Skip to Main Content

2020 Best Catholic High Schools in New YorkAbout this List

The 2020 Best Catholic High Schools ranking is based on rigorous analysis of key statistics and millions of reviews from students and parents. Ranking factors include SAT/ACT scores, the quality of colleges that students consider, student-teacher ratio, Catholic school ratings, and more. Data sourced from the U.S. Department of Education, Niche users, and the schools directly. Read more on how this ranking was calculated.

1 – 25 of 109
Best Schools
109 results

  1. Regis High School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 122 reviews
    #1 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Niche User: I commend the Founders and leadership. The vision, execution, and evolution of the model is spot on. Ask any student, parent, faculty, college admissions counselor, and Dean at any University and you will get the real story. It's not perfect but the school has been able to maintain it's high level of academics and keep its goal of providing a full scholarship education for future Catholic leaders, authors, scientists, etc.. The sincere approach to help diversify the classroom has been successful. With education costs going out of control, you would think governments and schools are studying how it's done at Regis.

    Get a top notch education without lowering standards or using temp solutions ("shuttling" minorities in or subsidizing over priced tuition with"generous" financial aid packages to fill quotas for chess, academics, sports, and school team competitions). Colleges and employers love Regians!
    Read 122 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 532 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  2. Marymount School of New York

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • PK, K-12
    • 42 reviews
    #2 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Parent: We have three daughters who attend Marymount and, in our experience, this school has exceeded our expectations in every way for our girls. The academics are rigorous but interesting and stretch our daughters in ways that develop their minds and heart while honoring their particular gifts and talents. The faculty is comprised of women and men who are life-long learners, warm, wise and challenge the girls to become the best versions of themselves. The teachers are role models and inspire the students to challenge, shape and change the world. Each division plans and serves the students at age-appropriate levels in social-emotional growth and supports the ups and down of developing friendship and learning self-care as the girls grow into mature young women. The families are lovely and we have made life-long friends in our years at Marymount. Our daughters are all thriving at Marymount and we are so grateful!
    Read 42 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 759 Students
    • 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  3. Convent of the Sacred Heart

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • PK, K-12
    • 40 reviews
    #3 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Sacred Heart is an academically challenging school. Advanced classes and a rigorous curriculum challenge the students and teaches them how to work hard. The school and the faculty are always pushing their students to reach their full potential. Sacred Heart educates the full person allowing their students to not only become intellectuals but also well rounded individuals and leaders. I have never met a more dedicated faculty and administration; the faculty at Sacred Heart truly care for their students and want to see them succeed. The students at Sacred Heart embody the schools values and mission, which is obvious in the girls caring and kind nature. I have never felt more supported and cared for than I have at Sacred Heart and I look back at my time at Sacred Heart very fondly. The gift of a Sacred Heart education is the greatest gift I have ever been given and I am so grateful to this community for always being there for me and providing me with the tools I need to succeed.
    Read 40 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 710 Students
    • 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  4. Loyola School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 19 reviews
    #4 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Freshman: Loyola was the first high school I toured, and from the moment I walked in, I knew that it was where I wanted to go. If you want a well-rounded high school, look no further. Loyola has top-notch academics - classes challenge us to grow and develop as thinkers. The Class of 2022 - my class - has only 63 kids in it, but that’s a good thing. Small grade sizes allow for us to get to know each other well. We have many fun events. In January, we have Sports Night. The whole school cheers on our basketball team. The night has a warm community feeling to it whether we win or lose. We recently had For and With Others Week, where we gathered to discuss important issues concerning diversity and equality in our school community and the world. Sports include soccer, basketball, baseball, and volleyball. As for clubs, we have a Newspaper, Book Club, and Dance Club, among many others. I love Loyola, and I’m so glad I’m here. Go Knights!
    Read 19 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 220 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  5. Fordham Preparatory School

    • Private School
    • Bronx, NY
    • 9-12
    • 185 reviews
    #5 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: I liked the reputation and overall academic prowess that Fordham Prep has to offer, and I love the widespread influence of the Prep, given that it has students from all across the tri-state area. However, the racial and ethnic diversity is not very strong, and I believe that many of the teachers are not very good, yet the Prep fails to act towards removing them. However, in terms of education, connections, and overall Jesuit foundation, I would say that Fordham is a very great school!
    Read 185 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 975 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  6. Dominican Academy

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 143 reviews
    #6 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Freshman: I absolutely love DA! Whenever I have an issue on my work I can always reach out to the teachers and they're happy to meet before or after school to explain. One time I had a family issue and missed a couple of days of school and when I came back, all the teachers welcomed me and made sure I got notes and work that I had missed. The students are also amazing and supportive as well. I may have trouble getting out of bed in the morning, especially on Mondays, but once I'm at school, the warm atmosphere is enjoyable to be in. One small issue I have is that 1 or 2 of the teachers can't always be reached by email and that can get frustrating occasionally. However, I truly do love being at DA, and I highly recommend it!
    Read 143 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 252 Students
    • 9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  9. School of the Holy Child

    • Private School
    • Rye, NY
    • 5-12
    • 23 reviews
    #7 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: This school has always been a gem, but now more so than ever!
    The facilities have been improved beyond belief offering all or more than any of the other private schools offer. They give their students an outstanding education and college prep, a confidence in themselves and their abilities, life long friendships and a secure path for their future. They nourish the entire whole student at Holy Child, allowing them to grow and flourish. It was a gift that I received my education there...one that keeps giving!
    Read 23 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 300 Students
    • 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  10. Christian Brothers Academy

    • Private School
    • Syracuse, NY
    • 7-12
    • 143 reviews
    #8 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Christian Brothers Academy helps students exel academically and socially and become successful well-rounded individuals. This school prepares each one greatly and prepares them for their next step in their lives. The faculty and staff show interest in the students lives in and out of school which help develop healthy relationships. Christian Brothers Academy exemplifies a sense of community and family where students push each other to reach their fullest potential and reach their goals. At this school, the students support one another in all that they do from outside activities, sports, exams and hobbies. You will always see many students step out to support their classmates at every sporting or theater event that is held. As a Senior, I am proud to say that I attend Christian Brothers Academy and will forever be grateful for the opportunities and friendships that I have made throughout my years.
    Read 143 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 785 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  11. Chaminade High School

    • Private School
    • Mineola, NY
    • 9-12
    • 208 reviews
    #9 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Parent: My son is a recent graduate from Chaminade HS, class of 2019 (known as the “Nade” for insiders). He was recently asked given the chance to repeat high school would he select Chaminade....His answer was; absolutely! Their are many rumors about Chaminade that for some reason instill fear in people. Our experience is that Chaminade helps your son become a man. The work is absolutely attainable. It’s not a cake walk, they do not coddle you so if that’s what you’re looking for it may not be the right fit. There are expectations at Chaminade and your young men are held to a high standard and are expected to be accountable for their decisions. My son thrived in this environment. My son also played ice hockey and I believe this helped him grow tremendously. The coaches are tough but supportive and you need to earn your spot on any team sport (no walk-ons at the Nade). Best decision our son made was to attend Chamimade High School.
    Read 208 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,700 Students
    • 25:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  12. Iona Preparatory School

    • Private School
    • New Rochelle, NY
    • K-12
    • 97 reviews
    #10 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Sophomore: Very good athletics and academics. Many excellent teachers and coaches as well as other faculty members. Good sized classes and all teachers offer extra help. All programs (College Prep, Honors, A.P., and STEP ) are different and can be a good opportunity for your son to ease or harden his schedule. A very strong public service program is also built into the curriculum which looks good on a college resume. Very strong brotherhood in which will stick with them for their lives. Friends are easy to make due to the diverse student body. This definitely one of New York's best college prep schools!
    Read 97 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 750 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  13. Canisius High School

    • Private School
    • Buffalo, NY
    • 9-12
    • 97 reviews
    #11 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Canisius has a brotherhood quality that you do not see at other schools, and along with having excellent academics, the school has retreat and service programs that really help each individual discover himself. One thing that I would change would be to lower tuition because that would allow more people to attend which would increase selectivity and improve academic competitiveness.
    Read 97 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 830 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  14. The Ursuline School

    • Private School
    • New Rochelle, NY
    • 6-12
    • 141 reviews
    #12 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: Without the Ursuline School, I would not be who I am today! TUS has prepared me for the world by molding me to become a strong independent woman who is not afraid to take risks and to make a voice for myself. Ursuline is an amazing school and I hope to send my daughters here one day because of how much I loved my experience. I came into Ursuline in the sixth grade and never once have I doubted my decision to go to TUS. The faculty and administration are amazing and I wouldn't trade in my seven years at TUS for anything!
    Read 141 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 800 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  15. Xavier High School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 134 reviews
    #13 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: My experience at Xavier has been very enjoyable and rewarding. What I love most about Xavier is how every teacher genuinely cares about your success and will put everything aside to help you reach your goals. I also love the sense of community and brotherhood that you cannot get at any other high school. Xavier is a very safe learning environment where working hard and getting good grades is seen as cool. This school does a great job of instilling discipline and developing boys into exemplary young men. I wouldn't change a single thing about Xavier, as it is already an excellent institution.
    Read 134 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,090 Students
    • 14:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  16. Saint Anthony's High School

