Skip to Main Content

2019 Best Catholic High Schools in New YorkAbout this List

The 2019 Best Catholic High Schools ranking is based on rigorous analysis of key statistics and millions of reviews from students and parents. Ranking factors include SAT/ACT scores, the quality of colleges that students consider, student-teacher ratio, Catholic school ratings, and more. Data sourced from the U.S. Department of Education, Niche users, and the schools directly. Read more on how this ranking was calculated.

1 – 25 of 112
Best Schools
112 results

  1. Regis High School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 106
    1 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Parent: Beyond academic rigor, being a Regian is a commitment and continuous giving of one's time, energies and talents to others. My son is regularly exhausted from the workload, obligations and commute, but he is also highly energized and inspired. The teachers are passionate, but my son learns as much from classmates who are accomplished and driven, yet supportive of each other.

    The all-scholarship legacy means true socioeconomic diversity and allows Regis to position itself above the what-can-you-do-for-my-child calculus of expensive private schools.

    Regis has an outsized share of boys receiving various national merit awards and placements into the very top universities. But those are never the explicit goals of the school, or the 'returns expectations' of families. They are just the outcome of 4 sincere years of amazing purposeful Regis experience.
    Read 106 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 529 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  2. Convent of the Sacred Heart

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • PK, K-12
    • 35
    2 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: If I had to start over again, I would choose Sacred Heart without a doubt! The challenging curriculum, the amazing teachers, wide array of extracurriculars have made my high school experience one I will treasure for the rest of my life!
    Read 35 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 710 Students
    • 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  3. Marymount School of New York

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • PK, K-12
    • 25
    3 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Sophomore: I have been at Marymount since kindergarten, but it continues to surprise and challenge me. I'm now a sophomore in the Upper School, and I couldn't enjoy it more. In all my classes, I have the opportunity to ask questions and participate in meaningful discussions with my peers. Even though classes can be stressful at times, my teachers are always willing to meet with me to sort through my confusion. I also enjoy being able to participate in a ton of different clubs that allow me to explore my interests. Finally, I most appreciate being part of such a great community. Not only do many of my closest friends go to Marymount, but our class as a whole is so supportive and lovely. I couldn't ask for a better experience!
    Read 25 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 756 Students
    • 5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  4. Sponsored

    Hoosac School

    • Private School
    • Hoosick, NY
    • 8-12
    • 198

    Parent: We transferred jr year from to Hoosac(specifically for their academic program and school spirit) and they made the transition incredibly smooth & pleasant! My daughter came out of her shell at Hoosac and was filled with school pride for her school.More importantly, I have told many parent since the switch I wish I’d done it earlier because their academic program is unparalleled! They start in Jr High with college prep, SAT’s and preparing our kids to become adults. What a student completes in on year at other high schools, they complete in one semester. That notion scared us at first but, again, the teachers there made it easy for her/us! The teachers, counselors and staff are always caring, accessible and the communication is top notch!
    I am incredibly grateful we made the switch!
    Read 198 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 130 Students
    • 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  5. Loyola School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 10
    4 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: I like the college readiness and preparation. I think the new administration helps a lot with preparing kids for life and educating them, as well as listening to them. Students can make the school difficult to deal with as it is very cliquey. The way Loyola helps you get into college and honestly prepares you, however, is worth it.
    Read 10 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 207 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  6. Fordham Preparatory School

    • Private School
    • Bronx, NY
    • 9-12
    • 171
    5 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: I liked the reputation and overall academic prowess that Fordham Prep has to offer, and I love the widespread influence of the Prep, given that it has students from all across the tri-state area. However, the racial and ethnic diversity is not very strong, and I believe that many of the teachers are not very good, yet the Prep fails to act towards removing them. However, in terms of education, connections, and overall Jesuit foundation, I would say that Fordham is a very great school!
    Read 171 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,000 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  7. School of the Holy Child

    • Private School
    • Rye, NY
    • 5-12
    • 18
    6 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: This school has always been a gem, but now more so than ever!
    The facilities have been improved beyond belief offering all or more than any of the other private schools offer. They give their students an outstanding education and college prep, a confidence in themselves and their abilities, life long friendships and a secure path for their future. They nourish the entire whole student at Holy Child, allowing them to grow and flourish. It was a gift that I received my education there...one that keeps giving!
    Read 18 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 300 Students
    • 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  10. Dominican Academy

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 122
    7 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: This school is a gem! Academic program is rigorous and offers lots of great electives. The faculty are top notch and go the extra mile to ensure their students’ success. It’s amazing that such a small school can offer so much in the way of clubs, sports, and opportunities to their students. Bravo, DA!
    Read 122 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 229 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  11. The Ursuline School

