2023 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.43 out of 5  141 reviews

Senior: Regis is not just a place for academic excellence, but a place where learning go hand-in-hand with personal development and a drive to be impactful. Peers are highly motivated and inspiring, while the dedication of teachers is obvious. I had an amazing experience, and now looking back as a senior all the hard work, long commutes and late nights were absolutely worth it. Regis has a culture where we are all highly supportive of each other and happy for each other's success. While everyone is highly driven, there is little competition amongst classmates because we understand that helping others make us better individually and collectively. While Regis won't have the excess of resources other NYC schools, the admin, teachers and students make the very most of prudently chosen opportunities. The full scholarship model has given me much greater appreciation of socioeconomic diversity and friendships that many would miss in other settings.... Read 141 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 532

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• PK, K-12

• •
  Rating 4.6 out of 5  93 reviews

Junior: Girls at Sacred Heart are friendly and supportive. There are some cliques that form but the majority of people are welcoming. Sacred Heart has also worked to increase diversity over the past several years, so I have a great group of diverse friends. There are also a lot of clubs and athletics to join which makes it easy to make friends. Sacred Heart is a catholic school and they do emphasize service and the school goals, which focus on personal responsibility and having the self confidence to make good decisions. The academics are strong, so there is a lot of homework, which can be a challenge. If I were to change one thing it would be for the administration to be more receptive and responsive to the student government. But, my time at Sacred Heart has been incredible and I will miss it when I graduate!... Read 93 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 699

• Student-teacher ratio 5:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• PK, K-12

• •
  Rating 4.68 out of 5  128 reviews

Parent: As a lifer at Marymount, I am very sad to see my daughter graduate! It has been a wonderful experience. Academically, my daughter received an excellent education allowing her to excel. She was admitted to many prestigious colleges with significant merit scholarships. But more importantly, Marymount played a large role in making my daughter the woman she is today. She is well rounded in academics, sports and cultural events, but she is also exceedingly polite, helpful and cooperative.... Read 128 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 768

• Student-teacher ratio 6:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.19 out of 5  36 reviews

Parent: Loyola has been a wonderfully nurturing environment for our child. The faculty and staff genuinely care for students' success and well-being. The academics are engaging and rigorous and teachers are very supportive of each child's achievement. They are always available for questions or extra help, and we have found them to be very accommodating especially if our child has a busy after-school schedule. There are ample opportunities for students to get involved in a variety of Loyola clubs, sports, and activities and bond with their peers. There is something for everyone. Sometimes there are so many options that the student will need to balance their workload and be selective about the activities they participate in. The parent body is also engaged, and there are many opportunities throughout the year to volunteer and support the students and the school. We are thrilled with our decision to send our child to Loyola.... Read 36 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 220

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.09 out of 5  159 reviews

Alum: This school has a great community and most of the teachers are very attentive. However, the clubs and sports could be stronger and it could offer more academic programs (for example, it advertises many APs that sometimes do not run depending on the year). It's a beautiful building but sometimes I think that the administration is more concerned with the school's aesthetic than with funding the student activities. College guidance is average at best, despite it being a very small school. If you are applying to more than 12 schools, you are required to pay Dominican Academy $35 for each additional school on top of the application fee. (for example, pay DA $70 when applying to 2 additional schools)... Read 159 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 252

• Student-teacher ratio 9:1

• Bronx, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.19 out of 5  203 reviews

Junior: Fordham Prep overall is a good school, but there are some flaws in the school. The teachers are very hit or miss. Some of my teachers are the best teachers I could ask for, but some teachers have a hard time answering the simplest questions and punish for the smallest issues. The classrooms are in decent condition, and they are renovating the bad classrooms. The school is diverse, and the college preparation is great. There are many clubs to participate in which is also good. However, the food service isn't good, because they overcharge for over/undercooked food, and I had food poisoning one time I ate their food.... Read 203 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 956

