2022 Best Christian Schools in the New York City Area

Trinity School

• Private School
• NEW YORK, NY
• K-12
• Rating 4.03 out of 5  72 reviews

Junior: My overall school experience has been very positive! The teachers(with 1 or 2 exceptions) and academics have been outstanding so far, and it seems like I can do whatever I put my mind to here. There are plenty of options for clubs, and plenty of motivated students who participate in them. When I first entered the school, I thought a lot of the students would be aloof trust-fund kids. However, for the majority of students, that thankfully doesn't hold true. My only 2 complaints are: 1)the math curriculum, which for me is too repetitive and not challenging enough; and 2)the behavior of the administration(especially during covid), which can be paternalistic at times...Read 72 Reviews

• grade A+

• 1,001 Students
• 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Friends Academy

• Private School
• LOCUST VALLEY, NY
• PK, K-12
• Rating 4.42 out of 5  90 reviews

Parent: We have a rising Kindergartener, who finished his first year at Friends in Pre-K. As a parent, and an educational professional, I personally could not have designed a better experience for my son, especially during the COVID-related shut down. We initially chose Friends for our son because we wanted more for him; we wanted him to learn through experience, to develop thoughts of his own and more importantly to be part of a community that subscribed to similar values as ours. Our son’s first year was FANTASTIC! Notably, while everyone was scrambling to figure things out when the State shut down, our son was being educated and supported in a way that was developmentally appropriate, fun and responsive. The transition to virtual school was so seamless, that it seemed like it was planned for (it might have been). More importantly, the teachers were open and responsive to feedback, and continued to tweak the new modality regularly. We are looking forward to many more years at Friends!...Read 90 Reviews

• grade A+

• 706 Students
• 5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

The Stony Brook School

• Private School
• STONY BROOK, NY
• 7-12
• Rating 4.35 out of 5  74 reviews

Alum: I would not expect a fuller and more meaningful four years at a high school. As an international student, I think I have regarded The Stony Brook School as my second home over the four years. Teachers on this campus are very dedicated and loving, willing to do everything in their ability to make you better. My peers at the Stony Brook School are no less knowledgable, intelligent, and motivated than students in any other elite private high school. Not to emphasize figures, but over 36 percent of my class got into US News top 25 universities in the nation. Most importantly, SBS is a place that motivates you to explore more about the world, whether it be science, math, humanities, or arts. My intellectual curiosity is cultivated here and I think I will benefit from this spirit throughout my college time and entire life. I feel grateful that I end up(whether it be God's will or pure randomness) at this magical place. I will definitely recommend this school to any friend!...Read 74 Reviews

• grade A+

• 446 Students
• 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Brooklyn Friends School

• Private School
• BROOKLYN, NY
• PK, K-12
• Rating 4.16 out of 5  57 reviews

Parent: Great education centered around integrating social justice within the curriculum, which starts very early. Extremely thoughtful and kind student body as a result. Teachers are wonderful, and nice parent community. ...The school could benefit greatly by finding the resources to add more robust extracurricular offerings and make much needed improvements to its lower and middle school building facilities. These are the two biggest areas where the school could grow. Otherwise it shines...Read 57 Reviews

• grade A+

• 898 Students
• 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Grace Church School

• Private School
• NEW YORK, NY
• PK, K-12
• Rating 4.07 out of 5  29 reviews

Senior: My experience at Grace Church School has been overall good. I believe that Grace has prepared me for the outside world and has given me opportunities of a lifetime. One thing the school needs to improve on is its diversity and antiracism practices. A student of color's school experience should not be deterred because of racist incidents at school. The school needs to support students of color more when these things occur. Outside of that experience, I'd say that I'd choose Grace again for the resources it has provided to help me be successful, the teachers and faculty always willing to help, the community building, and the number of opportunities...Read 29 Reviews

• grade A+

• 727 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Long Island Lutheran Middle & High School