    • Private School
    • New Rochelle, NY
    • 6-12
    • 130
    8 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: Without the Ursuline School, I would not be who I am today! TUS has prepared me for the world by molding me to become a strong independent woman who is not afraid to take risks and to make a voice for myself. Ursuline is an amazing school and I hope to send my daughters here one day because of how much I loved my experience. I came into Ursuline in the sixth grade and never once have I doubted my decision to go to TUS. The faculty and administration are amazing and I wouldn't trade in my seven years at TUS for anything!
    Read 130 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 800 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  12. Iona Preparatory School

    • Private School
    • New Rochelle, NY
    • K-12
    • 91
    9 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: During my time at Iona, I have been involved in athletics heavily. In this time, I have had great experiences from winning championships to building friendships for life. More importantly, Iona has set me up for a great future in terms of academics and college prep. The workload was difficult to adjust to, but I am sure it has prepared me for college. The guidance and support I have received from Iona are second to none. I would not have it any other way. Go Gaels!
    Read 91 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 750 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  14. Xavier High School

    • Private School
    • New York, NY
    • 9-12
    • 117
    10 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: I started Xavier sixty years ago and still consider it the second most important influence in forming my values, after my parents.
    Xavier was demanding academically and brought me into contact with a diverse geographic and cultural classmates. The Jesuits then were tough and rigorous. Some of the lay teachers should have been weeded out.
    I have been in fairly close contact with Xavier over the last fifty plus years and I have witnessed great things happen in the schools continuous growth.
    The Jesuit mantra of “ Becoming A man/woman for others is even more evident today.
    Going to a high school in Manhattan was a huge plus, not having fields nearby was challenge.
    Every January over a thousand alums, from 21 to 95 , get together to renew old friendships, tell exaggerated stories and sing “ Sons of Xavier......an exhilarating experience.
    Read 117 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,090 Students
    • 14:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  15. Canisius High School

    • Private School
    • Buffalo, NY
    • 9-12
    • 89
    11 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: I have never felt unsafe at Canisius. There is very little bullying, and most people are pretty accepting of other economic backgrounds and ethnicities. The workload can be challenging. There is not a lot of time to do homework during the day. The course selection is lacking. The service and retreat programs are life changing, and one of the highlights of Canisius. There are a lot of extracurricular activities and most students are very involved. Although our school has very advanced tech, like iPads and drones, the tech department is very unhelpful. The campus is beautiful. Most of the teachers are fantastic, although there are a few not so great ones. The sports programs are the best in WNY. Even if you are not involved in a sport, you can still have in the Blue Crew. One of the most memorable moments from my time, was going to the CHS Joe's football game. Finally, there is a strong sense of community and brotherhood at Canisius that you won't be able to find anywhere else.
    Read 89 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 830 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  16. Christian Brothers Academy

    • Private School
    • Syracuse, NY
    • 7-12
    • 135
    12 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: My time at CBA was 4 of the best years of my life! The small school setting fosters a great sense of community and everyone there is like-minded in their goals of success. The teachers are second-to-none, especially Dr. Infanti. Guidance counselors are also wonderful for getting students college-ready
    Read 135 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 785 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  19. Chaminade High School

    • Private School
    • Mineola, NY
    • 9-12
    • 189
    13 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Alum: The school is a very good place for learning discipline and becoming a hard-working student. However, the diversity in the school is heavily lacking, with over 90% of the students being white and a majority being conservative. It is apparent that sports were also funded and appreciated significantly more than the arts. Overall, if the diversity of the school, both in thought and in race, were to improve this school would easily earn a 5-star rating.
    Read 189 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,700 Students
    • 25:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  20. McQuaid Jesuit Preparatory School

    • Private School
    • Rochester, NY
    • 6-12
    • 98
    14 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: McQuaid is a fine school in many ways, and questionable in others. The academics are extremely competitive among the students, but the classes themselves are relatively easy. The AP classes are the only ones that are challenging. The teachers are mostly good and helpful, although some are rather poor. Diversity is quite low. There are many clubs for all the members of the school. Safety was upgraded this year, but from the almost non-existent point that it was at. There is a large school culture, with many activities designed to promulgate that culture. The administration is almost universally terrible. They do not support the teachers at all, and most of the time will take the students' side over the teachers'. The sports are pretty good, especially cross country and track. The food is excellent, although it is very overpriced. Resources and facilities are generally good, as is parent involvement.
    Read 98 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 932 Students
    • 12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  21. Saint Anthony's High School

