Compare Christian Schools in the New York City Area

Best Schools

222 results

Trinity School
Private School
New York, NY
K-12
51
#1 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: Trinity has been an amazing experience for my daughter. She came in 9th grade from an all girls school (Brearley) and my daughter had the fortune of choosing between Trinity, Dalton, Horace Mann and Exeter. We were worried about the academic intensity but my daughter was well-prepared by her time at Brearley and thrived in an environment where students are constantly challenged and pushed to do their very best. She loves her classmates, and finds the school much more diverse than Brearley. Overall a great experience so far!
Read 51 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,001 Students
6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Friends Seminary
Private School
New York, NY
K-12
40
#2 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: My daughter and son graduated from Friends Seminary (both attended from Grades 7-12). The community was a wonderful place for our family and the school prepared our children well for college. Particularly, what attracted our family to Friends, is its commitment to the Quaker tenets of diversity and service. The school is always evolving to fulfill the needs of its student body. We heard that they just opened a Center for Peace, Equity and Justice at the school....wish our children were still there to utilize it!
Read 40 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
754 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
The Stony Brook School
Private School
Stony Brook, NY
7-12
47
#3 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Junior: The academics are challenging but rewarding for those that are looking for a challenge. There are AP and college-level classes that certainly help students prepare for college. The teachers are very competent, responsible and try to develop deep relationships with their students. The student body is very diverse, with some coming from Asia, Africa, Europe and South America. The teachers are quite diverse too, most of which are not from Long Island! The food, made by Sage Dining, can be hit-or-miss. Some foods can be questionable, but it is mostly decent. The school is making an emphasis on improving the facilities of the school but need to fix some dorms.
Read 47 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
361 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Dwight Global Online School
Online School
New York, NY
7-12
6
Junior: This was my first year doing online school, and as a junior, I was worried about meeting all of the expectations that come with 11th grade. However, all of my classes, teachers, and college counselors have been extremely helpful. Communication with teachers is easy, and the live classes are very beneficial. I have enjoyed all of my classes and genuinely been challenged this year. This program allows me to pursue my passion for dance while getting a serious education. I definitely recommend this online program!
Read 6 Reviews
NG
Overall Niche Grade
860 Students
22:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Friends Academy
Private School
Locust Valley, NY
PK, K-12
28
#4 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Small class size, pro-active teachers who are always willing to make time for you. Each HS grade is comprised of approximately 100 students and you know almost everyone in your grade and the entire high school. I learned so much about myself and how fortunate I am as community service is required at Friends. It speaks to one of the underlying Quaker premises of treating others as you wish to treated. Spending time working (cleaning, cooking, food prep and kitchen work) at a Friends Seminary homeless shelter and then in the evening interacting with the men was ENLIGHTENING!
Read 28 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
750 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Grace Church School
Private School
New York, NY
PK, K-12
18
#5 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Grace provided me with what I believe to be the best possible high school experience I could have had the privilege to attend. Speaking of privelge, the only issues I personally encountered as a middle-class student on scholarship, is the ignorance, racially, socially, economically, of some of the more affluent students. While I am aware that these students are the reason why Grace sustains itself financially, I feel as though my schools has a proclivity towards having students leave Grace better than when they arrived. I believe this could apply to the subject and lack of conversation about financial privileges.
Read 18 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
727 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Brooklyn Friends School
Private School
Brooklyn, NY
PK, K-12
46
#6 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: BFS has provided our two kids an incredible home both academically and socially. Our older daughter has not only become an excellent scholar who's been taught to think analytically and creatively, but who's learned how to see the world with clarity as far as privilege around race and class, how to negotiate conflict, and how to take action to make her world a better place with both burning passion and peaceful compassion. Our younger child, who isn't as academically motivated and learns more kinetically, has also been embraced and supported. There's a good balance of academics and core values, and service to community is emphasized. There's great diversity in the student body and in the teaching staff and administration. With diversity comes challenges and often misunderstanding, and the school has faced these challenges head-on, not always with perfection but with commitment, passion, and consistent effort. We love BFS and feel lucky to have found it.
Read 46 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
898 Students
6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Grace Christian Academy
Private School
Merrick, NY
K-12
16
#7 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: We wanted a school that represents our worldview most effectively - one in which the Gospel is of most importance, one that demands rigorous learning, one that presents all sides of issues while instilling a sound Biblical worldview, and one that equips their students with the skills necessary to compete and excel in life. We got all of the above with Grace Christian Academy and more! We would not send our kids anywhere else.
Read 16 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
161 Students
6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Eastern Christian School
Private School
Midland Park, NJ
PK, K-12
117
#8 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: I have gone to Eastern Christian School all of my life. Eastern Christian helps nurture students to become the best person they can be to be a role model for Christ to those around them. I love the friendliness of the teachers at my school. Ever since pre-K, my teachers have always supported me not only through my assignments, but also through the struggles of daily life. I love how Eastern Christian has so many engaging activities and sports. My teachers are so funny and creative in every way! The only change I would like to see in Eastern Christian is an Eastern Christian college. That would be incredible!
Read 117 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
822 Students