• Private School
• BROOKVILLE, NY
• 6-12
• Rating 4.24 out of 5  148 reviews

Alum: I graduated from LuHi 2 years ago and I am so thankful that I had the opportunity to go there. LuHi taught me so many skills that are invaluable to me. I also had the opportunity to take electives that ultimately pointed me in the direction of my major and future career. It is not something that I ever saw myself doing and without my guidance counselor pushing me to try new things, flexibility in my schedule, and incredibly welcoming teachers, I certainly would have ended up down a different (and probably wrong) path...More important than all of this, LuHi taught me how to be a kind and empathetic person. I learned so many things I never knew I never knew from my diverse peers who were all from very different backgrounds. I have always said that even the people I was not friends with while at LuHi, I can without hesitation call good people. ...LuHi is a really really special place and I feel so blessed that I was able to spend 6 years there!Read 148 Reviews

• grade A+

• 428 Students
• 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Saint Demetrios School - Middle/High School

• Private School
• ASTORIA, NY
• PK, 6-12
• Rating 4.56 out of 5  18 reviews

Parent: Where has this school been all these years? Awesome school, my kids love it! Great families and children. Wish I would have found this school earlier for my oldest.Read 18 Reviews

• grade A+

• 700 Students
• 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Grace Christian Academy

• Private School
• MERRICK, NY
• K-12
• Rating 4.58 out of 5  33 reviews

Parent: Our experience at GCA has been outstanding! The Gospel is prominent and integrated into all academic and social life, while following its guidelines in disciplinary matters, making for some great discipleship. GCA's Classical approach is not only challenging but has equipped our kids to enter the college arena prepared and to face their culture's hostile worldview in a way that is Christ-like and well-informed. Drawing students in from the Bronx to Suffolk County and from over 45 different school districts, there is a reason so many families go to such lengths to be here. We would find it difficult to go anywhere else after experiencing a GCA education!...Read 33 Reviews

• grade A+

• 161 Students
• 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Timothy Christian School

• Private School
• PISCATAWAY, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 3.87 out of 5  76 reviews

Parent: TCS is a family-oriented school. This is our 4th year at the school, and we’ve loved it from the first day. We have an elementary student and middle schooler. The campus is historical in that it was a former military camp. The open campus is quite unique! Everyone at TCS is warm and welcoming. The teachers are excellent, and they are truly dedicated to making sure they get to know each student. Academics are at a high bar, but the spiritual and character development of the students is also a priority. The school really makes sure the students have a well-rounded experience. I really love the Carnegie Hall music program in the elementary school. The students learn music theory, explore music and cultures from around the world, begin their first instrument in 3rd grade and even go to Carnegie Hall in NYC for the program’s interactive concerts. TCS has a lot to offer! I truly encourage prospective families to stop in for a private tour or go to a preview day. You will be impressed!...Read 76 Reviews

• grade A+

• 368 Students
• 9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Hawthorne Christian Academy

• Private School
• HAWTHORNE, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 3.94 out of 5  51 reviews

Junior: Hawthorne Christian Academy specializes in Christian education for grades PreK through 12th. During my time there, I saw how much the teachers and students cared for Jesus and spreading the Gospel message to their students, peers, and families. However, I would say that some of the programs there are not as strong as they should be. The History and English programs are not as advanced...Read 51 Reviews

• grade A

• 437 Students
• 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

American Christian School

• Private School
• SUCCASUNNA, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 3.97 out of 5  30 reviews

Parent: When we send our children to school each day, we know they are surrounded by love, support and guidance from everyone they come across.Coming from years in public schools, I cannot begin to express the difference in the atmosphere and curriculum that ACS offers our kids.They are challenged every day in their education.The curriculum is demanding, but certainly rewarding as evidenced by their testing and college acceptance rates. The athletics program is fantastic!The clubs are limited only by what the kids are interested in.If a club does not exist, the kids are encouraged to help implement it.Most important is the manner in which the kids are encouraged to stand in their faith.Where else will you find kids running late to class because their voluntary Bible study went over because of someone needing prayer from their peers?I have seen some of the reviews complain about the facilities.What I care about is what happens inside those walls, not whether those walls need fresh paint!...Read 30 Reviews

• grade A

• 240 Students
• 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Somerset Bible Baptist Christian Academy