    • Private School
    • Huntington Station, NY
    • 9-12
    • 333
    15 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: St. Anthony's High School has given me the best three years of my life so far. The only thing I dislike about school, is waking up in the morning! The teaching staff are great, except for the math department. St. Anthony's pushes kids and heavily prepares them for college. The subject of college is constantly brought to the kids' attentions. St. Anthony's is also very diverse. Many kids are involved in school activities, like clubs, sports, and fine arts. There is a place for everyone at St. Anthony's. The one thing I would change at St. Anthony's, are the mean librarians. They don't let anyone print out anything, or let kids into the library if they don't have any schoolwork.
    Read 333 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 2,384 Students
    • 18:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  22. Seton Catholic Central High School

    • Private School
    • Binghamton, NY
    • 7-12
    • 29
    16 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Middle School Student: I think Seton Catholic Central is a great school. One of my opinions about it is that it has very good teachers that want you to succeed in life and know what they're doing. They aren't just teaching you the essentials of school education - they teach you to develop as a person, how to be independent, etc. Students at the school make you feel like a family and are very welcoming. The dress code you shouldn't mind in my opinion because you get dress down passes and if you participate in things such as fundraisers, then you could even get to stay out of uniform for a month. There are many extracurricular activities, such as the Ukulele Club, Robotics, Science Olympiad, Math Counts, Smile Club, Key Club, visiting places such as France and Haiti, etc. There are also sports such as lacrosse, soccer, football, baseball, and many others. Note that you also get the option to create your own club with the approval of the principal, who welcomes everyone, Mr. M. Martinkovic.
    Read 29 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 336 Students
    • 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  23. Nardin Academy

    • Private School
    • Buffalo, NY
    • PK, K-12
    • 201
    17 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: My experience at Nardin Academy has been amazing, yet I definitely take on an interesting perspective of the school since I have experienced so many of the changes each year. Nardin is progressing into the future by making the necessary changes with scheduling in order to fit the best needs of the student. It has been long overdue for change, but I am so glad that it’s happening now. The focus has definitely shifted from only teaching by lectures to taking a more wholesome approach in how the student can best benefit and prepare for the future, and my preparation at Nardin has definitely helped me gain the knowledge and confidence needed for college life and the real world.
    Read 201 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 913 Students
    • 10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  26. Sacred Heart Academy

    • Private School
    • Hempstead, NY
    • 9-12
    • 199
    18 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: I'm currently a senior at Sacred Heart Academy. I love the school, the teachers are supportive and the advanced classes that I take are both challenging and fun. I appreciate the atmosphere as an all girls school. Also the food is pretty great! I do wish that the school was larger, instead of just one building (albeit a large one) with several houses and a field.
    Read 199 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 873 Students
    • 14:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  27. Archbishop Molloy High School

    • Private School
    • Briarwood, NY
    • 9-12
    • 381
    19 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: My decision to attend Archbishop Molloy High School is a decision that I will never regret. The atmosphere of the school is fully committed to helping us develop not only as students, but as good people, something that reaches above and beyond what just any high school aims for. Excelling both academically and athletically, “Stanner High” as some refer to it, is a prestigious Catholic High School that does not mandate hours of community service, making it unique and teaching students that service should originate from the desire to help others, not just to fulfill any requirements. Despite this, service volunteer spots are in high demand and fill up quickly. Everyone is always willing to help, whether it be a teacher to a student, student to student, or student to a person outside of the high school community. Most teachers stay afterschool, leaving their classrooms open for helping students. I absolutely love it here!
    Read 381 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,490 Students
    • 19:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  28. Buffalo Academy of the Sacred Heart

    • Private School
    • Buffalo, NY
    • 9-12
    • 149
    20 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: I love the academy so much! It has grown to be my home away from home and will truly miss it once I graduate. The faculty is usually energetic about what they do and love working with the girls. Most of the teachers go out of their way to make sure that you ARE succeeding in their class! There are sooo many incentives that makes the girls grow closer together, that I've made some forever friends here. Not only that, there are endless possibilities for clubs, sports, service, internships, and even traveling that all the girls are open to! The only thing I would say that they are lacking in, is the diversity. While I am happy to say that they've grown, I would like to see MORE progress being made in that aspect. This school challenges, motivates, and is honestly the best thing that has happened to me :) Once you're a SHA girl, you'll always be one!
    Read 149 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 397 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  29. The Montfort Academy