    • Private School
    • Huntington Station, NY
    • 9-12
    • 366 reviews
    #14 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: I loved St. Anthony's and would do anything to be back there. Not only is it a private high school, but it becomes a family. I was so prepared for college and the staff genuinely cares for their students. I would recommend this school to any family looking for a private high school. I can assure you will never be disappointed!
    Read 366 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 2,384 Students
    • 18:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  17. Sacred Heart Academy

    • Private School
    • Hempstead, NY
    • 9-12
    • 227 reviews
    #15 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Sacred Heart was easily the best thing that ever happened to me! I have the greatest friends in the world, I love going to school every day and I am excited to see what each day will bring. All the students have each others back and it is such a great environment to be in. The school lunches are great and they have healthy options too. Every summer the school gets renovated and the staff is great. Many of the classes I took my senior year were solely because I loved the teachers teaching the course. Please go to SHA if you are considering it in your high school search. I am so much more confident and friendly since coming here and I can't wait to see where the future takes me
    Read 227 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 857 Students
    • 13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  18. Our Lady of Mercy Academy

    • Private School
    • Syosset, NY
    • 9-12
    • 148 reviews
    #16 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: Mercy is a great school for those who are looking for a small personal environment in which teachers give attention to each student and provide all necessary help. The physical school itself is charming, dating back to 1928 when the original boarding school openned. There are many academic opprotunities, and as a junior I feel that I will be more than prepared for college when that time comes. The overall atmosphere is empowering, and girls are pushed to build each other up and grow in their Catholic faith. Through Mercy, I've become closer to my faith and was even provided the opprotunity to go on a mission trip to the Dominican Republic. Our Lady of Mercy Academy is a wonderful school!
    Read 148 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 415 Students
    • 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  19. McQuaid Jesuit Preparatory School

    • Private School
    • Rochester, NY
    • 6-12
    • 105 reviews
    #17 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: Mcquaid provides a quality education that goes above and beyond in preparing young men for college. The staff are highly educated and caring. The focus goes beyond acedemic education to include spiritual growth.
    Built on the traditions of St. Ignatius Loyola, founder of the Society of Jesus, McQuaid inspires young men to realize their God-given gifts through their pursuit of excellence in academics, athletics, service to others, and a lifelong commitment to justice.
    Read 105 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 932 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  22. Nardin Academy

    • Private School
    • Buffalo, NY
    • PK, K-12
    • 212 reviews
    #18 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: My experience with Nardin Academy began when I was 4 years old, at their Montessori School. I am now a Senior and have had the privilege of attending Nardin for the past 13 years. All of my teachers, staff and executive leadership have been a tremendous support to me during family-related health situations as well as with my academic coursework. They all want me to succeed and offer whatever assistance they can provide to reach my goals. The numerous resources they offer and personal support I continue to be given has been amazing!
    Read 212 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 913 Students
    • 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  23. The Montfort Academy

    • Private School
    • Mt. Vernon, NY
    • 7-12
    • 35 reviews
    #19 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Montfort is one of the friendliest schools I've ever been to. I felt welcomed into the school on my shadow day and I now feel like I'm part of a very big family. Almost all of our teachers genuinely care about you. If you're struggling, they'll always spend time to help you specifically.

    What I think the school lacks is a steady schedule and overall cleanliness. Day schedules are constantly shifted leaving everyone confused and annoyed. The school can sometimes look like an asthmatic's worst nightmare. By the end of the day, your shoes will look like a used swifter.
    Read 35 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 168 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  24. Archbishop Molloy High School

    • Private School
    • Briarwood, NY
    • 9-12
    • 411 reviews
    #20 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: My decision to attend Archbishop Molloy High School is a decision that I will never regret. The atmosphere of the school is fully committed to helping us develop not only as students, but as good people, something that reaches above and beyond what just any high school aims for. Excelling both academically and athletically, “Stanner High” as some refer to it, is a prestigious Catholic High School that does not mandate hours of community service, making it unique and teaching students that service should originate from the desire to help others, not just to fulfill any requirements. Despite this, service volunteer spots are in high demand and fill up quickly. Everyone is always willing to help, whether it be a teacher to a student, student to student, or student to a person outside of the high school community. Most teachers stay afterschool, leaving their classrooms open for helping students. I absolutely love it here!
    Read 411 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,490 Students
    • 19:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  25. Seton Catholic Central High School

    • Private School
    • Binghamton, NY
    • 7-12
    • 32 reviews
    #21 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Parent: Seton Catholic Central is a very good school. The teachers are knowledgeable, and caring. They have high expectations of the students. The academics, arts and athletics are all impressive. Small class sizes and the foundation of faith help build a tight knit community. Many updates to the building and grounds have happened in the last 2 years. The cafeteria food is not great and is in need of improvement.
    Read 32 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 336 Students
    • 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  26. Our Lady of Mercy School for Young Women

    • Private School
    • Rochester, NY
    • 6-12
    • 160 reviews
    #22 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: I transferred to Mercy from a Rochester-area public school going into my junior year but it wasn't nearly as difficult as it sounds. Everyone was so welcoming and I quickly made some of the closest friends I've ever had. As an all-girl's school, I was able focus on my academics and explore topics usually avoided in co-ed classrooms. I was able to challenge myself through a variety of college-level and AP classes, participate in extracurricular activities, and build meaningful relationships. My self-confidence grew during my time at Mercy. I was also prepared to go to college after only two years.
    Read 160 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 786 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  27. Notre Dame School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 251 reviews
    #23 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Notre Dame fosters a unique learning environment where community and sisterhood are highly valued. Teachers are caring and understanding and go out of their way to help you. The students can become like a second family but sometimes it is difficult to find your place". There is a wide array of clubs to participate in and being in the heart of West Village, finding your passion is easy and within reach. Internships and jobs are easily accessible and the Meatpacking district offers fun activities to indulge in afterschool!
    Read 251 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 365 Students
    • 13:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  28. The Mary Louis Academy

    • Private School
    • Jamaica Estates, NY
    • 9-12
    • 290 reviews
    #24 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: People always say that high school is the worst part of their life but honestly, I enjoyed high school. The faculty and teachers are always willing to help their students, and we have a close relationship. The friends I make here are also the friends I will have for life. Although there is a lot of schoolwork and homework, it is to prepare you for college. Trust me, you will be used to the workload and will head to college with no surprises!
    Read 290 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 738 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  29. Xaverian High School

    • Private School
    • Brooklyn, NY
    • 6-12
    • 114 reviews
    #25 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: I was so excited when I received my acceptance letter for Xaverian, and it certainly has lived up to it’s name. I’ve been involved in various clubs and activities the school has to offer since I was a freshman and doing so has made me feel extremely welcome in the community. Almost every teacher is overwhelmingly friendly and will help you with whatever you need so long as you ask for help. It’s modern technology adds to its charm as well. Supplying students with iPads rather than having us lug around heavy binders, notebooks, and even textbooks allows us students to have a healthier and happier lifestyle than students who go to other schools around New York.
    Read 114 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,100 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  30. Sponsored

    Rippowam Cisqua School

    • Private School
    • Bedford, NY
    • PK, K-9
    • 16 reviews

    Parent: Rippowam is community of educators and students who care! A challenging, relevant curriculum engages students in real world conversations and challenges. We have experienced every grade, 5-9 and could not be more impressed with the outcome for each of our (very different!) children. They are challenged, encouraged to take intellectual risks, think critically and analytically and step up to take on leadership roles. All along the way, they are supported and feel known as individuals. Their teachers know their strengths, know when to push them further and know when to adjust to their specific needs in the moment.
    Ripp empowers its students with confidence, empathy and critical analytical and communication skills (they become powerful writers and speakers). They are learn real leadership skills and leave poised to succeed in high school.
    Read 16 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 363 Students
    • 4:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  34. Review Your School 
  35. Sponsored

    St. Vincent Ferrer High School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 177 reviews

    Alum: I am currently a sophomore in college and an alum of Saint Vincent’s. I commuted for all four years from Northern Westchester. The environment that the Adminstration and fellow students cultivate make the long trek worth every minute spent at school. The faculty and staff take the students progress and well being to heart. By the time I graduated, and arrived at college my teachers at SVF had already introduced me to basic collegiate concepts and skills. The warm environment and wonderful academics of Saint Vincent’s prepares every young lady to boldly go forward and embrace their goals!
    Read 177 Reviews

    • A-
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 516 Students
    • 15:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  36. Sponsored

    Chamberlain International School

    • Private School
    • Middleboro, MA
    • 6-12
    • 9 reviews

    Senior: I like how the staff treat me at the residence. I really enjoy the summer activities, we go to the beach and BBQ. During the week we go out at night to the movies and stuff. People in general have my best interest in mind here. I have solid relationships with the administration and supervisors, they seem to really care. And the food is good.
    Read 9 Reviews

    • 77 Students
    • 5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  • 1 of 5