13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Timothy Christian School
Private School
Piscataway, NJ
PK, K-12
43
#9 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: Strong & Christ centered academics. Biblical worldview integrated into all subjects. My children are ahead academically-performing well above grade level in reading & math. Parent participation is valued & encouraged! Athletic, academic & interest based after school clubs are available for ALL grades. MS & HS have strong STEM programs & a competitive Robotics Team. HS athletes compete in the Greater Middlesex Conference. Campus style allows students to spend more time outdoors. Teachers are committed to spiritual & academic growth. The teachers are truly invested in their students - as evidenced by a high rate of alumni returning to serve & teach at their school.
Read 43 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
462 Students
13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
- 2019 Best Boarding High Schools
- 2019 Best All-Girls Schools
- 2019 Best Private Schools
Long Island Lutheran Middle & High School
Private School
Brookville, NY
6-12
111
#10 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Alum: I am an alumnus of LuHi. What a fabulous school and amazing place to spend my high school years. I was absolutely prepared for college and career, and I went to school each day knowing I was part of the “LuHi Family.” You won’t meet a more caring, dedicated faculty/staff/administration anywhere! I am so incredibly thankful for this school and I cannot wait to send my 2 children here when they are old enough!
Read 111 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
512 Students
10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Trinity Christian School
Private School
Montville, NJ
K-12
10
#11 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Alum: Trinity Christian School provides a warm environment for children to learn. They engage the students academically, socially, spiritually, mentally, and athletically. I would love to see Trinity cater more to students who struggle academically.
Read 10 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
173 Students
10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
American Christian School
Private School
Succasunna, NJ
PK, K-12
17
#12 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: All three of my children attend ACS. This was the best decision my husband and I made. The academics are amazing - the students are getting into their top choice colleges and beating all the national stats. The school is growing which is notable since so many Christian and Catholic schools are closing in NJ. It has also been offering so many extras for my kids to be exposed to and I am 100% sure that my children are growing in their walk with the Lord thanks to ACS and its awesome faculty.
Read 17 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
215 Students
9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Martin Luther School
Private School
Maspeth, NY
6-12
15
#13 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Junior: Martin Luther is a small school with a lot of attention on all students. The teacher involvement is really high and we have a number of international students making it a pretty diverse environment
Read 15 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
203 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Our Savior New American School
Private School
Centereach, NY
PK, K-12
28
#14 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: I have 2 boys in the school. The oldest is graduating. It takes a village to raise kids and that is what this school is for us . The oldest scored 1500 on SAT and 34 on ACT. Without amazing teachers this would not happen . The classes are small enough to give the maximum attention. Both boys have strived and I expect them to strive in whatever the do.
Read 28 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
191 Students
4:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
International Christian School
Private School
Brooklyn, NY
PK, K-12
13
#15 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Great school to go to, amazing staff and faculty. ICS is an amazing place to attend, there truly care about the students learning, and not just knowing the answers. Most Christian schools use only the book, and use the provided tests with the book. That's not the case for ICS, they make there own guides and tests so the students actually learn, and not just memorize the answers but understands the answers. The Principle is a great lady and her husband, who is the pastor, is an amazing, christian man who truly cares about God's will in his life, and the students life.
Read 13 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
173 Students
11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Demetrios School
Private School
Astoria, NY
PK, K-12
11
#16 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: GREAT STAFF, WONDERFUL STUDENTS. AN OVERALL SAFE ENVIRONMENT FOR A CHILD TO THRIVE. MY CHILDREN LOVE THEIR SCHOOL AND ARE EXCITED TO ATTEND CLASS EVERYDAY.
Read 11 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
601 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Bergen County Christian Academy
Private School
Hackensack, NJ
PK, K-12
15
#17 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Alum: Graduating from Bergen County Christian Academy (formerly Hackensack Christian Schools) has prepared me exceptionally for college! I am now studying at a 4-year college to earn a degree in Communications. Bergen Christian teachers are hardworking, dedicated, and loving instructors who will go out of their way to make sure all students understand every lesson. They will also give one on one instruction if needed. This, along with the incorporated Bible classes and emphasis on spiritual growth is what makes BCCA unique. The administration tirelessly works in order to provide a well-balanced and strong education and are constantly progressing the school for the future. I am extremely grateful that my parents sacrificially sent me to Bergen County Christian Academy from Pre-K through 12th grade!
Read 15 Reviews
A-
Overall Niche Grade
168 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Calvary Academy
Private School
Lakewood, NJ
PK, K-12
20
#18 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Niche User: My nephew attended Calvary Academy and I can honestly say that they were instrumental in helping to mold and shape him into the man he is today. The teachers love their students and pour into their lives. They challenge them to strive for excellence and place a strong emphasis on character and on becoming who God has called you to be. When he went off to the University, he was well equipped and excelled in his studies. Many of his Freshmen friends struggled with all of the paper writing, but he had such a strong foundation in MLA writing format from his Calvary training and he thrived. I am thankful for Calvary and for their commitment to investing in future generations. This is a great school and worth every penny!
Read 20 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
250 Students
11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Victory Christian Academy
Private School
East Patchogue, NY
PK, K-12
14
#19 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Victory Christian Academy provides an overall personal relationship between faculty and students. It is an extremely small school and I have found it to be a rewarding experience.