    • Private School
    • Mt. Vernon, NY
    • 7-12
    • 28
    21 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Parent: The teachers are very communicative and truly care about the success of their students. The daily consult period is invaluable, making sure any struggling student gets the extra help needed. Strong community outreach/service program. Sports improve year after year and fosters great school spirit! There are lots of clubs, e.g., and if you have a specific interest, you can suggest starting a club. Very strong administration and faculty. But, it is the students that make the Montfort Academy a welcoming, positive experience in the High School years! That are a wonderful group of young men and women!
    Read 28 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 168 Students
    • 8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  30. Our Lady of Mercy High School

    • Private School
    • Rochester, NY
    • 6-12
    • 139
    22 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: The education I have received at Mercy is above and beyond what i would have expected. The teachers genuinely care about the student beyond just classwork, test scores and the grades they get. They get to know and understand you as a person and so their best to accommodate to an individual's learning style. My favorite classes here are AP Studio Art, AP Literature and AP Biology, mainly because they taught me more than just the content, they taught me about life. I carry lessons from those classes with me now and will through college and beyond. What I'd like to see change is how administration deals with problems within the school. I went through a 6 month long ordeal because my coach displayed inappropriate behavior towards me and other athletes, and it took months of prodding, me leaving the track team, phone calls and an impulsive/unsanctioned letter from my coach in order to solve the problem.
    Read 139 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 776 Students
    • 9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  31. Review Your School

  32. Xaverian High School

    • Private School
    • Brooklyn, NY
    • 6-12
    • 107
    23 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Senior: Xaverian high school has changed my life for the better. It is an amazing institution - but only if you take advantage of all of their opportunities. They provide so much, take all of it! You will meet extraordinary people that will carry you through your lives.
    Read 107 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,100 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  33. Seton Catholic Central

    • Private School
    • Plattsburgh, NY
    • 6-12
    • 27
    24 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Junior: I switched to Seton from a public school half way through high school, unlike the majority who switch in sometime around 7th or 9th grade. However, I was still accepted into the family like environment we call Seton. Class sizes are small, which means more individual attention from teachers and you can easily ask them questions by email. My smallest class is just me, and the teacher and I get along well and the lessons are structured to what I need help on. The food is great, the cafeteria staff goes above and beyond to make sure kids get the food they want (they even custom make students salads if they let them know ahead of time) The facilities are always clean, and there's no bullying that I am aware of.
    Read 27 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 149 Students
    • 7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes

  34. The Mary Louis Academy

    • Private School
    • Jamaica, NY
    • 9-12
    • 273
    25 Best Catholic High Schools in New York

    Freshman: I personally loved my freshmen year at The Mary Louis Academy because of the memories and experience they give you. So they make it worth your money. One great memory I had was spirit night where all the grades would vs each other through dancing, stepping and hallway designs. During the preparations you really see each grade come together as a whole. Also with academics I could not have asked for better teachers this year I was able to get the grades that I worked hard for, for each class. The teachers are always helping students through extra help which is amazing. Throigh great academics this school really prepares you for college and makes sure you have the best of chances to go where you want to go. Overall I wouldn’t change one single thing able The Mary Louis Academy.
    Read 273 Reviews

    • A
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 738 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  35. Sponsored

    Norfolk Academy

    • Private School
    • Norfolk, VA
    • 1-12
    • 128

    Parent: Norfolk Academy provided an extraordinary educational journey for my two children, fueling their curiosity and inspiring them to explore new avenues that they might not have discovered without the incredible teachers and coaches at this school. My oldest child, who came in sixth grade, now studies engineering at an Ivy League university; he particularly loved the robotics team, as well as soccer, swimming, and crew teams. My youngest child, who is a senior at NA, came in first grade, and she has developed a passion for medicine and health, largely through the school's Global Health Fellows program and the Medical Scholars program.
    Read 128 Reviews

    • A+
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 1,203 Students
    • 11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  36. Sponsored

    BASIS Independent McLean

    • Private School
    • McLean, VA
    • PK, K-12
    • 9

    Parent: Our son is currently in the 2nd grade. He has been at the school for two years, and it has been a wonderful experience. The enthusiasm of the teachers, who are truly experts in the subjects they teach, is infectious. They consistently set high standards for all students at every stage of their academic career. This is a school that prioritizes academics and the students themselves; it is targeted to students with intellectual curiosity and a strong work ethic. We are very happy here!
    Read 9 Reviews

    • NG
      Overall Niche Grade
    • 375 Students
    • 6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
    View Nearby Homes
  • 1 of 5