I live in one of the oldest dorms, Aagard, which is an all-girls dorm, but I still love it. Because our dorm is so old, we don't have air conditioning, and there are days that the hot water (and the radiators) go out, but we all still love our building, and I wouldn't want to move to a different one. Aagard has character, and our common "suffering" brings us together as a dorm. Aagard is a bit quieter than some of the other dorms, I've heard, but as an introvert, I appreciate that. There are still fun things going on, though, and always doors open if you want to chat with people. We have a great laundry room, and hangout areas on every floor. Lots of places if you want to watch a movie with friends or do homework.
We also have a great relationship with our brother dorm, Farrar, and are very very close to the dining hall - perk!