students feel welcome. When attending Aquinas and even after graduation, you truly feel like part of the Aquinas family.
Read 78 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
B+
College Prep
1410 Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Regis High School
Private School
Eau Claire, WI
6-12
10
24 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Wonderful school! Obviously less resources than that of a public school but well worth the tuition to come here. Students are all tightly knit and cordial. Helps you keep your faith in the forefront. Athletics have a hard working and pride-filled culture. Would recommend!
Read 10 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
B+
College Prep
— Average SAT
27 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes
Wisconsin Lutheran High School
Private School
Milwaukee, WI
9-12
243
25 Best College Prep Private High Schools in Wisconsin
Senior: Wisconsin Lutheran High School is an exceptional school for any student looking to challenge themselves academically, get involved in extra curricular activities, and be constantly enveloped in a Christian environment. Due to the versatility of the school and the willingness of the teacher and administration, I've been able to experience choir, basketball, STEM curriculum, student council, A/V club, book club, steel band, mission trips to Arizona and Zambia, the Civil Rights Tour, AP classes, and so much more! This school provides amazing opportunities for all of its students in academics, athletics, and fine arts. I'm glad to be able to call Wisco my home.
Read 243 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
B+
College Prep
1260 Average SAT
25 Average ACT
View Nearby Homes

1 of 4

University School of Milwaukee

The Prairie School

Marquette University High School

Divine Savior Holy Angels High School

Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart

Dominican High School

Bishop Ireton High School

Madison Country Day School

Xavier High School

Wayland Academy

University Lake School

St. Lawrence Seminary High School

Catholic Memorial High School

The Madeira School

Eastbrook Academy

Notre Dame de la Baie Academy

Christian Life School

St. Thomas More High School

Pius XI High School

Lourdes High School

Newman Catholic High School

Martin Luther High School

St. Joseph Catholic Academy

St. Catherine's High School

Aquinas High School

Regis High School

Wisconsin Lutheran High School