• Private School
• SOMERSET, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 1 out of 5  1 review

• grade A

• 79 Students
• 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Trinity Christian School

• Private School
• MONTVILLE, NJ
• K-12
• Rating 4.26 out of 5  19 reviews

Parent: There are different approaches to education, and parents have a variety of priorities when it comes to their children's education. If you are looking for Christian education for your child, TCS is the school. In addition to the Christian values taught in the classroom, TCS also offers a classical education. In my opinion, classical Christian education is the way to go! My wife and I decided to transfer our daughters to TCS three years ago, and we are impressed with the level of excellence and commitment of teachers and the staff. We highly recommend TCS!...Read 19 Reviews

• grade A

• 153 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Eastern Christian School

• Private School
• MIDLAND PARK, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 4.26 out of 5  132 reviews

Senior: Apart from a Christian education, which this school does very well, there are advantages and disadvantages to the small private school education offered by Eastern Christian. On one hand, students get lots of individual help and attention. On the other, there are far fewer opportunities and resources available to students as compared to a larger school. I wish I had been able to explore more clubs and activities during my time in high school, and I wish I was able to meet more people outside the typical private school demographic. However, I imagine the cultivation and support I was able to receive through this school would be hard to find anywhere else...Read 132 Reviews

• grade A

• 822 Students
• 13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Bergen County Christian Academy

• Private School
• HACKENSACK, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 3.35 out of 5  17 reviews

Alum: Graduating from Bergen County Christian Academy (formerly Hackensack Christian Schools) has prepared me exceptionally for college! I am now studying at a 4-year college to earn a degree in Communications. Bergen Christian teachers are hardworking, dedicated, and loving instructors who will go out of their way to make sure all students understand every lesson. They will also give one on one instruction if needed. This, along with the incorporated Bible classes and emphasis on spiritual growth is what makes BCCA unique. The administration tirelessly works in order to provide a well-balanced and strong education and are constantly progressing the school for the future. I am extremely grateful that my parents sacrificially sent me to Bergen County Christian Academy from Pre-K through 12th grade!...Read 17 Reviews

• grade A minus

• 168 Students
• 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Smithtown Christian School

• Private School
• SMITHTOWN, NY
• K-12
• Rating 4.15 out of 5  99 reviews

Parent: SCS teachers, administrators and staff are to be commended for their dedication, compassion and Christian faith in these challenging times with constantly evolving COVID-related health guidelines, distance learning cycles, quarantines and more. With a chance to look back at how SCS faced these obstacles and then reading about the frequent media reports of academic learning losses, mental health issues and absenteeism due to prolonged distance learning, I'm glad SCS decided to re-open to in-person instruction last Fall. It took faith-filled courage, backed by scientific knowledge that schools are not an infection incubator, to make this decision, and then faith and determination to see it through. Well done!...Read 99 Reviews

• grade A minus

• 306 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Calvary Academy

• Private School
• LAKEWOOD, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 4.94 out of 5  50 reviews

Parent: Calvary academy is an excellent school. I had 3 children attend and they have had experiences and academic achievements that have followed them through to higher education. They were loved and prayed for daily. Each of my children had exceptional spiritual experiences whether in class, sports or in the arts. Their teachers and coaches truly love and care for the students. I highly recommend sending your children to Calvary academy. The investment that you make will be worth it for years to come!...Read 50 Reviews

• grade A minus

• 230 Students
• 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Our Savior New American School

• Private School
• CENTEREACH, NY
• PK, K-12
• Rating 4.38 out of 5  65 reviews

Alum: Our Savior New American School has been my second home and family for 15 years. I started there in Pre-school and graduated high school. I love the christian values, faculty, and life long friendships this school provided for me. I am forever grateful for Our Savior and all those who dedicated their time and services here!...Read 65 Reviews

• grade A minus

• 155 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Victory Christian Academy

• Private School
• EAST PATCHOGUE, NY
• PK, K-12
• Rating 3.67 out of 5  15 reviews