If I would like to see anything changed, I wish there were more activities and opportunities to participate in. However, it has prepared me for the next step in my educational journey.
Read 14 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
73 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Kearny Christian Academy
Private School
Kearny, NJ
K-12
3
#20 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Niche User: The school was small, so everyone knew each other easily. It became easy for everyone to become friends.
Read 3 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
135 Students
11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Parsippany Christian School
Private School
Parsippany, NJ
PK, K-12
17
#21 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Parsippany Christian School's academics are what I think they should be known for. I personally had trouble learning math in a public school. The curriculum Common Core was confusing but a PCS the math teachers are excellent and get straight to the point. As for the other classes they are just as excellent. This school is very diverse. Also an advantage is that since this school will be considered small-medium, as a student you have an advantage to work with the teacher one on one. As for things to change I believe this school should have a lot more activities and sports. As the teachers and students should have a more compassionate and loving spirit. Regard this academically I believe one will be ready for college.
Read 17 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
151 Students
9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Valley Stream Christian Academy
Private School
Valley Stream, NY
K-12
13
#22 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Valley Stream Christian Academy is a great, close-knit school. The teachers here care a lot about their students and are always willing to help their students. Staff and faculty are great. This school offers a safe, healthy learning environment for students of all ages. It not only prepares students academically but also challenges them spiritually with great Bible classes.
Read 13 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
150 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Review Your School
Smithtown Christian School
Private School
Smithtown, NY
PK, K-12
57
#23 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Niche User: Smithtown Christian School is the top tier of private schools, not just on Long Island but across the United States. Through this school students can build an education that is surrounded by a Biblical Worldview without avoiding topics that are relevant to today's culture and society. This school equips students to go into the world and be examples of Christ's love towards one another!

