2019 Best Catholic High Schools in America

Best Schools

1,270 results

Regis High School
Private School
New York, NY
9-12
114
#1 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: Beyond academic rigor, being a Regian is a commitment and continuous giving of one's time, energies and talents to others. My son is regularly exhausted from the workload, obligations and commute, but he is also highly energized and inspired. The teachers are passionate, but my son learns as much from classmates who are accomplished and driven, yet supportive of each other.

The all-scholarship legacy means true socioeconomic diversity and allows Regis to position itself above the what-can-you-do-for-my-child calculus of expensive private schools.

Regis has an outsized share of boys receiving various national merit awards and placements into the very top universities. But those are never the explicit goals of the school, or the 'returns expectations' of families. They are just the outcome of 4 sincere years of amazing purposeful Regis experience.
Read 114 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
532 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Delbarton School
Private School
Morristown, NJ
7-12
89
#2 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: Delbarton prepares our boys for life. Delbarton has a reputation of having very smart young men that move on to top universities and go on to successful careers. It is not nepotism. It is not that someone knows someone. It is simply that Delbarton maintains traditional values, accept the best students and teach our boys the value of effort, perseverance and hard work. It is not easy nor should it be. My son plays a sport and is very active in multiple extra-curricular activities but when he comes home after school, he stays focused and spends several hours doing homework, as do his friends. Yes, some of his friends played sports and went on to ivies and top schools. Yes, the sport helps but I think the fact that the boys also took AP courses, maintained top grades and scored 34 on ACT and 1500 on SAT had something to do with their success too. People that say otherwise are trying to justify some shortcomings that they have unfortunately experienced in their own family.
Read 89 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
588 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Woodside Priory School
Private School
Portola Valley, CA
6-12
60
#3 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Alum: I love talking about my time at priory and I spend every summer working on campus at Mountain Camp Woodside.

If you are looking for a small school where you will be known respected and valued; teachers that go out of their way to ensure your success; a strong arts program as well as incredible athletics: Priory is the place for YOU.

Built on the values of Community Individuality Spirituality Integrity & Hospitality, there is support for every student, every interest, and every struggle. Our Monks are the foundation of our community. Their unconditional love and acceptance knows no borders. Their energy motivates every activity. Their patience allows them to listen with the ear of their heart.

Priory prepared me for hard pre-med classes. If you are considering Priory, you are considering an amazing college predatory school, community, and an alma matter you won't regret!