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• Rye, NY•

• Private School•

• 5-12

• •
  Rating 4.06 out of 5  32 reviews

Parent: Niche targets the big schools but the School of the Holy Child is positively as good as every other private school. My daughter scored higher than her other relatives that went to Fordham, Hackley, Marymount, and Regis. More importantly, she has zero fear of public speaking, is active in the community and so loving. In this selfish world, there is no better school for promoting positive Catholic values. They learn about community service and being a friend. All of the girls are wonderful young women!... Read 32 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 300

• Student-teacher ratio 7:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.49 out of 5  167 reviews

Senior: Growing up with a faith-based education my entire life, Xavier was a perfect fit for my four years of high school. Regardless of your faith, though, Xavier provides you with so many unique opportunities to grow into an incredibly well-rounded man, or what they call a "Man for Others." My time at Xavier has been filled with lasting friendships, encouraging mentors, memorable experiences, and so much more! I'm especially pleased with Xavier's emphasis on service. Through Xavier's variety of CFX (Companions of Francis Xavier) service programs, I've been able to travel around the country giving back in ways that I never could've imagined. Overall, Xavier has made my high school experience some of the best years of my life, and I'd recommend it to any prospective student who wants to make the most of their next four years!... Read 167 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 975

• Student-teacher ratio 14:1

• New Rochelle, NY•

• Private School•

• K-12

• •
  Rating 4.22 out of 5  112 reviews

Alum: I genuinely had some of the best years of my life at Iona. They talk a lot about brotherhood in the ads and whatnot, but I truly felt like my peers at Iona were my brothers, and I still feel that to this day. The community is warm and there's a lot of spirit, and the teachers genuinely all care about their jobs and put an immense amount of work into it. I truly believe that I came out of Iona a better man than I was when I went in, and I highly recommend anyone looking for Catholic High Schools in the New York area to consider it. Go Gaels!... Read 112 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 750

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• Syracuse, NY•

• Private School•

• 7-12

• •
  Rating 4.09 out of 5  159 reviews

Parent: Christian Brothers Academy has been an exceptional choice for both of my children. The older one just finished her freshman year at college and was extremely well prepared for the rigors of college life. My son is a senior and although very different from his sister, has also had an amazing CBA experience. They came from public school and both entered in 7th grade which I highly recommend. The Jr. High team does a remarkable job of creating a sense of community and family from the start. There is a tremendous amount of school spirit and pride. My children have been involved in sports, the musical, clubs, and every social activity. While they most loved the traditions, like Founder's Day and Homecoming, it seems like there is always something fun going on and they've made great friends from all over the Syracuse area. I feel like CBA was the best choice we've made and it prepared our children well for the rest of their lives.... Read 159 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 750

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• New Rochelle, NY•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 3.92 out of 5  162 reviews

Junior: I have enjoyed the Ursuline School ever since I have been here since 8th grade. Junior year was most definitely my favorite year, as we had just come back from covid-19 quarantine and it was our first "normal" year. I have learned the most in my junior year than I ever had in previous years. I was enlightened about many different subject and topics throughout the course of the year because I am now a Junior. I have been set up for success, and because Junior year is the most important, my grades are the best they have ever been. The administration such as teachers and college counselors have also prepared me for college and the college process, and make sure I obtain all of the resources I need for this big step in my educational career! They have been preparing me for college since day one of the Ursuline school and I can say I have greatly changed in the most positive way since I had been attending this school. It has taught me to be a hard working, persistent, and kind woman.... Read 162 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 800

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• Huntington Station, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.35 out of 5  433 reviews

Senior: As a soon to graduate senior, I have had all the resources needed to succeed and supportive teachers to help me on the way. The school’s staff is great and the majority of the teachers are cool, most more than not. Ive had access to state of the art technology and facilities. The only thing holding me back from giving a full 5 stars is the fact that the seniors have felt a bit neglected this year due to senior privileges being loosely enforced, if even so, such as senior parking being limited due to not cracking down on juniors parking, a senior cafe that any grade level has access to; seniors being forced to eat lunch in a hallway instead of their own cafeteria; and biggest of all, no senior trip. The school advertises their Italy pilgrimage strongly but it only applies to the chorus which the majority is not involved in. Otherwise the school is amazing and have been recommending anyone considering to go!... Read 433 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 2,384