I would recommend this amazing school to anyone interested in private education through all grade levels!
Read 57 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
424 Students
10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Evangel Christian School
Private School
Long Island City, NY
PK, K-12
84
#24 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Parent: Evangel Christian School is not just a school its a family. My 3 children attended ECS and loved their teachers and were also part of the National Honor Society. Teachers take time to work with students and offer help after school as well. Administration is always willing to listen and are sure to offer the support that is needed to see your children do well. They were also able to earn college credits with Nyack that Evangel offered and were accepted to great colleges and have graduated and earned their degrees. They are now working in their professions. My children have also maintained close relationship with their classmates and still are like family.. If you are looking for a school that will love and support your children like you do Evangel is the school.
Read 84 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
463 Students
15:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Our Saviour Lutheran School
Private School
Bronx, NY
PK, K-12
13
#25 Best Christian High Schools in New York City Area
Senior: Being at our saviour has been a great experience for me. Our saviour Lutheran is full of people who you can converse with and lend you a hand when you need help. This school is very family oriented and the teachers help you to prepare yourself for college. The most I like about our saviour was that you can always find someone to lean on to talk about something that's bothering you or anything else. The one thing I would change is the amount of sports for the girls there's not that much activity for the girls. Anything but that our saviour is pretty good school.
Read 13 Reviews
B+
Overall Niche Grade
182 Students
11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Friends Academy
Private School
Locust Valley, NY
PK, K-12
28
Senior: Small class size, pro-active teachers who are always willing to make time for you. Each HS grade is comprised of approximately 100 students and you know almost everyone in your grade and the entire high school. I learned so much about myself and how fortunate I am as community service is required at Friends. It speaks to one of the underlying Quaker premises of treating others as you wish to treated. Spending time working (cleaning, cooking, food prep and kitchen work) at a Friends Seminary homeless shelter and then in the evening interacting with the men was ENLIGHTENING!
Read 28 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
750 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
The Willow School
Private School
Gladstone, NJ
PK, K-8
13
Parent: Enrolling our children at Willow is the best thing that we have ever done for our family. All three of our children, who range from middle school to preschool, adore their teachers and their classmates. They are excited to go school, which is no wonder when every aspect of the curriculum has been intentionally designed to ignite curiosity, creativity, and problem solving skills. I did not truly appreciate how innovative the curriculum is until I watched Beyond Measure! We are also thrilled that school partners with us on our children’s character education. The Virtues Program, which is implemented daily at Morning Gathering, teaches the children about the real world applications of ethical and moral behavior through lessons from teachers and students. It is my favorite part of the day, and I often sit in on the morning gatherings to listen to their discussions!
Read 13 Reviews
A
Overall Niche Grade
90 Students
4:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes

1 of 9

Trinity School

Friends Seminary

The Stony Brook School

Dwight Global Online School

Friends Academy

Grace Church School

Brooklyn Friends School

Grace Christian Academy

Eastern Christian School

Timothy Christian School

Long Island Lutheran Middle & High School

Trinity Christian School

American Christian School

Martin Luther School

Our Savior New American School

International Christian School

St. Demetrios School

Bergen County Christian Academy

Calvary Academy

Victory Christian Academy

Kearny Christian Academy

Parsippany Christian School

Valley Stream Christian Academy

Smithtown Christian School

Evangel Christian School

Our Saviour Lutheran School

Friends Academy

The Willow School