Senior: I would definitely rate this school a 5/5. Not only do the students receive an excellent curricular education, but they also develop a deeper understanding of life and working with others. The overall environment is very healthy and promising. It is really the staff that serves as admirable role models for the students. It's safe to say I've met some of the best people at this school...Read 15 Reviews

• grade A minus

• 73 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Valley Stream Christian Academy

• Private School
• VALLEY STREAM, NY
• K-12
• Rating 3.85 out of 5  20 reviews

Senior: What I like about Valley Stream Christian Academy is the closeness that everyone has to each other. It is a very close-knit family dynamic. The teachers are amazing at what they do. They give every student the chance to take some time to understand the material before going forward with the work. Also, since it is a Christian school, administration incorporates the love of Jesus Christ into our daily school day. They have a Bible teacher that teaches the word in such a way that makes it easier to understand...Read 20 Reviews

• grade B+

• 150 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Our Saviour Lutheran School

• Private School
• BRONX, NY
• PK, K-12
• Rating 2.64 out of 5  14 reviews

Senior: Being at our saviour has been a great experience for me. Our saviour Lutheran is full of people who you can converse with and lend you a hand when you need help. This school is very family oriented and the teachers help you to prepare yourself for college. The most I like about our saviour was that you can always find someone to lean on to talk about something that's bothering you or anything else. The one thing I would change is the amount of sports for the girls there's not that much activity for the girls. Anything but that our saviour is pretty good school...Read 14 Reviews

• grade B+

• 182 Students
• 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Martin Luther School

• Private School
• MASPETH, NY
• 6-12
• Rating 3.88 out of 5  42 reviews

Parent: My son started 8th grade in Martin Luther School and his talent was quickly identified. He was placed in Biology and Algebra classes (HS level) instead of Science and Math. By the time he reached 9th grade, he already took Chemistry and Geometry classes. He was at 97th percentile at Evidence-Based Reading and Writing Score and overall, in the 94th percentile at PSAT 8/9 at the beginning of 9th grade. He is all set to take AP Biology as a 10th grader, which generally recommend to have Biology, chemistry, and Algebra 1 as prerequisite. On the other hand, MLS has summer program to help students who are struggling at some subjects. This school is for students with all academic levels and aims to unlock students’ talent! MLS has diversity student body with faith of all walks. I am very proud of the school and my son!...Read 42 Reviews

• grade B+

• 192 Students
• 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Abundant Life Academy

• Private School
• NUTLEY, NJ
• PK, 1-12
• Rating 4.03 out of 5  29 reviews

Senior: my experience at Abundant Life Avadeny has been wonderful! The staff really look out for their student. They really take the time to get to know you and pray for you. Teachers become more of a mentor rather than an authoritative figure. The students are hungry for God and his presence. there are various clubs/sports to get involved in. such as fine arts, worship team, STEM ,and many more...Read 29 Reviews

• grade B+

• 302 Students
• 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Greater New York Academy

• Private School
• WOODSIDE, NY
• 9-12
• Rating 3.55 out of 5  71 reviews

Alum: Greater New York Academy (GNYA) is a spirit-filled school with great teachers and religious activities, though lacks some crucial features such as a gymnasium, SAT/ACT test prep, and accommodations for special-needs students, most-likely a result of limited funding. Competing against public schools may not give GNYA the best rating, but as a place through which you could grow spiritually, academically, and mentally with a community of loving teachers who care, GNYA may score the highest...Read 71 Reviews

• grade B+

• 149 Students
• 13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio

Calvary Christian School

• Private School
• OLD BRIDGE, NJ
• PK, K-12
• Rating 3.95 out of 5  57 reviews

Senior: I came to Calvary in sixth grade, and it honestly has changed my life. In my almost seven years of being enrolled, I have grown closer to God and my fellow students, learning so much. I have always felt welcomed by both students and staff. Something we could improve upon would be having a janitorial staff working throughout the day, as well as possibly organizing school events better, with staff actively involved in students' lives. Although Calvary has done well in the latter portion thus far, maybe students uncomfortable with talking would be better handled with a formal staff member for this job in particular...Read 57 Reviews

• grade B+

• 300 Students
• 13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio