2024 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• PK, K-12

• •
  Rating 4.67 out of 5  111 reviews

Senior: Sacred Heart is a unique school, with incredible facilities. It helps girls find their voice and encourages us to explore different paths to problem solving. Even though we are in a competitive environment, we are always supportive of each other and encourage each other to do our best. Whether it was in class or during sports, we had fun and enjoyed our time together. I’ve made a great group of diverse friends I know I will keep forever. I also feel very prepared for college. I was excited to be accepted to my top choice university. Sacred Heart has great college placement and an exceptional college counseling group. It’s been a wonderful experience, and I will be sad to leave. But, I know I always have a home at Sacred Heart!... Read 111 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 741

• Student-teacher ratio 6:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.44 out of 5  150 reviews

Parent: My son recently graduated. I am so pleased with the education he received, the friends he has made, and his overall experience. Regis takes the best of the best from the 5 boroughs and NJ/CT/Long Island. My son had boys in his class who commuted 2 hours to school each way. I was afraid that the school would be hyper-competitive with all these great students. I was surprised to find that it was the exact opposite. The boys helped one another. The students who understood the material would put together study guides or tutor the others. The atmosphere was one of Christian charity and helping others. Academically, I do not know of many, if any schools, which are better. Half of my son's class were National Merit commended or Finalists. My son has matured, has learned, and has made many great friends. I now understand why parents stay involved in this great school long after their sons have graduated.... Read 150 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 532

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• PK, K-12

• •
  Rating 4.7 out of 5  136 reviews

Parent: The school is truly a dream. Top ranked in the country, few blocks from our apartment, on beautiful 5th Ave overlooking the MET. Most importantly, they engage, cultivate, and support their girls into a rigours education. We are happy our daughter was accepted into their limited spots; but amazed at their educational support that will make my daughter thrive. Huge highlights: First STEM program for girls, Financial Literacy through Bloomberg Terminal certification, brand new Upper School with state of the art technology. An Apple Distinguished School with ipads for students. An absolutely unreal Fabrication Lab that easily competes MIT/Caltech labs. Art and dedicated classrooms at the MET. Finally, and most importantly, a humble grace that shows how education is a gift; a gift to selflessly give back to society.... Read 136 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 768

• Student-teacher ratio 5:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.13 out of 5  39 reviews

Senior: Loyola fosters an extremely close-knit community that is made up of around 50 students per grade, in addition to faculty and staff. Everyone is a familiar face, whether classmates or teachers, allowing a comfortable learning environment for all students. Teachers and students here are extremely welcoming, whether coming in as a freshman or a transfer. Having been a student at Loyola for nearly four years, I have really enjoyed my experience.... Read 39 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 220

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.57 out of 5  192 reviews

Parent: Xavier High School has been a wonderful experience for our entire family. At this time I have a graduate (class of '20) and a rising senior (class of '24). The education they have received has been exemplarily, the faculty and staff wonderful and the Jesuit education second to none. We have experienced the athletics programs with one son (Go Knights!) and the STEM courses with robotics, architecture and 3D design with the other. Xavier has enough of a diverse course offering to satisfy all types of curious young men. The events for both students and parents have been truly wonderful and we have all made lots of new and interesting friends form all over the city and beyond. Our boys matured at Xavier, becoming fine young men with a strong religious understanding . Being in Manhattan daily has a way of doing that! We could not have selected a better place for our boys to grow, nor a better place for them to learn. They strive to become "the grad at graduation", truly special.... Read 192 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 944

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.05 out of 5  172 reviews

Sophomore: When touring DA as an 8th grader, I instantly fell in love with how close-knit the community was. Although I was accepted into other prestigious schools on the Upper East Side, I felt that the girls there were cold and were not very welcoming; therefore, I chose to attend Dominican Academy. I believe that DA truly wishes that all of their students become the best that they can be, both in academics and in character. Every girl here cares about her grades and strives to do her greatest, and teachers will challenge their students, but will not turn away someone if they reach out for help. Being at Dominican Academy has given me a sense on how to be independent in my studies, almost how one would be when they attend college. Along with this, DA is very open in accepting everyone from different backgrounds as there is Culture Day and Students of Color Alliance (SOCA), which is one of the biggest clubs. I truly love my school and could not imagine being anywhere else.... Read 172 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 252

• Student-teacher ratio 9:1

• Bronx, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.21 out of 5  217 reviews

Freshman: The school offers a rigorous academic curriculum, a strong emphasis on character development, and a variety of extracurricular activities. We appreciate the challenging academic environment, which prepares us well for college and beyond. The school also offers a wide range of extracurricular activities, including sports teams, clubs, and community service opportunities. I had the chance to participate in competitive athletics, join clubs based on my interests, and engage in meaningful service projects. Fordham Prep is known for its strong sense of community and brotherhood. Students often form close bonds with their classmates and develop lifelong friendships. The school also places a strong emphasis on character development, encouraging students to be compassionate, ethical, and responsible individuals. Overall, my experience has been a positive experience. I appreciate the challenging academics, the wide range of extracurricular opportunities, and the strong sense of community.... Read 217 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 956

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• Huntington Station, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.38 out of 5  464 reviews

Junior: My involvement with Saint Anthony’s has overall been an amazing experience and I feel incredibly lucky to attend such an inspiring school. My favorite piece so far has been the academics; the options feel endless with the amount of courses offered in various fields including, engineering, computer science, business, and more. One thing I believe needs improving is regarding our international students. Although, we have many students from all around the world, I feel like we should include more opportunities where these international students can meet current St. Anthony’s students before joining our school. This will allow them to feel connected to our school community. It can be difficult to join a school in the middle of the year, especially without knowing anyone there, so I feel that this is a necessary piece to integrate into our school.... Read 464 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 2,483

• Student-teacher ratio 14:1

• New Rochelle, NY•

• Private School•

• K-12

• •
  Rating 4.2 out of 5  121 reviews

Senior: Entering Iona Preparatory School for the first time, I was anxious to begin high school and was not sure if this was the correct place for me to spend the next 4 years of my life. However, the Iona Prep community, or brotherhood, as we describe it, is committed to helping their students academically, socially, and spiritually. I've had countless opportunities to become involved with clubs, sports, service, and faith-based ministry through my teachers who I believe truly want us to succeed. Additionally, I've made countless friendships through this brotherhood which I know I wouldn't be able to form anywhere else!... Read 121 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 194

• Student-teacher ratio 3:1

• Astoria, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.2 out of 5  202 reviews

Senior: I have been in St. John Preparatory school for 4 years. I am currently a Senior trying to pursue a career in the Medical field. When I first went into St. John's Preparatory High school, I really didn't know who else was going to attend this school. I was kind of scared and didn't know what to expect. High schools are normally big but I thought I was never going to succeed spending four years in this school. I was imagining the worst. As time passed by, I met friends and the teachers were better than I thought. On my first year, I made honors and was so proud of myself. One thing my parents have always told me is to never give up and that is exactly I what I did and continue to do. Never let your hope down.... Read 202 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 657

• Student-teacher ratio 14:1

• Mt. Vernon, NY•

• Private School•

• 7-12

• •
  Rating 4.34 out of 5  65 reviews

Parent: Montfort is an exceptional educational institution that nurtures the whole child academically, emotionally, and spiritually. My son is a Freshman there this year and I cannot say enough about the wonderful administration, staff,parents,and students. He is very happy here and it truly feels like a family.It really is a hidden gem!... Read 65 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 168

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 3.78 out of 5  270 reviews

Senior: In my eighth grade year, I was introduced to the Notre Dame School of Manhattan and felt a connection, so of course, I rushed to take the Tachs Exam - which I had been quite averse to initially. Despite a bumpy transition between middle and high school, through clubs and French projects I accumulated a substantial amount of loyal, talented, and intelligent friends. Without Notre Dame, I would have never been exposed to some of the most brilliant, curiosity-invoking teachers, ones who have both challenged and encouraged me throughout my high school years. I would be remiss if I did not share how accessible teachers are to their students. Whether it be the morning, after school, or during a free period, in my experience, teachers are more than happy to help or even just converse with students. Of course, this is not to say the school is completely flawless - there are a couple assemblies we probably could have done without. Overall though, I'm grateful for my experience.... Read 270 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 351

• Student-teacher ratio 13:1

• Rye, NY•

• Private School•

• 5-12

• •
  Rating 3.85 out of 5  39 reviews

Parent: My daughter loves Holy Child - the school has become her second home. The faculty and staff are kind, caring and supportive. She is thriving in her academics, athletics and extracurriculars. The school is smaller than other comparable schools but that's the secret to its success - its smaller size allows for a feeling of belonging and family. My daughter is not just a name on a class roster - her teachers know her and nurture her to be her best possible self.... Read 39 reviews

• grade A+

• Students 300

• Student-teacher ratio 7:1

• Syracuse, NY•

• Private School•

• 7-12

• •
  Rating 4.08 out of 5  164 reviews

Parent: Christian Brothers Academy has been an exceptional choice for both of my children. The older one just finished her freshman year at college and was extremely well prepared for the rigors of college life. My son is a senior and although very different from his sister, has also had an amazing CBA experience. They came from public school and both entered in 7th grade which I highly recommend. The Jr. High team does a remarkable job of creating a sense of community and family from the start. There is a tremendous amount of school spirit and pride. My children have been involved in sports, the musical, clubs, and every social activity. While they most loved the traditions, like Founder's Day and Homecoming, it seems like there is always something fun going on and they've made great friends from all over the Syracuse area. I feel like CBA was the best choice we've made and it prepared our children well for the rest of their lives.... Read 164 reviews

• grade A

• Students 750

• Student-teacher ratio 11:1

• Jamaica, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.15 out of 5  458 reviews

Alum: My school is well-known for its demanding academic program, exciting extracurricular offerings, and strong focus on community service and leadership development. Students at TMLA frequently compliment the school on the encouraging and uplifting atmosphere it provides. The professors are renowned for their commitment and encouragement, giving each student individualized attention and direction to help them succeed in their studies. Community service is highly valued, and students are encouraged to give back through a variety of programs and volunteer opportunities. My school is well-known for its demanding academic program, exciting extracurricular offerings, and strong focus on community service and leadership development.... Read 458 reviews

• grade A

• Students 644

• Student-teacher ratio 9:1

• New Rochelle, NY•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 3.93 out of 5  172 reviews

Junior: From my very first experience here, which was at a shadow day, I saw that girls at the Ursuline School are very friendly, classy, and positive people. I have attended this school since freshman year and had never had a problem with feeling left out. I love this school because it has more diversity than other all girls schools in Westchester, and it provides a challenging education. Its main focus is Serviam, which everyone takes very seriously and the traditions here are amazing. Seniors experience most of the "fun traditions" like Ring day, which I am so excited about!... Read 172 reviews

• grade A

• Students 770

• Student-teacher ratio 10:1

• Briarwood, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.14 out of 5  495 reviews

Senior: I enjoyed the various classes available and the teachers. From my freshman year the growth that happened for me was tremendous. Even during the pandemic, the school supported the students so we could continue with our education. We continued to learn at a high rate and seemed almost seamless being at home. I was able to get additional assistance from the teachers over the years. We have parental support and the staff kept my parents informed of all changes. The support from my classmates was a blessing as we were able to bounce ideas of each during team building exercises.... Read 495 reviews

• grade A

• Students 1,490

• Student-teacher ratio 19:1

• Brooklyn, NY•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 4.49 out of 5  160 reviews

Alum: Xaverian is a college preparatory school that helps prepare students to pursue their academic endeavors. There were endless opportunities at my fingertips when at Xaverian. Xaverian welcomes and guides students throughout their four years of high school. At Xaverian, there are various pathways students can take. These pathways are filled with elective courses. I was able to learn further about biomedical science through the biomedical science pathway. I realized the passion I have for pursuing medicine. Now I am attending a 7-year BS-MD program called The Sophie Davis School of Biomedical Education/CUNY School of Medicine at the City College of New York. To make additional opportunities available for students, I would like to see stronger connections with colleges and scholarships. This will motivate students during the college application process and display additional options when narrowing down their college choices.... Read 160 reviews

• grade A

• Students 1,685

• Student-teacher ratio 17:1

• Mineola, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.39 out of 5  260 reviews