• Student-teacher ratio 18:1

• Mt. Vernon, NY•

• Private School•

• 7-12

• •
  Rating 4.26 out of 5  53 reviews

Senior: Excellent school! The teachers are accomplished, intelligent, and always willing to help students when they don't understand something. The school is very much involved in the Catholic faith, providing Mass every Tuesday and Holy Hour every other Thursday for students to pray and reflect on their relationship with God. The students are very diverse, friendly, and down-to-earth. Additionally, there are various clubs to participate in, such as Speech and Debate, the Drama Club, and the Creative Writing club. Students can even start their own clubs, such as the Classics Club, Marine Biology Club, and Social Media Club. This school has helped me to grow as a person, both mentally and spiritually. I greatly appreciate the wonderful four years I've spent at Montfort! Would highly recommend to future Montfort Knights!... Read 53 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 168

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• Brooklyn, NY•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 4.48 out of 5  145 reviews

Senior: Xaverian has a very welcoming and inclusive culture. The school always makes sure to include everyone wherever they can. They offer a great range of Honors, AP, and elective classes. There is a class for everyone's interests. This can be said with the extracurricular activities as well. There is over a dozen clubs and if there isn't a club for you, you can make it easily. Overall, this school is great for everyone and I would absolutely recommend it without any doubt.... Read 145 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 1,100

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• Mineola, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.39 out of 5  245 reviews

Junior: Nice high school. You can decide your involvement. They aren’t going to push you into doing something you don’t want to do, but it’s there for anyone to join. Sports are great and competitive. Involvement with the Catholic faith is available and there is an amazing team combining campus ministry and the Marianist brothers. More AP classes have begun to be offered too (some being mandatory). Overall, great school to help your child to grow and explore different opportunities.... Read 245 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 1,700

• Student-teacher ratio 25:1

• Buffalo, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.19 out of 5  112 reviews

Parent: Cannot rate this school highly enough. my son transferred in after his sophomore year. The school at large, teachers, admin, students alike all welcomed him with open arms and really made him feel like part of the brotherhood immediately. He was an athlete and honor roll student. he is now playing D1 collegiate athletics and feels very confident going into it because of the preparation both in the classroom and on the field, that canisius provided. As a parent I really appreciate the feeling of family that this wonderful place provides. My wife and I consider ourselves honored that we had the privilege to send our son there.... Read 112 reviews

• grade A

• Students 830

• Student-teacher ratio 12:1

• Binghamton, NY•

• Private School•

• 7-12

• •
  Rating 4.16 out of 5  49 reviews

Alum: I attended Seton Catholic Central High School from 2010-2014, but I attended Catholic Schools of Broome County since kindergarten. I found the community and family atmosphere so warm and encouraging, I returned as an employee for the following 7 years after my high school graduation. The values, academics, athletics, extracurriculars, and connections Seton provided shaped who I am today. I now coach varsity cheerleading at Seton and am proud to continue my involvement in the Catholic Schools. Go Saints!... Read 49 reviews

• grade A

• Students 336

• Student-teacher ratio 10:1

• Rochester, NY•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 4.08 out of 5  111 reviews

Sophomore: McQuaid Jesuit is preparing me not only for a strong academic foundation, but one coupled with a dedication to caring for others and creating an environment of inclusion and acceptance.... Read 111 reviews

• grade A

• Students 932

• Student-teacher ratio 12:1

• Y•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 3.77 out of 5  264 reviews

Senior: Notre Dame fosters a unique learning environment where community and sisterhood are highly valued. Teachers are caring and understanding and go out of their way to help you. The students can become like a second family but sometimes it is difficult to find your place". There is a wide array of clubs to participate in and being in the heart of West Village, finding your passion is easy and within reach. Internships and jobs are easily accessible and the Meatpacking district offers fun activities to indulge in afterschool!... Read 264 reviews

• grade A

• Students 365

• Student-teacher ratio 15:1

• Y•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.15 out of 5  450 reviews

Parent: My twin African American daughters LOVED their time at Mary Louis. They went on to an elite selective college and have excellent careers. Mary Louis is a great choice for a solid and refined education. Put it at the top of your list. Character and excellence made it our choice! My daughters were received with enthusiasm and warmth. They came home happy every single day. They led the tennis team to victory and enjoyed every one of their teachers. The academic guidance was exceptional and respect for your teachers and classmates is part of the culture of this fine institution. Young women are there to learn. Some may call it conservative. That’s just fine with us. We appreciate the grace and refinement Mary Louis continued to encourage in their students.... Read 450 reviews

• grade A

• Students 644

• Student-teacher ratio 9:1

• Hempstead, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.05 out of 5  263 reviews

Freshman: I am currently a freshman at Sacred Heart Academy and overall it has been an honor going to this school and being a part of the community. Sacred Heart is an amazing school for girls to challenge themselves hence the fact that it's a college predatory high school. When asked to describe a good school most people say that they have amazing teachers and nice friends but I can say that my school has a curriculum based on teaching us and stimulating our brains to live in the real world. The many subjects introduce us to the diverseness of the world. Alongside education, Sacred Heart is a great place to make friends and socialize while staying on top of school work. We have a large range of sports, clubs, and extracurriculars that are a great way to find friends that you have similarities. Some of the clubs that I am involved with are the Multicultural Club and Women Empowerment. As much as school can be exhausting, we should always remember the great times we've had and are soon to have!... Read 263 reviews

• grade A

• Students 857

• Student-teacher ratio 13:1

• Astoria, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.18 out of 5  195 reviews

Alum: An amazing school. Highly educated teachers who love what they do. You’ll be welcomed here with open arms by all administrators. Amazing sports, performing arts, and clubs. The school atmosphere is very comfortable and you’ll feel like your at home. Students really look out for each other. Teachers always looking to help if your struggling with something and guidance counselors are very helpful. There’s nothing like the red storm family.... Read 195 reviews

• grade A

• Students 657

• Student-teacher ratio 14:1

• Briarwood, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.13 out of 5  478 reviews

Senior: What I like about Archbishop Molloy is all teachers are very welcoming and offer help whenever needed. Molloy is an environment that helped me shape my character. In this school, teachers treat you like a older adult and often offer great advice to students. My time being here I learned a lot about myself and developed many dreams for my future. Molloy has an amazing faculty that keeps order in the building, which makes me feel very safe. Looking back the past three years so far, I can say that Molloy has a very interesting student body. Its a private school that is more diverse than others, and offers a variety of student clubs. My experience wasn't the greatest a first, because on the first day it seemed like everyone already had their own group of friends. All teachers hold group discussions and engage the class to learn, which allowed me to reach out to my peers and know them better. If I were to make a change: there should be more dress down days for self expression.... Read 478 reviews

• grade A

• Students 1,490

• Student-teacher ratio 19:1

• Syosset, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 3.83 out of 5  167 reviews

Alum: As an alumnae of OLMA, I can truly say that being a "Mercy Girl" was crucial to my success in getting my bachelors degree, master's degree and PhD. If I could give Mercy six stars for college readiness, I would! The Mercy experience is next to none; it's a place where everybody knows your name. I also participated in so many clubs and activities and I value all the friendships I made at this wonderful school to this day!... Read 167 reviews

• grade A

• Students 415

• Student-teacher ratio 6:1

• Y•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 4.02 out of 5  192 reviews

Freshman: I genuinely have loved every second being at Mercy, and sending your daughter here is definitely a gift everyone deserves. I will say though if your daughter doesn’t have great grades in your typical public school, she might not excel here. As someone who had all grades above a 98% at public school, now I average around a 90%. Although the school is very challenging, I feel like I learn a lot more being given more homework, and getting good grades feels much more rewarding. The people are genuinely so sweet - staff and students, and they are all very welcoming. The teachers are very qualified and they are really helpful when you advocate for yourself and ask. In general Mercy pushes for your daughter to grow more independent and be able to go out and conquer challenging tasks on her own, and they really do it amazingly. Overall I would definitely recommend this school!... Read 192 reviews

• grade A

• Students 786

• Student-teacher ratio 12:1