Skip to Main Content

2024 Best Catholic Schools in the Buffalo Area

1-25 of 42 results

  1. #3 Best Catholic High Schools in Buffalo Area.

    Bishop Timon-St. Jude High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    BUFFALO, NY,

    9-12,

    27 Niche users give it an average review of 4.3 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says After transferring in from another well known institution where you are just a #, we had no idea the unbelievable positive impact this school would have on our family and son. We learned alot about....

    Read 27 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 245,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 9 to 1,

  2. #4 Best Catholic High Schools in Buffalo Area.

    St. Francis High School

    Private School,

    HAMBURG, NY,

    9-12,

    91 Niche users give it an average review of 4.3 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says I had an incredibly memorable experience. I was encouraged to do as much as I can, regarding clubs and sports. I played volleyball all four years, and I'm very glad I did. I made close friend that I....

    Read 91 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 470,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 11 to 1,

  3. #5 Best Catholic High Schools in Buffalo Area.

    Nardin Academy

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    BUFFALO, NY,

    PK, K-12,

    232 Niche users give it an average review of 4 stars.

    Featured Review: Alum says I have had the immense privilege of graduating from all three Nardin Academy schools. I am a proud alum of the Montessori, Lower School, and High School. Throughout my youth, I was aware of what a....

    Read 232 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: A minus,

    Students: 913,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 10 to 1,

  4. #8 Best Catholic High Schools in Buffalo Area.

    Mount Mercy Academy

    Private School,

    BUFFALO, NY,

    9-12,

    137 Niche users give it an average review of 4 stars.

    Featured Review: Senior says My time as a Mercy Girl has completely transformed me from the nervous freshman who walked in through those blue doors into the confident young woman who will walk out through them in just a few....

    Read 137 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 181,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 6 to 1,

  5. #9 Best Catholic High Schools in Buffalo Area.

    St. Mary's High School

    Blue checkmark.

    Private School,

    LANCASTER, NY,

    9-12,

    76 Niche users give it an average review of 4.2 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says It is with great pleasure that I share the experience my family has had as part of the St. Mary's High School community. My son entered high school in 2020 amid the pandemic. We had no idea what to....

    Read 76 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 375,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 15 to 1,

  6. Notre Dame Academy

    Private School,

    BUFFALO, NY,

    PK, K-8,

    8 Niche users give it an average review of 3.5 stars.

    Featured Review: Parent says My school teaches me discipline, respect, and responsibility. I love my school because it has lots of facilities. There is a playground, a computer lab, library, science labs, prayer hall, and a...I also enjoy my school because it has some really cool teachers who make the lessons interesting and really make you want to work hard. I like school because I get to do things that can't do at home...My school is special because we have a unique system that allows us as students to make our way to a better future. We have a community of respect and love for everyone no matter their race or skin...I am not just a number at my school. I really do feel like it’s a home away from home. My teachers know me and I feel comfortable communicating with them..

    Read 8 reviews.

    Overall Niche Grade: B+,

    Students: 500,

    Student-Teacher Ratio: 19 to 1,

Not sure what schools you are zoned for?Find out by exploring our school boundary maps. Look up public schools and districts by address or ZIP code.

Showing results 1 through 25 of 42