Skip to Main Content

2022 Best Private Schools in the Indianapolis Area

Best schools
  • Most diverse
  • Best teachers
  • College prep
  • Largest
  • Niche standout schools
  • Best schools
  • Most diverse
  • Best teachers
  • College prep
  • Largest
  • Best for STEM
  • Niche standout schools
  • Best for the arts
  • Best for athletes
  • Best districts

1 through 25 of 237 results

237 results

  1. #1 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Park Tudor School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    84 Niche users give it an average review of 4.3 stars.

    Featured Review: Freshman says This school is excellent! I am currently a freshman and i have never felt more at home. There is however a concern that there are not in enough AP courses. I do not find this a problem because if you....

    Read 84 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A+,

    Students: 950,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 7 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  2. #2 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    International School of Indiana

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    84 Niche users give it an average review of 4 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says We sent our pre-K child to this school, with intentions of leave him there for a few years until we bought a house in which we would switch him to that school district. Regardless of where we move....

    Read 84 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A+,

    Students: 500,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 5 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  3. #3 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    University High School of Indiana

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    CARMEL, IN,

    9-12,

    59 Niche users give it an average review of 4.3 stars.

    Featured Review: Junior says University High School is not the school for everyone, but it's perfect for the student determined to expand their horizons and improve. The freedom and variety of extracurriculars, along with the....

    Read 59 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A+,

    Students: 304,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 9 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  4. #4 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    119 Niche users give it an average review of 4.1 stars.

    Featured Review: Junior says The school has been nothing but extraordinary. It is one which gives a vast span academic rigor and the 11:1 student-faculty ratio gives an amazing opportunity for one-on-one student teacher time.....

    Read 119 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A+,

    Students: 734,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 11 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  5. #5 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Cathedral High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    211 Niche users give it an average review of 4.4 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says Cathedral is more of a "community" than anything. It take a village to raise responsible students and Cathedral definitely does their part developing young adolescents into college prepared young....

    Read 211 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A+,

    Students: 1,067,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 10 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  6. #6 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Heritage Christian School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    168 Niche users give it an average review of 4.3 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says I've been at Heritage ever since I was in Kindergarten and now I will be a Senior in High School! The quality of the school overall is excellent. You can tell how well the teachers truly care about...For a private Christian school, the academics are great! Though Heritage does not offer the same spread of APs as larger public schools, there are still plenty of advanced course offerings and...The teachers are all willing to sit down and chat about any problems students could be having, whether it be in their personal or academic life. Overall, Heritage is a tight-knit community and a....

    Read 168 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 1,465,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 14 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  7. #7 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Eman Schools

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    FISHERS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    13 Niche users give it an average review of 4 stars.

    Featured Review: Sophomore says Eman Schools is a diverse school in which there are many opportunities for the students to learn new things about the world and their religion, Islam. Although Eman School is a private school, it....

    Read 13 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 342,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 10 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  8. #8 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    St. Theodore Guerin High School

    Private School,

    NOBLESVILLE, IN,

    9-12,

    172 Niche users give it an average review of 4.2 stars.

    Featured Review: Alum says Outstanding Catholic High School in the heart of Hamilton County! As an alumni, I have so much love for this Catholic Community. The students, staff, families and community supporters are what make....

    Read 172 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 733,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 14 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  9. #9 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Cardinal Ritter High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    7-12,

    164 Niche users give it an average review of 3.9 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says I have enjoyed my time spent at Cardinal Ritter High School. I was enrolled in the seventh grade, and I have attended Cardinal Ritter up till my senior year. The environment that encompasses Cardinal....

    Read 164 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 635,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 14 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  10. #10 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    MTI School of Knowledge

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    12 Niche users give it an average review of 3.5 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says Mti School of knowledge is a muslim school which teaches students from K-12 about various subjects like math, physics,computer,govenment,etc, make sure the students uphold good moral values/ethics,....

    Read 12 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 312,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 10 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  11. #11 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Bishop Chatard High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    133 Niche users give it an average review of 4.2 stars.

    Featured Review: Alum says I loved the atmosphere and the high standards we were held to being in a private catholic school. Everyone was always so accepting of one another no matter how different each person was. The faculty....

    Read 133 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 714,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 13 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  12. #12 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Roncalli High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    229 Niche users give it an average review of 4.1 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says Everyday, I am so thankful I can attend Roncalli High School. Roncalli has provided many great lessons about service to others and my faith, fulfilling what it really is to be a Catholic school. It....

    Read 229 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A,

    Students: 1,141,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 14 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  13. #13 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Covenant Christian High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    146 Niche users give it an average review of 4.5 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says Covenant is an incredible school. Not only do they enable to students to thrive academically in whatever they’re interested in, but they also cultivate a Christian Spiritual growth environment for....

    Read 146 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 365,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 11 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  14. #14 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Colonial Christian School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    13 Niche users give it an average review of 4.5 stars.

    Featured Review: Alum says Went here for high school all four years. It was an amazing experience that allowed me to get to know my classmates and teachers. The best part was that they all cared about me and my well-being and....

    Read 13 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 211,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 10 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  15. #15 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Scecina Memorial High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    95 Niche users give it an average review of 4.2 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says Scecina's strength is its small size and strong community. For many kids, the opportunities to play sports is a top priority for choosing Scecina. Although it was not ours, our son has flourished in....

    Read 95 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 441,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 14 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  16. #16 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Horizon Christian School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    35 Niche users give it an average review of 4.1 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says Horizon has been a wonderful experience for our family. Smaller classroom sizes, teachers who are genuinely concerned for student growth are a huge plus. There are also opportunities to be....

    Read 35 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 288,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 9 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  17. #17 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Indiana Academy

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    CICERO, IN,

    9-12,

    24 Niche users give it an average review of 3.7 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says This school has the most loving teachers and staff. That alone trickles down to every aspect of the schools education. Four of my children have now attended/graduated from there, and the remaining....

    Read 24 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 115,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 7 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  18. #18 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Lutheran High School of Indianapolis

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    115 Niche users give it an average review of 4.2 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says Choosing Lutheran was the best decision we could have made for our family! The boys are getting the academic push they need in the classroom as well as more one on one attention from teachers because...The kids are able to be involved in a number of different activities and the small school allows them to feel more a part of a family then just a number in a crowd. They are freshman, sophomores,...Lutheran is more than a school, it is a family. It is a community that welcomed us in as strangers and instantly made us feel at home. It was the best decision we could have made..

    Read 115 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 226,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 14 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  19. #19 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Cornerstone Baptist Academy

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    17 Niche users give it an average review of 4.5 stars.

    Featured Review: Middle School Student says As a student in 7th grade, Cornerstone Baptist Academy has changed my life. Cornerstone Baptist Academy has been such a blessing to me and my family. There is nothing negative to say about....

    Read 17 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 75,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 6 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  20. #20 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Traders Point Christian Schools

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    WHITESTOWN, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    58 Niche users give it an average review of 4.2 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says I have been going to Traders Point since the three's program and am now graduating how crazy is that. While I've been at this school it has helped me build my faith as a Christian. With teachers that....

    Read 58 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 650,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 12 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  21. #21 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Crosspointe Christian Academy

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    22 Niche users give it an average review of 4.6 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says I started my 7th grade son in January of 2022. This could have been a very difficult transition. Instead, the administration, church and faculty embraced him and helped him flow right into the....

    Read 22 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 239,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 13 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  22. #22 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Calvary Christian School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    10 Niche users give it an average review of 4 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says The thing I like most about Calvary Christian School is the family atmosphere that there is. All the teachers and staff members are always warm, welcoming, and loving. The school is filled with....

    Read 10 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 228,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 12 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  23. #23 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Providence Cristo Rey High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    9-12,

    39 Niche users give it an average review of 4 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says Providence Cristo Rey has provided my daughter with a high quality and well rounded education. The teachers demonstrate a high level of personal concern for the students' well being. They....

    Read 39 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 186,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 11 to 1,

    View nearby homesVirtual tour
  24. #24 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Tabernacle Christian School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    MARTINSVILLE, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    11 Niche users give it an average review of 4.3 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says Amazing teachers and staff and great academics! The lunches also help support local restaurants, so it helps the community and it tastes good..

    Read 11 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 270,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 18 to 1,

    View nearby homes
  25. #25 Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis Area.

    Central Christian Academy

    Private School,

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN,

    PK, K-12,

    17 Niche users give it an average review of 3.8 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says I have a few that have graduated from Baptist Academy (Central Christian Acadmey), and one who still attends. The school has been around for the many years, however the teachers are Newer. the teachers are there for the reason, they are kind and hopeful to the children...they pray for them and with them and...the students here are many different backgrounds, and getting more diverse as the time goes on....We have sports, the coaches will include the students in some way in the sports, if the students want to... Being part of the IHSAA, we encourage students to participate The school accepts the vouchers, and allows families with lower income to send and invest in their childs education. The school will help your family if there is a way, they will help you find it!.

    Read 17 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B,

    Students: 197,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 12 to 1,

    View nearby homes
loading indicator

Showing results 1 through 25 of 237