Senior: Coming out of middle school, I was very interested in the opportunity to continue my education to a well established, highly academic private high school like Chaminade. Right from the beginning of my first week, they made me feel welcome. Their effort to ensure that that I belonged at there and that I was a part of a unique family of students that would sustain a lifetime of friendships was evident during Freshman 3C week and has continued throughout my four years. The worst part of the overall experience can only be that they offer so much to do! Sometimes it can make it difficult what to choose or you can find yourself involved in too much, which could impact your academics. Finding the right balance of extra curricular activities and maintaining above standard academics is the goal of every student. The only thing I would like to see change at Chaminade would be to make the tuition more affordable so my parents wouldn't have had to sacrifice so much for me to go there.... Read 260 reviews

• grade A

• Students 1,644

• Student-teacher ratio 25:1

• New York, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 3.98 out of 5  147 reviews

Parent: I've been incredibly happy with La Salle and the impact the school has had on my son. I have watched him blossom into a bright young man taking on leadership roles. After attending a charter middle school, we were unsure of the right direction for his high school path. He has made wonderful friends, tried new sports, and he love the communication we receive from the teachers.... Read 147 reviews

• grade A

• Students 187

• Student-teacher ratio 8:1

• Rochester, NY•

• Private School•

• 6-12

• •
  Rating 4.09 out of 5  116 reviews

Senior: Mcquaid Jesuit is a very good college prep school. The campus is decent, although not as new and updated as many others. The STEM center is definitley the highlight of the campus. The preparation for college is likely its biggest strong point. They push kids hard, so everyone is pretty well off and ready for college. Those involved with the college application process are experienced, informative, and proactive. The cafeteria has amazing food, and the sports teams are dominant. This all combines with a faith-based experience that brings satisfaction to the more spiritual parts of every student.... Read 116 reviews

• grade A

• Students 811

• Student-teacher ratio 10:1

• Brooklyn, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.2 out of 5  65 reviews

Junior: I absolutely love St. Saviour High School. I knew it was the school for me when I first walked through the big red doors. The teachers and staff are wonderful. They strive to give their students the best education and a healthy school atmosphere. St. Saviour also offers students the opportunity to join many different clubs. Some include Student Government, Art Club, Book Club, Yearbook, Disney Club, Hydroponics Club, Afro-Caribbean Student Association, and so much more. St. Saviour also has many traditions, such as Song Contest. Song Contest is an annual event in which the different grades put on a performance and compete for 1st place. It is so much fun. Even through the pandemic, the school continued to amaze me. I love St. Saviour High School and would recommend it to any 8th grader looking for a high school. When I think of St. Saviour, I think of family. Although it is not perfect, I wouldn't want any other high school experience. Plus, the food is really great too.... Read 65 reviews

• grade A

• Students 200

• Student-teacher ratio 10:1

• Buffalo, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.19 out of 5  113 reviews

Alum: Canisius is a place where diverse students, athletes, and faculty form to build community. Canisius is one community and recognizes individual talent and celebrates the individual.... Read 113 reviews

• grade A

• Students 830

• Student-teacher ratio 12:1

• Elmhurst, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.4 out of 5  52 reviews

Junior: This high school was not like any other. With only having a 100 and more students, this had helped the school have a close-knit community, and had strengthened brotherhood in the school. In my experience, learning had been more enjoyable and had helped me learn more than when I was in my freshman and sophomore years in a big public school. The teachers had been really good and are very supportive to us students. Overall a great school for students who would want to practice the christian faith and enjoy learning.... Read 52 reviews

• grade A

• Students 160

• Student-teacher ratio 13:1

• Hempstead, NY•

• Private School•

• 9-12

• •
  Rating 4.06 out of 5  273 reviews

Freshman: I am currently a freshman at Sacred Heart Academy and overall it has been an honor going to this school and being a part of the community. Sacred Heart is an amazing school for girls to challenge themselves hence the fact that it's a college predatory high school. When asked to describe a good school most people say that they have amazing teachers and nice friends but I can say that my school has a curriculum based on teaching us and stimulating our brains to live in the real world. The many subjects introduce us to the diverseness of the world. Alongside education, Sacred Heart is a great place to make friends and socialize while staying on top of school work. We have a large range of sports, clubs, and extracurriculars that are a great way to find friends that you have similarities. Some of the clubs that I am involved with are the Multicultural Club and Women Empowerment. As much as school can be exhausting, we should always remember the great times we've had and are soon to have!... Read 273 reviews

• grade A

• Students 857

• Student-teacher ratio 13:1