If you don't believe me, watch my video: www.priory48.com/happy

Chris Gregory ‘14
Read 60 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
375 Students
6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Nysmith School for the Gifted
Private School
Herndon, VA
PK, K-8
5
Alum: Our 3 kids attended Nysmith from pre-K to 8th grade and it was the best decision of our lives! They never wanted to miss a day of school, because Nysmith knows how to make learning fun. Our kids went on to a great high school (TJ), that was perfect for their math/science/technology interests, and attended their #1 college choices. They were not only ready academically after Nysmith, but they were also happy and confident. The teachers, who are experts and passionate about the subjects they teach, treated the kids with kindness and respect, welcomed their questions, nurtured their curiosity, and helped my kids discover their gifts and abilities - sometimes before they even knew what they were. I highly recommend Nysmith. Or, better yet, don't listen to me...look at their website, see how their alums are doing, schedule a tour and a couple of student visit days for your child. See for yourselves what Nysmith is all about!
Read 5 Reviews
NG
Overall Niche Grade
580 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Convent of the Sacred Heart
Private School
New York, NY
PK, K-12
38
#4 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: If I had to start over again, I would choose Sacred Heart without a doubt! The challenging curriculum, the amazing teachers, wide array of extracurriculars have made my high school experience one I will treasure for the rest of my life!
Read 38 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
710 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Cistercian Preparatory School
Private School
Irving, TX
5-12
34
#5 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: As a parent of two sons who graduated almost a decade apart, I can say, unequivocally, that Cistercian remains a top-notch academic institution dedicated to its long-standing mission of educating the whole child. My sons -- one driven by academics and the other by athletics -- thrived at the school. Yes, the very environment encourages students to strive for excellence, but the boys are supported as they determine what that means to each of them individually. The classical curriculum can be demanding, but each year prepares the boys for what is to come. The school has been able to maintain a fine balance between remaining firmly rooted in their founding mission and history while implementing progressive educational practices. It’s a beautiful thing to witness young men of character and accomplishment graduating each spring, heading to college well prepared and grounded, and excited for their next steps.
Read 34 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
349 Students
6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Strake Jesuit College Preparatory School
Private School
Houston, TX
9-12
91
#6 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: Strake Jesuit is an amazing school! It has amazing academics. The teachers are always willing to meet with students and they care about your success. The counselors are very good about sending different scholarship opportunities to kids. The sports facilities are amazing too! Strake Jesuit will form your son into a man by the time he graduates and he will be prepared for college.
Read 91 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,151 Students
11:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Marymount School of New York
Private School
New York, NY
PK, K-12
26
#7 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Sophomore: I have been at Marymount since kindergarten, but it continues to surprise and challenge me. I'm now a sophomore in the Upper School, and I couldn't enjoy it more. In all my classes, I have the opportunity to ask questions and participate in meaningful discussions with my peers. Even though classes can be stressful at times, my teachers are always willing to meet with me to sort through my confusion. I also enjoy being able to participate in a ton of different clubs that allow me to explore my interests. Finally, I most appreciate being part of such a great community. Not only do many of my closest friends go to Marymount, but our class as a whole is so supportive and lovely. I couldn't ask for a better experience!
Read 26 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
756 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Saint Louis Priory School
Private School
Saint Louis, MO
7-12
81
#8 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: We can't recommend Priory enough. Though early into his tenure, we'd like to share our thoughts with you as our son is currently a new 7th grader. We were interested in a school that would challenge and bring out the best in our son (he previously attended a challenging Catholic school). The curriculum is rigorous, and our son greatly enjoys all of his classes and teachers. It has been a bit bumpy here and there with grades, but this was expected. Teachers are all available when extra help is needed, but your son must reach out to them and make the time. Is there a fair amount of homework? Yes, but it seems to be pretty evenly balanced across the subjects. Our son is very active in sports, so we've been careful to balance his activities, letting him get accustomed to the new setting and priorities.
Read 81 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
443 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Carrollton School of the Sacred Heart
Private School
Miami, FL
PK, K-12
79
#9 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Sophomore: Carrollton is a school that encompasses various opportunities for students starting from their Montessori years. It is a College Prep school and therefore preps their students for college from the very beginning of Freshman year. Students learn about the college admissions process, the challenges and difficulties of applying to colleges, and how to determine what college is best fit for them. Carrollton is also an all-girls school. The benefit of being a diverse all-girls school is that students have the freedom to speak on various topics regarding race, sex, culture, etc. in an open environment. Along with that, students have a close bond with their class along with different grade levels. Teachers strive to assist their students in any struggle they have. Last but not least, the campus, home to multiple peacocks and a beautiful bayside view, provides students with an atmosphere full of nature and beauty. Overall, Carrollton is a wonderful school!
Read 79 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
847 Students
9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
- 2019 Best All-Boys High Schools
- 2019 Best All-Girls High Schools
- 2019 Best Boarding High Schools
Marymount High School
Private School
Los Angeles, CA
9-12
101
#10 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: Overall, I feel prepared for college. The history department is very well run, while the other departments seem to lack quality faculty in one way or the other. The administration does a good job at running the school and listening to the students. The close-knit campus is something a value, as I know all my teachers and classmates very well. Comparing my experience to that of my mom's, who also went to Marymount, and faculty who have been there at the time, I can say that the school was definitely in better condition 30 some years ago. There are some parts of the school I will miss, like my friends I have made and some of the teachers, but overall I am happy to be graduating and moving on from Marymount.
Read 101 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
396 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sacred Heart Schools Atherton
Private School
ATHERTON, CA
PK, K-12
93
#11 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: I have had the most amazing education at SHS. The teachers teach beyond the book and what is required, which allows me to have a truly well rounded education. In addition, they are extremely supportive and truly want to get to know the students. There are lots of opportunities for students to get involved in pretty much anything, from sports to leadership to arts. Leadership opportunities are structured in a way that is balanced during the school day, so student athletes or performers in the play can still be involved in other clubs. The school has really placed emphasis on student wellness also. And, the community is supportive and fun. I have loved my experience as a gator and will miss it next year!
Read 93 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,180 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Agnes Academy
Private School
HOUSTON, TX
9-12
258
#12 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: St. Agnes really prepared me for college and the college application process. the college counselors are amazing, and for the most part, teachers are as well. The key to learning here is talking to teachers when you need help, even when some seem unapproachable. I promise you, they're really not. As for the administration, they're doing their job but sometimes it feels like micro-managing the students. The food is extremely expensive and not worth it. I recommend just packing your lunch. The facilities are definitely a lot better now with the new building and all of the renovations. Consider going here if you want to get a good education and form great bonds with other strong women!
Read 258 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
921 Students
9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Georgetown Preparatory School
Private School
North Bethesda, MD
9-12
48
#13 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Alum: There are several pros associated with this school: instilling a sense of purpose and becoming "Men for Others," is of utmost importance. Students are academically challenged from the start. The campus is incredible, facilities immaculate, and the history of the school is incredibly rich. I also really enjoyed the religious element; I most enjoyed "World Religions," where I learned about inclusivity and open-mindedness through carefully studying and understanding other religious systems and beliefs. The one negative for me was how conservative and non-diverse the school is; you will experience your fair share of rich kids. Your typical kid at Prep will spout whatever political/religious jargon their well-off parents spewed at home, without thinking about it critically and how policies/actions will affect "normal" people -- which can become quite hypocritical, given the school's motto: "Men for Others." Students of varying income levels and backgrounds need to be better incorporated.
Read 48 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
496 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Brophy College Preparatory High School
Private School
Phoenix, AZ
6-12
130
#14 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Sophomore: Brophy College Preparatory is an amazing school. Full of diversity in fellow classmates and in clubs or activities or sports that one can join. It is a school that wants you to be smart, it wants you to succeed. It the best school you can join if you are looking for rigorous and diverse activities and classes. In simple terms, Brophy has it all. Go Broncos!
Read 130 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,300 Students
14:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Jesuit College Preparatory School of Dallas
Private School
Dallas, TX
9-12
58
#15 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Junior: Words cannot describe how thankful I am for my Jesuit education. The personal, spiritual, and intellectual growth that has been fostered over the past two years has shaped me into the person I am today. Jesuit is unique in its ability to foster a brotherhood between students; my classmates and I have built relationships that I am confident will last a lifetime. Even with a maxed schedule, I look forward to going to school every day. The academics are as difficult as you choose them to be, but the administration does a great job allowing the student to try new things and challenge themselves academically. Jesuit offers so many extracurriculars, and if you want to pursue something beyond what Jesuit offers, they encourage students to start clubs based on their interests. I could go on for days, but I honestly couldn't be happier with where I go to school.
Read 58 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,108 Students
8:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Mayfield Senior School
Private School
Pasadena, CA
9-12
97
#16 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: Mayfield is a wonderful school! Mayfield not only provides a wide range of athletics and conservatories, but also provides opportunities for service and courses that prepare you for the future. The faculty and staff treat the students and parents with care, as if they are family. Safety is not an issue at Mayfield, for there is a security guard at the gate who takes his/her job seriously and works to help keep the campus safe. Teachers make themselves available for students who need extra help, but there are also peer tutors. The college counselors are always around to lend a helping hand, wether it be teaching you how to properly mail a letter, give you a "pep talk", how to apply for scholarships, and much more! Mayfield provides many resources for help if one seeks them. The sense of community is outstanding and everyone looks out for each other constantly. Mayfield is a place of opportunity.
Read 97 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
333 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Louis University High School
Private School
St. Louis, MO
9-12
169
#17 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Alum: Each class is filled with a diverse group of unique students driven by their interests, creating a real brotherhood. The campus, from the classrooms to the environment surrounding it, is constantly maintained and improved upon. Additionally, a growing focus on creating a sustainable campus distinguishes itself from other schools. As a student, I benefitted greatly from the studio arts department which pushed me to grow as an artist and not only a student. The engaging atmosphere it creates serves as a great break from typical classes.
Read 169 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
980 Students
10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Notre Dame High School
Private School
San Jose, CA
9-12
209
#18 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Junior: So welcoming and passionate. Amazing, tight-knit community that is incredibly nerdy and fun. There's something for just about anyone here - with so many clubs and extracurriculars. Come here if you want to work hard, make friends, and grow your interests - that's how you'll get the most out of it!
Read 209 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
646 Students
10:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Francis High School
Private School
Mountain View, CA
9-12
242
#19 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Alum: Saint Francis overall was a great place to go to high school. The facilities were amazing, the teachers were great (mostly), and as a current college student, I feel so prepared to tackle university courses and exams. I was a participant in the theater program at Saint Francis, and (for the most part), I had a great experience. As a non Catholic at a Catholic school, I felt that the religion classes gave me another perspective in which I view the world. I had a wonderful time at Saint Francis, and I believe that my high school education is the main reason why I am thriving at NYU. Thank you Saint Francis!
Read 242 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,755 Students
16:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Ignatius College Preparatory School
Private School
Chicago, IL
9-12
317
#20 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Niche User: Best school ever! They have everything you could possible want in a high school! Most schools say they have things and at the surface it may look like they do but really don't. All you need to do is spend time at SICP and know what a special place this is. SICP's 150 year history and landmark status has given it credentials no other high school can claim. It has top notch academics, religion, financial aid, counseling, parent involvement, diversity, innovation...you name it they have it.
Read 317 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,404 Students
16:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Loyola High School
Private School
Los Angeles, CA
9-12
174
#21 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: My son just graduated from Loyola. High marks for the school on turning out high-quality young men who care about their friends and communities. The education is rigorous and while not all of my son's teachers would receive an "A," many are outstanding. I felt that the school was behind the times for students with an interest in engineering/technology as the targeted outcome for students seems to be more focused on law, business, finance tracks. Overall, my son enjoyed the experience and feels very prepared for his freshman year at a top college!
Read 174 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,247 Students
14:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Anselm's Abbey School
Private School
Washington, DC
6-12
24
#22 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: Saint Anselm's Abbey School is one of the best things to ever happen to me. The school has an amazing environment that I have not felt outside of St. Anselm's. The faculty love what they do and love to always talk about their respective subjects and offer help to those that need it. The school has a phenomenal community that welcomes in everyone that enters. New students almost immediately become oriented with their new classmates and feel like part of the family the moment they enter the community. The brotherhood at the Abbey cannot be duplicated in high school. Everyone loves each other and seeks the best in each other. There is no bullying or issues like that at our school, there are no cliques or anything of the sort at our school. The sports programs welcome anyone to join, we do not recruit so all of our athletes come from within our walls. I love this school and I encourage anyone looking for a school please consider the Abbey.
Read 24 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
257 Students
5:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Review Your School
St. Sebastian's School
Private School
Needham, MA
7-12
34
#23 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Senior: St. Sebastian’s developed me in to a better student, and man. With a big focus on public speaking, St. Sebastian’s really worked with me to develop my writing skills. The teachers are eager to see their students succeed both inside and outside of the classroom. Built on a strong athletic reputation, St. Sebastian’s teams all compete on a high competitive level. Sportsmanship is heavily influenced. The biggest part about St. Sebastian’s is the community. Everyone is extremely friendly and always willing to help out. Starting from the younger grades up, students support each other both inside the classroom and on the fields.
Read 34 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
375 Students
6:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
The Summit Country Day School
Private School
Cincinnati, OH
PK, K-12
88
#24 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: The Summit is tops! We put all three of our boys through the school, and I’m certain that it was the best choice that we/they could have made. The academic preparation was exceptional, and our boys developed close relationships with several faculty members. Their athletic experiences were outstanding as well. Each boy played multiple sports all the way through, and they were blessed to play for great coaches who made character their primary focus. As a launching-off point for college and life, The Summit provided everything we could have hoped for.
Read 88 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,019 Students
7:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
St. Xavier High School
Private School
Cincinnati, OH
9-12
140
#25 Best Catholic High Schools in America
Parent: We currently have two boys at St. X. At St X it’s cool to be smart! And the boys encourage each other to do better and be the best they can be. There are also numerous opportunities for the boys to get involved, from Top Ranked Sports, Clubs, Community Volunteerism and school involvement. St. X seeks to develop the entire person.
Read 140 Reviews
A+
Overall Niche Grade
1,514 Students
12:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Whittle School & Studios
Opening September 2019, Private School
Washington, DC
PK, K-10
NG
Overall Niche Grade
— Students
— Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes
Sponsored
Our Lady of Mercy School
Private School
Potomac, MD
PK, K-8
2
Middle School Student: It’s really inclusive and allows for growth if you need it and they can work with you if you don’t understand the material
Read 2 Reviews
NG
Overall Niche Grade
226 Students
9:1 Student-Teacher Ratio
View Nearby Homes

1 of 51

Regis High School

Delbarton School

Woodside Priory School

Nysmith School for the Gifted

Convent of the Sacred Heart

Cistercian Preparatory School

Strake Jesuit College Preparatory School

Marymount School of New York

Saint Louis Priory School

Carrollton School of the Sacred Heart

Marymount High School

Sacred Heart Schools Atherton

St. Agnes Academy

Georgetown Preparatory School

Brophy College Preparatory High School

Jesuit College Preparatory School of Dallas

Mayfield Senior School

St. Louis University High School

Notre Dame High School

St. Francis High School

St. Ignatius College Preparatory School

Loyola High School

St. Anselm's Abbey School

St. Sebastian's School

The Summit Country Day School

St. Xavier High School

Whittle School & Studios

Our Lady of Mercy School